Macbook Air 2012 - LG vs Samsung LCD

[bp1000]

Not sure if the osx daily post was referring to a thread I started last year but here it is https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1195561/

It contains profiles to improve calibration

I suggest calibrating your own screen too

 

[Jobsian]

The profile I created for my display is attached here:
https://forums.macrumors.com/posts/15106385/

My panel is the AUO (11") also. All panels are different though, so I cannot promise that your display will look correct with it. It is definitely worth a try though.

Much appreciated, have you noticed any difference between your panel and the other 2?

 

[mcbiz]

Any problems with uneven backlighting on either the LG or Samsung displays on the 2012 models?

got the LG panel in my new 13inch...my last air had samsung, definitely noticing a difference. When the screen goes completely black, I can notice an uneven distribution of light around the bezel. Colors are definitely a bit washed out, and the difference between brightness levels is more intense (I used to feel comfortable using the screen at about 70 to 80% brightness, but now feel it's too dark to go below 90% in most scenarios...

going to call apple tonight and see what my options are.

 

[mattopotamus]

got the LG panel in my new 13inch...my last air had samsung, definitely noticing a difference. When the screen goes completely black, I can notice an uneven distribution of light around the bezel. Colors are definitely a bit washed out, and the difference between brightness levels is more intense (I used to feel comfortable using the screen at about 70 to 80% brightness, but now feel it's too dark to go below 90% in most scenarios...

going to call apple tonight and see what my options are.

the only options are to use a color profile or return and hope to get lucky. If you return in store and buy in store, i suggest setting it up while you are in the store so you can verify the screen before leaving.

 

[darthpotato94]

From this thread, all the 11" owners except for one got the LG display. One person went into the stores and checked the four 11" models they had on display and three of them had LG displays. It seems that you're likely to get an LG display with the 11", but you could end up with a Samsung. The 13" seems to be more of a "mixed bag."

I have the LG on my 11", and honestly, using the MacRumors ICC profile I'm finding the screen to be quite pleasurable. I didn't previously own an MBA so I can't comment on the differences since I haven't compared to a Samsung screen, but I'm definitely pleased and don't have any desire or intention of exchanging and taking my chances getting something worse (I have the Samsung SSD right now and my MBA is flawless - don't want to risk getting the Toshiba or one with some other imperfection).

I have the 13" with a Samsung display and a Toshiba SSD.

I read that they was a slight difference between the Samsung and Toshiba SSD, however, I don't know if there is any in the 2012 models.

My MBA performs very well except for the system freezes/crashes and 2 kernel panics from using chrome. I don't know if that is a hardware or software issue but is it worth returning and hoping to get a samsung ssd?

 

[slumpey326]

I have the 13" with a Samsung display and a Toshiba SSD.

I read that they was a slight difference between the Samsung and Toshiba SSD, however, I don't know if there is any in the 2012 models.

My MBA performs very well except for the system freezes/crashes and 2 kernel panics from using chrome. I don't know if that is a hardware or software issue but is it worth returning and hoping to get a samsung ssd?

I have both the samsung display and samsung ssd. Everything is great except for the stupid crashes on occasion as a result of Chrome. Please for the love of god can google or apple please fix this.

 

[KPOM]

I have both the samsung display and samsung ssd. Everything is great except for the stupid crashes on occasion as a result of Chrome. Please for the love of god can google or apple please fix this.

Does Chrome Canary give you the same issues?

 

[slumpey326]

Does Chrome Canary give you the same issues?

when I tried canary it was taking a long time to load some websites up including some of its own, i.e. gmail.

 

[Zeni Xeni]

Just received my 13"/i5/8/128 Air today. Short end of both sticks with the Toshiba SSD and LG panel. Contrast is looking better with that custom ICC. I can live with this.

