Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
The first post of this thread is a WikiPost and can be edited by anyone with the appropiate permissions. Your edits will be public.
They just look like eggs ovals from the distance. I observed that too when I tried to redo some liquid-glass-buttons on one of my HTML projects (I never will run of ideas as long as Apple brings me new). My solution was to put an angle onto the highlighting, as well as balance the brightness and darkness of the borders. A shadow (even barely visible) makes the element look more circular aswell. If you look closely, you'll see that the yellow button in the post above has a yellow halo that might try to do the same.
Yeah, you're rediscovering a lot of the same ideas they already used in retro Aqua. Light angled from the top to form a glossy reflection which visually reinforces the idea of a sphere, and extensive use of drop shadows to show depth which wasn't nearly as common for interfaces of that era as it became later. For early OS X traffic lights they used harsh outer drop shadows, then in Panther switched to more subtle inner shadows (what is pictured here) so the buttons look recessed into the window. Always thought that was a cool look.

TigerDesk.png


edit: Side note, years ago I tried to create an Aqua styled button from OS X Mavericks using HTML/CSS and got very close, I'll have to see if I can find that. I also tried to recreate one of the newer flat gradient buttons introduced in Yosemite. You can guess which one took more time...
 
Last edited:
I think in the macOS of old (pre Tahoe) it was much easier to quickly locate an important and/or often used function because it usually had a glyph while others that weren't important/often used did not. In Tahoe, everything has glyphs so nothing is important/most used. I hear they balanced it back out in GG (haven't used it myself yet). Though, I agree with options.

Ideally, there are 3 options:
  1. All On
  2. Important/Often Used Only
  3. All Off
Cannot agree more. Thank you!
 
Yeah, you're rediscovering a lot of the same ideas they already used in retro Aqua. Light angled from the top to form a glossy reflection which visually reinforces the idea of a sphere, and extensive use of drop shadows to show depth which wasn't nearly as common for interfaces of that era as it became later. For early OS X traffic lights they used harsh outer drop shadows, then in Panther switched to more subtle inner shadows (what is pictured here) so the buttons look recessed into the window. Always thought that was a cool look.

TigerDesk.png


edit: Side note, years ago I tried to create an Aqua styled button from OS X Mavericks using HTML/CSS and got very close, I'll have to see if I can find that. I also tried to recreate one of the newer flat gradient buttons introduced in Yosemite. You can guess which one took more time...
First thing I always did on a fresh installation was install the Aqua Extreme theme though. It gave a much more refined Aqua experience than Mac OS X Panther - Leopard offered out of the box IMO.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.