Of course they can be reused. You sell them to someone that can use them.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
New 12.9-inch iPad Pro Not Compatible With Older Magic Keyboard
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
You can just sell the keyboard with the iPad.
Scenario 1: Keyboard not compatible
Buyer: Buys 1 iPad and 1 keyboard
You: Sells 1 iPad and 1 keyboard, buys 1 iPad and 1 keyboard
Total: +1 iPad +1 keyboard
Scenario 2: Keyboard is compatible
Buyer: Buys 1 iPad and 1 keyboard from Apple
You: Sells 1 iPad and buys 1 iPad from Apple
Total: +1 iPad +1 keyboard
There is no e-waste in this situation.
One cannot not ignore the opportunities though to complain about each option.
Scenario 1:Waaah, it's not compatible - woe is me!
Scenario 2: Waaah, it doesn't support feature x and iPads are too thin. Woe is me!
At the very least, it’s a heads up to anyone thinking of buying a new 11” iPad Pro that if they buy a magic keyboard this year, that it will not be compatible with the future ones.
His point is it isn't waste as long as someone else using that keyboard.
That customers have to spend more money, doesn't change that fact.
Yes, but then don't bring e-waste into the argument.
If I am responsible for killing 10 million people, don't say my action are bad for global warming, when it fact it would have the opposite effect.
In that case, please have the decency to accuse me of genocide and crimes against humanity.
Like I said. Check the thread in the iPad forums. People are using a case that is even heavier than the difference of the new iPad Pro vs 4th gen and it still works well with the MKB. This would point to it being 2
It will look wonderful when it gets dirty, grimey and starts to peel as they have a habit of doing ☹️They have! It’s available in white
😂
An iPhone battery case isn’t $350. Somehow Apple was able to make this new keyboard work with older iPads yet the couldn’t design the new iPad so it would work with the old keyboard (or future proof the old keyboard to work with a nearly identical future iPad)? It would be one thing if the new keyboard had different functionality like a row of function keys or something. Or if the new iPad was bigger or a different form factor. Or if they let you trade in the old MK for a discount on a new one. But that’s not the case here. The iPad I was planning to replace was the 2018 model. That‘s 3 years old. The MK I just bought last year. How Apple could not have foreseen this is baffling. And if they did but just don’t care that’s worse. And worse for them as if I find out the new iPad won‘t work with the existing MK then I’m not buying the new iPad. So they’re out $1,100. I’m sure I won’t be the only one.
No it doesn’t as the current MK works with older iPad models. The iPad Pro I was planning to replace is the 2018 model. Please explain how Apple engineering/accessories teams were able to make a new MK that supports older iPad Pro models but couldn’t figure out a way for the new iPad Pro to support the older MK, or at the time they were designing the original MK didn’t think to design it so it could support a future iPad Pro. One would assume the iPad Pro they just announced has been in the pipeline for a while.
Why am I not surprised. Anyway, the idea to buy an iPad keyboard was far-fetched. I make do with the ordinary Apple bluetooth kb and a €10 Ikea iPad stand. Compatible with any iPad
I hope you’re right and “not compatible” means “doesn’t recommend” vs “won’t work”. It would be nice if Apple cleared this up. A little birdie could easily tap John Gruber, Rene Ritchie, Jason Snell or Federico Viticci on the shoulder and say here’s the deal with the MK.
Some people would rather the ease of Apple’s trade-in program. It doesn’t exist for the keyboard. Also my iPad is in perfect physical condition but the keyboard is a bit grubby. But I don’t need a new keyboard. Why spend $350 on something that is almost exactly the same as what you have?
You'll be spending $150-$200 on it, depending on how much your old one sells for.
That's what happens when you upgrade due to want instead of need.
Besides, all you had to do was look it the iPad Pro history.
2016 9.7" iPP
2017 10.5" iPP
2018 11" iPP
There was every chance that the 2021 iPP would change more than the minuscule 0.5mm thickness.
Last edited:
It DOES work. With the current iPad.
You're complaining because it won't work with the thicker iPad 12.9.
And why is that? Because the current 12.9 is thinner and Apple precision engineer their devices.
This is nothing more that elitism at work. Sell your iPad AND Magic Keyboard.
When the Series 4 watch came out Juuk discovered Apple had changed the specs by less than 1mm where the band connects to the Watch: this meant Series 3 metal based bands would not fit the series 4 or higher.
Big freaking woop. Live with it.
I can't believe the amazing amounts of crying over this. Utterly speechless.
When I buy an accessory I buy it for the current device; if it fits later models then that's a bonus, but I sure don't expect or demand it.
If you could afford a 12.9 last year with a MK AND you were looking at buying a 12.9 this year AND this issue bothers you then perhaps you shouldn't be buying new top-end tablets every year.
The person you quoted purchased their tablet in 2018 and purchased the MK last year. A 2018 user upgrading to a 2021 revision isn't an "every year" upgrade user and their concerns are valid.
Thickness has nothing to do with this I'm sure. It will come down to magnet placement in the new revision for the 12.9 size. Apple decided to move the magnets. Maybe they had no choice, but it stills comes off as bad form.
There is no reason for the keyboard to not last multiple revisions of the product similar to what has happened on the 11". Apple is also wanting to promote this which is why they made the newly revised MK still compatible with older revisions. They also get that it is ridiculous to expect people to swap these out every revision to some degree. I just don't get why they didn't offer something to deal with the breakage here, but maybe we'll see something once they start allowing orders who knows. Either way, people complaining have a valid complaint.
In an ideal world. Apple should allow a swap to the newer revision at no charge for anyone purchasing the newer IPP. Hopefully we see that happen. Then they can refurbish these and help to align a bit closer with their environmental pledges and customer service. Especially since the keyboard here has zero difference from a user perspective and it will be a real challenge buying the Apple MK from third parties who may not readily disclose the different revisions.
Incorrect. It's everything to do with thickness.
In fact the new keyboard can be used with older iPads.
New 2021 12.9-inch iPad Pro can't use previous Magic Keyboard | AppleInsider
Buyers of the new 2021 12.9-inch iPad Pro will not be able to use the previous model's Magic Keyboard.
Apple has not confirmed why it does or does not work. The thickness is one of the hypothesis from tech places but nothing confirmed from Apple. Someone can try this out. Take the thinner iPad 12.9 and the old keyboard and add 5 pieces of standard 11x8.5 inch papers. What kind of issues would someone see? Does the screen rub against the keyboard with or without the 0.5 mm added?Incorrect. It's everything to do with thickness.
In fact the new keyboard can be used with older iPads.
New 2021 12.9-inch iPad Pro can't use previous Magic Keyboard | AppleInsider
Buyers of the new 2021 12.9-inch iPad Pro will not be able to use the previous model's Magic Keyboard.appleinsider.com
I wasn’t sure about this because I’ve carried additional documents in between my ipad and case before. So I made a 0.5mm plastic insert and added it to the front of my current iPad Pro. Open and Closed it over a dozen times, no issue… The new case might be “incompatible“, But, i don’t see an issue with the thickness… unless the new display is super fragile or something… one thing i did notice: with the insert in and the cover closed, with the keyboard side up the magnets aren’t quite strong enough to hold down the “bulging“ iPad Pro completely; nothing noticable with keyboard side down, no foreseeable damage to the iPad, but it could be seen as an Apple product failure: as the display might stay on if the magnets don’t touch.
Last edited: