Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
The first post of this thread is a WikiPost and can be edited by anyone with the appropiate permissions. Your edits will be public.
I was around when the entire Interwebs correctly decided that incremental updates were the way to go. Looks like Apple did not get the memo.NO ONE wants this. This is 100% UNNECESSARY. Confusing, polarizing. In plain English, it is stupid.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: fisherking
1751902898508.png


Preview: when clicking on "Inspector", instead of a small floating window now there is a sidebar.

In addendum, I still think those scrollbars are ugly and do not fit this aesthetic.
 
Last edited:
TextEdit: new font picker in plaintext mode.

(Also a bug is obvious - when font picker is in focus, TextEdit should be out of focus, but there is 0 indication that it is. Even window buttons are still colored.)

1751908136430.png



Edit: the new font picker appears to be system wide, I encountered it in Terminal as well.
 
Last edited:
View attachment 2526593

Preview: when clicking on "Inspector", instead of a small floating window now there is a sidebar.

In addendum, I still think those scrollbars are ugly and do not fit this aesthetic.
Jesus christ, this looks god awful. Don't they want CONTENT to shine and UI to get out of the way? lol this is the opposite of that. A bunch of ugly floating icons with shadows covering up the content and wasted space everywhere and ugly scrollbars. Yikes.
 
Jesus christ, this looks god awful. Don't they want CONTENT to shine and UI to get out of the way? lol this is the opposite of that. A bunch of ugly floating icons with shadows covering up the content and wasted space everywhere and ugly scrollbars. Yikes.
You are correct. This is a train wreck of epic proportions. Damn near unusable.
 
View attachment 2526593

Preview: when clicking on "Inspector", instead of a small floating window now there is a sidebar.

In addendum, I still think those scrollbars are ugly and do not fit this aesthetic.

Oof, this feels so clunky. The oversized corner radius looks bad, especially when you place a scrollbar up to it. I've always associated Apple with slick, precise detail, but Tahoe's sloppiness is effectively removing that impression. 🫤

This pains me... 😄
1751965195386.png
 
The Applications tab in Spotlight (a.k.a the 'Apps' app) has been modified so that the categories scroll along the top alongside suggestions.

Below that the apps appear to be listed in alphabetical order.

Screenshot 2025-07-08 at 10.14.06.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: StellarVixen
I hate it with passion. I already felt the bigger corner radius of macOS Big Sur was bad enough compared to Catalina and before. But it’s nothing compared to what Tahoe introduces.
To me it looks uncomfortable at that size - I'm sure it probably works ok in some places, but in the main (especially for non-touchscreen macOS) I think it's too much. The window loses its neatness. I'm running Sequoia which I don't really have any issues with, but will wait and see what the public release of Tahoe ends up like. At the moment I still need a fair bit of convincing for me to want to update.
 
There are just so many places where the increased corner radius looks bad when other window elements are in close proximity. It also needlessly takes away space from content. It needs a lot of work before GM. Maybe something gets introduced so it actually makes sense on macOS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr.Ben
Oof, this feels so clunky. The oversized corner radius looks bad, especially when you place a scrollbar up to it. I've always associated Apple with slick, precise detail, but Tahoe's sloppiness is effectively removing that impression. 🫤

This pains me... 😄
View attachment 2526909
The more you look at little details of this most basic app, the funnier it gets. Feels like Apple only redesigned button element, select-element just got low contrast colors, and of course this text alignement is epic. So consistent.
Screenshot_2025-07-08-21-14-43-011-edit_org.thunderdog.challegram.jpg


I also don't understand why they made these floating panels with corners if they're trying to make the corner invisible in the Settings app. Maybe they still can't figure out how to remove this background filling rect on the left side?
IMG_20250709_082130.png
 
IMO the focus of the "Liquid Glass" aspect of the interface is all wrong. Apple should have given the smaller interface elements a glassy look such as traffic light buttons, progress bars, scroll bars, checkboxen, etc. similar how things were when we still had Aqua. That worked brilliantly. Now the focus lies on the larger interface elements actually holding content such as toolbars, windows, floating elements etc. while keeping the smaller elements largely flat. I mean they could have gone all out with the liquid glass effect when they limit it to the smaller elements without creating too many issues. Now it's just overkill instead of nuanced and they end up toning everything down to the point there's not much left of "Liquid Glass".
 
Last edited:
The more you look at little details of this most basic app, the funnier it gets. Feels like Apple only redesigned button element, select-element just got low contrast colors, and of course this text alignement is epic. So consistent.
View attachment 2527250

I also don't understand why they made these floating panels with corners if they're trying to make the corner invisible in the Settings app. Maybe they still can't figure out how to remove this background filling rect on the left side?
View attachment 2527251
I agree, that separator line should go away entirely.
 
I think what everyone is saying is that the whole "glass" thing is completely 100% unnecessary, poorly conceived and implemented. A waste of time and effort. And horrendous from a UX/UI point of view. Did I get that right?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.