clayjohanson said:There are other examples in the show of characters "wishing" for something to happen shortly before it happens: Walt always rolls the dice that he needs when playing backgammon, Walt wants it to stop raining (so his dad Michael can go look for the dog) and it stops raining, Locke predicts that it's about to START raining and it does, etc. There's a theory that something on the island is manifesting the hopes, fears, etc. of those on the island.
I'm glad you pointed this out. People seem to be forgetting something Locke said to Charlie when they were digging through the wreckage in one episode where Charlie wanted his guitar.
Locke said something along the lines that you have to give (or maybe it was ask for) something to the island for something in return. Later, Locke points up to find Charlie's guitar stuck in the canopy of the forest.
So we have an island inhabited by insane/religious humans and some sort of crazy monster or alien, but it somehow gives you things.