Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Don't start buying vinyl, as someone who used to have 10K of the things, just don't.
I have a love/hate relationship with my collection. It’s such a nice way to collect and listen to music. But they’re so heavy, fragile and take up so much space. A collection can quickly start to dominate your home and packing/transporting them is the worst part of moving house.

But there are much worse and more senseless things to spend money on, such as endless iterations of devices you don’t need to upgrade 🙂
 
Well I dont know the show (apart from what I have read on various articles on this site) but I am a vinyl fan (basically I never gave up on it even during the unpopular years) and I love great packaging in general and this looks to be very well put together.
 
Start with albums you are already familiar (and in love with) and look on Amazon or even eBay and if you find a good deal for a fave of yours, go for it. I grew up on vinyl (I’m a “first gen” Beatles fan) and it admittedly could just be me, but there is a romance to be enjoyed with vinyl. The large cover art. Placing the record on your turntable. Flipping it over for “side 2”. It’s an interaction that can’t truly be expressed - it has to be experienced.

Buying the deluxe version only to be told on side 2 there is no deluxe version...
 
Coming back? It’s the single largest music format on the planet right now. Here’s a fun visual.

Interesting, but I wonder how this compares to the UK. Although I bought my albums on cassette in the '80s, everyone else I knew bought them on vinyl and then recorded them to cassette for car, Walkman, friends, family etc.

As an aside, recently when driving I saw meters and meters of brown shiny cassette tape blowing around in the wind at the side of the road - that bought back memories of a bygone era!
 
Vinyl will never die, I've seen it outlive many people that predicted its death!

Almost no format or even form of technology ever truly dies. They either move slowly to the fringes of society or become popular with hobbyists and collectors. People still make or buy or collect gramophones.
 
Having something like this back in the days of LOST would have been really cool, especially given the nature of the show and such.
 
Start with albums you are already familiar (and in love with) and look on Amazon or even eBay and if you find a good deal for a fave of yours, go for it. I grew up on vinyl (I’m a “first gen” Beatles fan) and it admittedly could just be me, but there is a romance to be enjoyed with vinyl. The large cover art. Placing the record on your turntable. Flipping it over for “side 2”. It’s an interaction that can’t truly be expressed - it has to be experienced.

Well that's gonna be difficult...

Oof.PNG
 
Interesting, but I wonder how this compares to the UK. Although I bought my albums on cassette in the '80s, everyone else I knew bought them on vinyl and then recorded them to cassette for car, Walkman, friends, family etc.

As an aside, recently when driving I saw meters and meters of brown shiny cassette tape blowing around in the wind at the side of the road - that bought back memories of a bygone era!
Oh that’s super interesting. What was the process for transferring from vinyl to cassette? Takes me back to the days of recording radio broadcasts on a separate cassette player/recorder.

I started consciously building my vinyl collection ~8 hrs ago. One aspect I really enjoy about vinyl, is the process of the music listening experience. The rhythm of that process. There is an intimacy and intent that comes with listening to vinyl that simply does not exist with any other format. For starters, unlike streaming, your options are limited to the vinyl you own. theres a beauty in that limitation that affords a focus that can be a challenge when you can quite literally play almost any song you can imagine. The sifting throughly your collection. The selecting of a specific album that fits that specific moment in time. The time it takes to unpack the record, place it on the platter and drop the needle. The anticipation of those first notes as the pop and crackle of the needle dragging through the magic valley. And then the lost art that is listening to an entire album… There’s nothing quite like it.

I’m not a complete luddite - my music enjoyment is predominantly of the streaming variety. But having the option to sit down and listen to a record is one of my favorite scenarios. Some people belong to book clubs. I have a vinyl night with a couple of others and it’s been such a treat. We take turns playing one side of an album. And the fun that is trying to find a good fit with the six records you traveled can make for some pretty dynamic sessions. Highly recommended.
 
Don't start buying vinyl, as someone who used to have 10K of the things, just don't.

You do you. My 17-year-old started collecting them mostly as art - but instead of amassing 10,000, he's got some built-in self-control due to wall space and funding. I think it's kindof neat. He has albums on his wall that I previewed new on CD at Blockbuster Music 30 years ago... Of course, according to him, his LP of OK Computer is cooler than my Radiohead CD or MP3s, but whatever. :D

I will admit - as others have said, there is something ritualistic and natural-feeling about flipping Rumours over for "side B" - but as a whole cultural experience, I just barely missed out on this growing up.

As far as the merch itself, Severance is probably the best thing I've watched all year - but I just need one cool trinket, not a whole set. Good luck to those who will really go for these.

Oh that’s super interesting. What was the process for transferring from vinyl to cassette? Takes me back to the days of recording radio broadcasts on a separate cassette player/recorder.

I started consciously building my vinyl collection ~8 hrs ago. One aspect I really enjoy about vinyl, is the process of the music listening experience. The rhythm of that process. There is an intimacy and intent that comes with listening to vinyl that simply does not exist with any other format. For starters, unlike streaming, your options are limited to the vinyl you own. theres a beauty in that limitation that affords a focus that can be a challenge when you can quite literally play almost any song you can imagine. The sifting throughly your collection. The selecting of a specific album that fits that specific moment in time. The time it takes to unpack the record, place it on the platter and drop the needle. The anticipation of those first notes as the pop and crackle of the needle dragging through the magic valley. And then the lost art that is listening to an entire album… There’s nothing quite like it.

I’m not a complete luddite - my music enjoyment is predominantly of the streaming variety. But having the option to sit down and listen to a record is one of my favorite scenarios. Some people belong to book clubs. I have a vinyl night with a couple of others and it’s been such a treat. We take turns playing one side of an album. And the fun that is trying to find a good fit with the six records you traveled can make for some pretty dynamic sessions. Highly recommended.
Do you find yourself buying older albums, or newer stuff, or both? Musical taste aside, I wonder if the romance of listening to vinyl is the same for an Interpol album as it might be for something like Abbey Road or Led Zeppelin IV etc...
 
Last edited:
  • Disagree
Reactions: jimthing
You do you. My 17-year-old started collecting them mostly as art - but instead of amassing 10,000, he's got some built-in self-control due to wall space and funding. I think it's kindof neat. He has albums on his wall that I previewed new on CD at Blockbuster Music 30 years ago... Of course, according to him, his LP of OK Computer is cooler than my Radiohead CD or MP3s, but whatever. :D

I will admit - as others have said, there is something ritualistic and natural-feeling about flipping Rumours over for "side B" - but as a whole cultural experience, I just barely missed out on this growing up.

As far as the merch itself, Severance is probably the best thing I've watched all year - but I just need one cool trinket, not a whole set. Good luck to those who will really go for these.


Do you find yourself buying older albums, or newer stuff, or both? Musical taste aside, I wonder if the romance of listening to vinyl is the same for an Interpol album as it might be for something like Abbey Road or Led Zeppelin IV etc...

I started buying DVDs, Blu-ray movies and PS3 games again after so many years. I also buy Xbox Series X games on disc because we can get them usually $10 cheaper than the digital version or even half price after just half a year.

They are not only dirt cheap in shops but there are many titles you can’t buy digitally or stream.

Some movie titles have extra content that the streaming versions don’t have. The director James Gunn has stated that the quality of his movies are better on Blu-ray UHD than any of the streaming services for the most obvious reasons. He has more control over the bit rate when they ship physical discs. Netflix, Apple and Prime get to control the bit rate and encoding of films they stream.

It feels great to handle physical discs. We get off our ass, go to our colorful shelves, pick up a disc, put it in the machine, listen to that satisfying sound of the disc starting up.

All these little movements give us bits of stimulation and exercise that we don’t get if we are just lazily sitting with our laptop and pressing play in an app. Over a whole lifetime a lack of physical movement is unhealthy and we would be forced to compensate for being sedentary in some way. We are physical beings, if we are not interacting with physical objects there are physiological costs.

I mix it up. I enjoy the best of streaming, digital purchases and physical discs. Diversity keeps more people employed. The employees at digital services and the employees who make, design , ship and sell boxed discs.
 
Last edited:
I have a love/hate relationship with my collection. It’s such a nice way to collect and listen to music. But they’re so heavy, fragile and take up so much space. A collection can quickly start to dominate your home and packing/transporting them is the worst part of moving house.

But there are much worse and more senseless things to spend money on, such as endless iterations of devices you don’t need to upgrade 🙂
I agree with nearly every part of this, except the “fragile” thing - maybe the basics of care and handling come as second nature to me after dealing with these for more than 25 years but if you treat these things kindly, they will outlast you. Many of my records have outlasted many previous owners and are now 60-70+ years old, even significantly beyond that age if you’re getting out of the age of vinyl and into shellac…

It really comes down to a lot of common sense things. Keep them clean, meaning don’t deliberately smear your Doritos dust fingers all over the grooves or leave discs laying on the floor. Use good equipment that’s properly setup and properly maintained. Don’t store them in an active volcano. So on and so forth.

We have iPhones that we handle more and subject to many more extremes on a daily basis than any record we only handle for a limited amount of time, from the sleeve to the platter. If you can keep an iPhone in good shape then you can keep a record in good shape.
 
Well for perspective:

To put things into greater perspective, a very small portion of vinyl sales are even tracked. It’s really only major label new releases passing through major distributors. Indie labels and DIY artists basically don’t count toward anything, though they make up a larger portion overall of what is actually being currently produced/sold. And then there’s the entire used market which isn’t tracked at all and is probably healthier and more active than even the new market, at least as far as the real record collectors are concerned. There is a whole world of records out there outside of what you’re going to find at Walmart and Target. It’s not even a drop in the ocean.
 
Great soundtrack and I love seeing vinyl making a comeback in a digital age.
 
