May I ask you why do you stick with Sonoma? I also have the exact model as you (iMac17,1) + MacPro6,1, and I didn’t find any significant problems with Sequoia. What are the pros of having Sonoma rn? Except 4k on YouTube with Safari.
Well there were a couple of main things:
1. The messages app (even with a clean install) would randomly freeze / become sluggish on certain messages. It would also have little graphics glitches in the text input field.
2. Apple is just making changes to the way the OS functions, that I don't need, or like in my particular setup, and many of the features I would want to at least test. Don't even work without a T2, or Apple Silicon.
3. Sonoma in my setup just feels smoother, and better polished, even for an unsupported OS.
4. I would have stuck with Monterey, as it still works for what I need, and I have Firefox, and Chrome support, as I have never been a Safari user. It, always had issues with sites I used, when it first came out, so I had to switch to another browser anyway, and I got used to the other two, plus they aren't limited to Apple's platform, and I don't want to be either. With this said, I have older software that's happier under Monterey, and older, even though it does run on current versions of macOS.
5. I would prefer to switch to Linux, but because of my visual impairment, having text message forwarding available helps, and it's one of the only reasons I still need a Mac at this point, or at least use one. Besides that it's just a matter of finding software replacements in the open source community. It's just a combination of specific details in my case that most people don't have to deal with, or it's not what they use a computer for that makes my setup specific. One other thing is, After trying, and using Sonoma as my daily driver for almost a month now, It's nice to have the few app updates I get, but seriously, talking from a daily driver, and a computer as a tool, and not a toy prospective, modern macOS doesn't really give me anything over the old stuff. All the new features Apple is adding are useless to me, and things I don't need, or want. In terms of security, the main things that really matter in my case, are an up to date browser, and email client. (for the time being)
Edit: Bottom line, I need stable over bleeding edge.