Gunna have to say, coming from my glossy 17'' umbp got in july, the glossy is the biggest mistake I've made on any of my laptop purchases. Definitely worth the extra $50 for 17''s. Theres a different vibe I've noticed. Those of the 17'' crowd definitely agree the glossy blows, while those who have to live without the luxury of choice (13/15) have a majority vote of favor for the glossy. Now, it's easy to assume why?
On a semi-lit room, my 17'' still returns reflections that are just god damn annoying. You'd have to adjust ur viewing angles of the tilt and such, and still you can't get it completely off your screen but off to the sides.
Is it completely unusable?? no. But I wouldn't put a lb of flesh on any man who can legitimately believe to say that the glossy screen is fantastic, without doubting his ability to see the obvious reflections unnecessarily and annoyingly polluting his screen.
Do you like having to ignore things on your screen that shouldn't be there on the first place? then go for the glossy. If you've accidentally got the 17'' matte and its still in great shape, lets trade.
pic off web that pretty much shows it. I guess u need to own something thats not a glossy (that actually gives u the option not to) before u can consider yourself able to even believe your own opinion about glossy lol. Hands down though, glossy is beautiful to behold. definitely a design over function choice. And in terms of the color being better, ppl over at the graphics design posts are saying matte has better cfidelity.