 

[theSeb]

You guys are so silly. Even among a single panel brand there will be variation. They take commodity panels and implement them into a final design. This includes additional circuitry, backlight (sometimes edgelight), etc. The profile thing is also a somewhat odd way of addressing this. A profile describes physical hardware behavior. They use generic ones. To a degree you're just lying to the framebuffer to adjust the final behavior.

Please don't pollute this good, old Macrumors paranoia thread with your facts, logic and sense.

 

[mcbiz]

I have the 13" with a Samsung display and a Toshiba SSD.

I read that they was a slight difference between the Samsung and Toshiba SSD, however, I don't know if there is any in the 2012 models.

My MBA performs very well except for the system freezes/crashes and 2 kernel panics from using chrome. I don't know if that is a hardware or software issue but is it worth returning and hoping to get a samsung ssd?

you are not alone with the chrome kernel panic, experienced it for the first time today.

 

[halledise]

oh boy.. here we go again

true enough.

for the exercise I did the Terminal thingy and my new 13" Air has an LG display.
love it - Life's Good.
Apple know what they're doing …
my LG lcd television is a cracker, and so is my Samsung colour laser printer.
OP needs to get out more

 

[RocketRed]

true enough.

OP needs to get out more

Anybody wanna place a bet? There's going to be the exact same topic next summer when the Haswell MBA's come out.

... Unless Apple sticks to one type of screen instead of 2.

 

[Hichisky]

Much appreciated, have you noticed any difference between your panel and the other 2?

I haven't yet compared them. I am wanting to though. I imagine it is at least on par with the LG.

 

[thekev]

Please don't pollute this good, old Macrumors paranoia thread with your facts, logic and sense.

You know.. I stole one of your lines as it was possibly the only amusing car reference ever posted on here. It involved the scenario of buying a set of pirelli tires from a porsche dealer rather than a tire shop.

 

[Skoopman]

Anybody wanna place a bet? There's going to be the exact same topic next summer when the Haswell MBA's come out.

... Unless Apple sticks to one type of screen instead of 2.

I bet Apple will use Sharp displays next summer

 

[RocketRed]

I bet Apple will use Sharp displays next summer

I've owned Japanese phones with Sharp displays in them (as the phone themselves were by Sharp).

My Body is Ready.

 

[Skoopman]

I've owned Japanese phones with Sharp displays in them (as the phone themselves were by Sharp).

My Body is Ready.

Let's just hope the IGZO displays are ready too.

 

[theSeb]

You know.. I stole one of your lines as it was possibly the only amusing car reference ever posted on here. It involved the scenario of buying a set of pirelli tires from a porsche dealer rather than a tire shop.

That's ok - the first couple are free, until you're hooked.

 

[halledise]

okay - seeing as we're going waaay off topic, consider this …


http://youtu.be/5Ana9w3uSNA

 

[DaDalle]

Damn it, I both have the Toshiba SSD and the LG Display. Bad draw...

 

[kylera]

On another forum here in Korea, MBA users actually prefer the LG display over Samsung...so the gold combo is LG LCD, Samsung SSD.

 

[iKnowMr.Jobs]

How about that, my BTO 13 inch (8gb ram) has a samsung display. I could sorta tell the second the desktop launched the first time.

 

[alias99]

Sorry, the link is broken. I went ahead and zipped it up.

1. I was regretting reading this thread whilst waiting for a new 2012 13 MBA because I don't know what ill get

2. I have had a 2010 MBA for a while and always thought the display seemed odd but didn't take to much notice and got used to it.

3. I just found out I have an LG screen.

4. Used your profile and was shocked at the difference! Wish I found it 2 years ago! Will be using this on my new machine incase of another LG screen. Thanks!

 

[Mac-86]

I got a 2011 11" 1.6 i5/128GB(Toshiba)/4GB with Samsung panel and a 2012 11" 2.0 i7/256GB(Samsung)/8GB with LG. I can totally tell the differences right from initial boot. The one with LG is flat out white/bright and the color is less crisps as compared to the one with samsung.

I picked up the ready stock 2012 11" model at apple store.