Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
If attachments and formatting weren't so troublesome, I would use Mail.

I'm glad they're ditching the plug-ins though---nothing but bad experiences with them when I used to use Mail.
 
Previously, mail bundles would break between point releases. Not major releases, mere patches. Every time Mail.app got updated, these bundles needed to get updated, too, and, until they did, the bundles wouldn’t work.
99% of this was not due to anything actually breaking but because of Apple’s policy of forcibly disabling any bundles that were older than the patch release on the assumption that they might have broken.
 
99% of this was not due to anything actually breaking but because of Apple’s policy of forcibly disabling any bundles that were older than the patch release on the assumption that they might have broken.
how do you know this?
 
how do you know this?
I’ve been developing a Mail plug-in for 16 years, have talked with other plug-in developers, and have seen how things worked before and after Apple introduced the compatibility UUID policy. There were also some popular utilities for updating the UUID of an old/abandoned plug-in to trick Mail into thinking they had been tested on the new release, and while I don’t recommend doing that my impression was that users generally saw good results.
 
Just hope by now apple would fixed up the columns in Apple mail. Even i had issues over that, and despite installing Catalina, still do to this day
 
  • Like
Reactions: transpo1 and xmach
It will be. SmallCubed expects to have a beta available for the public beta of Monterey in Early July.
That’s great news. Have they announced this publicly?
I also wonder how Neil Jhaveri, the developer of Mimestream, will react to this.
 
They really need to overhaul Mail with Pro level workflows and features.
unfortunately Apple may especially reluctant to do this given the antitrust/competition-law scrutiny of late (regardless of the merits of that).

There may be some hope regarding the MailKit API that Apple is introducing in the forthcoming macOS Monterey. For developers, Apple describes MailKit as "the best way to build amazing experiences on top of Mail." However the scope of Mailkit seems somewhat limited, at least in this initial iteration.
 
  • Like
Reactions: transpo1
Seems to me hey.com rewrote the book on email and Apple's Mail.app to still to answer that. Maybe MailKit extensions can close that gap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xmach
Does macOS Monterey's Mail app support non-inline attachments? And if not, would the API allow someone to implement that functionality into the app? Forced inline attachments is the only thing holding me back from using Apple Mail.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TrancyGoose
Slightly separate though maybe related issue: any understanding or speculation why Apple has not implemented tags in Mail.app? Arbitrary tagging was introduced in the Finder way back in MacOS X 10.9 Mavericks (2013). Ever since then an obvious next step would be enabling the same, extremely useful functionality to help manage and organize email.

Gmail added support for arbitrary tagging about a decade ago (a quite excellent, flexible implementation, albeit completely non-standards-based). And just last week Apple announced support for arbitrary tagging in the upcoming macOS 12/iOS 15 versions of Notes and Reminders. But still Apple is apparently holding off on tagging for email — there appears to be no attempts to either work with Google, collaborate with email standards bodies to make this possible, or roll its own, proprietary solution.

* correction: Apple introduced arbitrary tagging into the Finder in 10.9, not 10.7 as I originally thought.
Oh how this makes me crazy... It's such an obvious thing to do. I thought maybe tags were semi-deprecated in Finder since I haven't heard boo about them since, but they show up in iOS Files when using iCloud Drive, so obviously they're still maintained.

I started tagging files for a while, and then realized that I could only tag files and half my life is in my email so what's the point? Email tags are essential. Folders don't cut it. If I have an email from Mary about the budget, do I put it in the Mary folder, or the budget folder? Neither-- I tag it Mary and budget. But I can't...

There used to be a MailTags extension written by a 3rd party that predates Finder tags, but it wasn't compatible with Finder tags when they came out and didn't find a way to become compatible so it wasn't terribly useful.
 
They really need to overhaul Mail with Pro level workflows and features.
Actually, while I prefer a native client myself, increasingly, I suspect most users aren’t even aware that native email clients are even a thing. Most people seem perfectly content to use webmail to access their email. I wonder if that’s why Mail.app doesn’t seem to get a lot of development time at Apple.

Outlook in corporate environments is probably the most popular email client, but even Outlook 365 is a webmail front-end (much to my annoyance as a contractor, the firm I’m contracted to uses desktop Outlook but my employer uses Outlook 365 on the web, and I never remember to check it daily). I haven’t heard much about Thunderbird in years. And those two and Mail.app are really the last of the native email clients I’ve heard much about in years (beyond Spark and a few other power user mobile oriented email clients). Eudora is well and gone, even the version of Eudora that was based on Thunderbird. Opera ditched their email client when they went over to using Blink.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: TrancyGoose
I always had two challenges with Apple Mail:

Windows using customers got my mails in a distorted way.
  • Images were embedded and reduced when they shouldn’t.
  • Fonts were replaced when they shouldn’t.
Airmail does this for me without any hassle.

I hope Apple solved this and I can come back. Airmail is quite buggy in minor areas and not that well designed.
Airmail also seems to be running on their design award from four years ago. I used to love the application, and I'm not saying that I could ever make something close to worthy of such an award, but I think it lost some of its momentum. I was part of a few betas years ago, and they were super-responsive, but I feel like they have, sadly, sort of ghosted on all of us.
 
Are any of the extensions displayed in the demo screenshot actually available?
 
Found this old thread and figured it's worth a bump. Are there any Mail extensions and where do you find them? I have searched via DDG and the App Store.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TrancyGoose
Found this old thread and figured it's worth a bump. Are there any Mail extensions and where do you find them? I have searched via DDG and the App Store.
There is nothing. Mac Mail is literally inferior to third party competitors, even some free ones. No one is going to bother to develop anything, unless they do a complete overhaul of the app!
 
There is nothing. Mac Mail is literally inferior to third party competitors, even some free ones. No one is going to bother to develop anything, unless they do a complete overhaul of the app!
Wow, I don't agree. It's not feature-rich but for basic, smart functionality and its GUI (plus a few easy, breezy yet vital things, like a unified inbox), I really like it.
 
Wow, I don't agree. It's not feature-rich but for basic, smart functionality and its GUI (plus a few easy, breezy yet vital things, like a unified inbox), I really like it.
Everything that Spark has, and does far better. But without stupid inline attachments you don't have a choice about. Without the need to freaking add every single account when you open it on another device. With the conversation view that never works and forgets emails in the chain, that are lost forever. Granted, I would love to use a stock app instead of a third party app, I really would. But it has fundamental flaws and gives little flexibility forcing you to do things their way. I won't even talk about signature creation, that looks and works like something from the 90s, probably hasn't changed since then.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: srbNYC
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.