It's not just a phone, it's used for browsing the Internet, watching movies and playing games all of which would benifit from a larger screen. I was hoping for a larger, higher resolution screen in a similar sized package not an inscrease in the dimensions.
Apple may be innovative but they don't make screens inhouse, so forget any edge-to-edge screen iPhones in the foreseeable future. They can't make the screen wider without making the casing wider. Right, it's not merely a phone, but it
is a phone and this dictates the form factor. They can't make phones that only NBA players can hold comfortably, it has to work for 7-year old pygmy girls as well.
As for making the screen taller, the top houses a speaker, the headphone jack, the SIM card slot, the camera and soon also a front-facing camera. The bottom, apart from having a home button also houses a mic, a speaker and a 30-pin connector, none of which will fit under the screen without making the phone thicker, and Steve would rather die than release a product that's thicker than its predecessor, never mind the fact that fanbois would kill him over this if he doesn't kill himself first -- they're already sobbing uncontrollably over the seams and screws.
I'm hard to please so I usually understand when others are disappointed, but not when they're irrationally disappointed over Apple being unable to bend the laws of physics.
So Apple gives us a curvy iPhone 3G that feels great in your hand. Now the next one will be flat? What are they gonna tell us?
Probably the same thing they told us when they replaced the Mighty Mouse with one that has sharp edges and looks like Oprah sat on it:
Nothing. Fans will instinctively rationalize the design changes, and then they'll explain to you why a flat phone is more ergonomic than a curved one. Apple could remove the stands on their monitors and the space key on their keyboards, and all their evangelists out there would still be able to tell you why this makes perfect sense.