Well... one thing you can give MJ credit for is that he didn't engage in gratuitous wailing like Mariah Carey, Whitney, Aguilera and others who are more concerned with showing off their vocal licks than with the actual source material. It's clear that he respected Chaplin's original melody and didn't once deviate from it. Generally he kept it simple and on the rare occassion he did add something extra it was done tastefully, like at 3:00 on this song.
Look yes, he was deprived of a childhood, to an extent. Yes, he was probably beat up pretty badly by Joe. But it takes someone with extreme delusions of grandeur to make it the biggest deal in the world ever ever EVER. Nevermind WW2, what about Michael's chiiiiiiiiiiiiiildhood?NO ONE can even begin to image what his life was like, what he went through.
Michael had 8 siblings. They all grew up on the stage, in the same household, with the same parents, and they all got a taste of the same belt. I wouldn't go as far as saying the rest of them turned out "normal" in any conventional sense of the word, but there are some things that can be said about Rebbie, Jackie, Tito, LaToya, Marlon, Jermaine, Randy and Janet:
- They didn't build giant amusement parks for themselves and spend most of their adult lives riding a choo-choo train
- They didn't surround themselves with hundreds of kids daily or consider 12-year olds their bestest buddies
- They didn't whine about their childhood in Every. Single. Interview.
- They didn't sing teardripping songs called "Childhood"
OK, so he was robbed of his childhood. Billions of people are. If you were born in India you started supporting your family by working 12-hour days when you were 9, and your line of work sure doesn't involve singing on the Ed Sullivan show. But, whatever, fine... compensate, Michael, have a bit of delayed childhood when you're an adult. Just make it quick, because, you know, a childhood really isn't that long. You play around with some toy cars and suddenly you have pubic hairs and a deep voice, and bam you're off to high school and emerge an adult. You get about 12-13 years worth of childhood-esque life and that's it. But not Michael Jackson, oh no... his childhood just had to go on and on and on. After 12 years (say, between 18 and 30) of the best childhood in the history of the universe, with his own theme park, all the money and toys in the world and a whole staff cooking and cleaning for him, he was nowhere near done. Nope, still gettin' a piece of that childhood. 20 years of it. No, 30 years. "But Michael... you have kids now, isn't it about damn time you grew up?" "Shut up, can't you see I'm up in my treehouse building Lego?"
At some point you have to take responsibility for your own life and actions and grow up, no matter what you went through as a child. The other 8 Jacksons pulled it off (with a question mark for LaToya whose head isn't screwed on right). Countless other former child stars did too. Brooke Shields started when she was 11 months old, but she wasn't the one in the casket at Staples Center. You can't hold the entire world responsible except Michael himself. Nobody forced him to die from daily injections of an anaesthetic designed for the E.R. He would nag 99 doctors for it until he found the 100th who caved in, and he would take it in spite of the 99 doctors telling him he was an idiot. He didn't take no for an answer because he was Michael Jackson and he knew best. That's not a responsible parent no matter how many of his entourage praise his fatherly qualities.