I don't really get the audiophile fetish about vinyl that isn't end-to-end analog. If it's recorded and mastered digitally so who cares if the end result involves a needle bouncing over plastic?
I feel the same way. I started buying cassettes in the mid 1970s. So many commercial albums were poorly recorded, though, that I switched to vinyl in the late 1970s. I used to love going to used-record stores; I'd take a chance on almost anything that cost a dollar or two. What I didn't like about vinyl were the pops, ticks, and scratches that inevitably accrued over time. I was thrilled when CDs came out. In the 1980s, I began replacing my favorite LPs with CDs. I eventually sold my collection of over 400 LPs, except for some collectibles or ones that were never released on CD.

I never heard an LP that I thought sounded better than a well-mastered CD of the same recording. Some people claim they can hear the difference. Some consider the pops, ticks, and scratches to be "character." Some like the fact that an LP is a physical object in which they can "see" the music in the grooves. Some like lifting and placing the needle on the LP. Some like the distinction between "side 1" and "side 2," especially when the artist intentionally broke up the music thematically. What I liked best about LPs was the large-format cover art and printed lyrics, although they usually were reproduced in smaller format for CDs. These days, I rarely buy physical media, since almost everything is available on Apple Music, often in remastered format.

As for "Severance," I loved the show, but I can't remember a thing about the soundtrack. Some of my most disappointing used-LP purchases were original movie and TV soundtracks. I'd buy them for the main- and end-title music, and the rest of the music usually was boring to me.

Anyway, of those of you who love vinyl, more power to you; I'm not criticizing. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eddie Beeps
I feel the same way. I started buying cassettes in the mid 1970s. So many commercial albums were poorly recorded, though, that I switched to vinyl in the late 1970s. I used to love going to used-record stores; I'd take a chance on almost anything that cost a dollar or two. What I didn't like about vinyl were the pops, ticks, and scratches that inevitably accrued over time. I was thrilled when CDs came out. In the 1980s, I began replacing my favorite LPs with CDs. I eventually sold my collection of over 400 LPs, except for some collectibles or ones that were never released on CD.

I never heard an LP that I thought sounded better than a well-mastered CD of the same recording. Some people claim they can hear the difference. Some consider the pops, ticks, and scratches to be "character." Some like the fact that an LP is a physical object in which they can "see" the music in the grooves. Some like lifting and placing the needle on the LP. Some like the distinction between "side 1" and "side 2," especially when the artist intentionally broke up the music thematically. What I liked best about LPs was the large-format cover art and printed lyrics, although they usually were reproduced in smaller format for CDs. These days, I rarely buy physical media, since almost everything is available on Apple Music, often in remastered format.

As for "Severance," I loved the show, but I can't remember a thing about the soundtrack. Some of my most disappointing used-LP purchases were original movie and TV soundtracks. I'd buy them for the main- and end-title music, and the rest of the music usually was boring to me.

Anyway, of those of you who love vinyl, more power to you; I'm not criticizing. :)

Some people here will understand why vinyl remained popular and caught on with young consumers.

It was called the Loudness War.


It started in the analog era but grew worse and worse after CDs and digital streaming caught on. And then came super compressed mp3s. Such a bad combo.

If you compare a modern digital track to the early vinyl editions, the vinyl might not have the cleanest sound, but it had the incredible depth, warmth and range. A lot of people are fans of that natural ‘live’ feeling sound. It feels real, uncompressed and raw.

Dolby Atmos and other new audio codecs do attempt to address the problem the Loudness War introduced, but many digital tracks don’t support it or haven’t been remastered to it yet.
 
Some people here will understand why vinyl remained popular and caught on with young consumers.

It was called the Loudness War.


It started in the analog era but grew worse and worse after CDs and digital streaming caught on. And then came super compressed mp3s. Such a bad combo.

If you compare a modern digital track to the early vinyl editions, the vinyl might not have the cleanest sound, but it had the incredible depth, warmth and range. A lot of people are fans of that natural ‘live’ feeling sound. It feels real, uncompressed and raw.
What you’re talking about though is a difference in how the recording is mixed, it has little to do with storage medium. You can have extremely well mixed digital recordings too. The trend to mix badly for increased loudness, and the trend towards digital release formats, just coincided. The solution is not vinyl, the solution is to stop pressuring sound engineers to mix things badly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jimthing
Oh that’s super interesting. What was the process for transferring from vinyl to cassette? Takes me back to the days of recording radio broadcasts on a separate cassette player/recorder.
Back in the old days, many home stereo systems had a turntable and a cassette deck (player/recorder) hooked up to a receiver (combination pre-amp, amplifier, tuner), and the cassette deck was hooked up in such a way that whatever the pre-amp was supplying to the amplifier (for the speakers) was also sent to the cassette deck.

So, it was a simple matter of cueing up a record, putting in a blank tape, dropping the needle on the record and hitting record on the cassette deck. And this was born thousands of mix tapes, one track at a time.
 
So, it was a simple matter of cueing up a record, putting in a blank tape, dropping the needle on the record and hitting record on the cassette deck. And this was born thousands of mix tapes, one track at a time.
We used a reel to reel. Ah those days…. Hours making a mix tapes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CarlJ
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.