Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
New iMac Keyboard Revealed?
- Thread starter mrat93
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Oh God please save me. Why do I have to be an engineer to understand that this keyboard won't work? If a bridge falls then the engineer was an idiot and careless right? The stuff you say about Dashboard and system preferences....? I don't know where you are going there.
Like that ugly one on the F4 key? The Apple logo hasn't confused any one... the key is called the Apple Key right? Maybe that's why there is an Apple on it for the new users. It used to not be there, then they started calling it the Apple key, so I guess they put an Apple on it. Why change what has been there for years. That's would be very Vista-ish.
That's why there was a system update that extended the time needed to press the eject key to eject the CD. And most people can't type anyway, so as I said before P.E.B.K.A.C.
You got that idea from where? Why have a FN key on a desktop keyboard and bunch all the most used keys on one side then have 8 unused programmed keys? Why not just have use change the entire programming ourself through system prefs. The users that want their keyboard to make sense can keep it the same way it has been for years. Not everyone uses spreadsheets.
I was a student of civil engineering for 5 years. Then switched to Video Production/Graphic Design/Photojournalism. Every friend I made in college is still an engineer. I know what engineers do. I will just tell you that your assumption of my "fear of change" is very insulting to me. I will also tell you that your knowledge of an engineer is slightly skewed. Engineers don't analyze or find connections, they solve problems. "Find connections" is a bit ambiguous. Engineers are given a task and they have to solve it within certain boundaries and restraints. This keyboard makes new one and doesn't solve any old problems. It isn't consistent with the companies culture and its not practical.
This is the mocked up keyboard of a designer, since there was nothing wrong with the layout of the keys on the current keyboards, so they changed them for no reason, which is a big mistake in engineering. They don't change the way bridges are made and designed unless they have to.
I attack it because there has been too many bad mockups and this just adds to the list. And people are starting to accept bad design as Apple innovation, like the horrible iMac and iPhone mockups. The design may lead to better usability since a lot of people like the MacBook keys, but the layout is not Apple and will cause more confusion for new and current users of the Mac.
They're convex, not concave. And moon gray sounds just fine to describe them; it must be the color rubber, which may not correspond to other colors.
Nope, Dashboard. Circular dial with a triangle for a need. It's hard to zoom in on that keyboard. However, take this picture below and, if you will, use your imagination to see it as a simple outline/silhouette. Then look back at the keyboard and you'll see it.
What? Windows keyboards have two delete keys; Apple doesn't and AFAIK never has. What's up with that?
I was smart enough not to open this in Word. Not that there's anything in the document to begin with. Bean didn't turn anything up. Nice first post though.
What is in it?
That mockup is exactly what I am talking about. Bad design.
By the way... why did you put the images in Word? Why not.... anything else?
I am glad NeoOffice could open it.
I think anything would be better than the current Apple keyboard, the keys are horribly mushy IMO.
I like the MBP keyboard the best, but the MB keyboard isn't bad (I own a MB).
I didn't bother looking at the photos in detail, but I think this could legitimately be the new keyboard. Notebook-style keys is pretty common now so that's no big revelation. But this keyboard also has some design elements that make it unique.
I like the MBP keyboard the best, but the MB keyboard isn't bad (I own a MB).
I didn't bother looking at the photos in detail, but I think this could legitimately be the new keyboard. Notebook-style keys is pretty common now so that's no big revelation. But this keyboard also has some design elements that make it unique.
I believe the §± is something from the UK keyboards. There are many slight differences here or there between different localizations and languages of keyboards.
Someone tell me this isn't a virus and then I'll look at it.
why not just post the picture? Why is it embedded in a .doc?
Heh nice one.
AbiWord turned up something for me. Looks like every other metal Cinema Display/iMac mockup.
Why did they save it as a word .doc though...
Attachments
This is what I use on my PC at home (which will be sold and replaced by the new iMac):
It is very thin, with small laptop style keys. It is very nice to type on, so I don't understand the 'it's fake because it looks ergonomically horrible to type on' posts.
Oooh purdy. I like it.
I didn't get anything when scanned and opened in Neo Office, but I agree. It is a bit skeptical. Word sucks with graphics.
Very FUGLY
Keyboard: it's terrible, so it's probably real.
I think this keyboard is real. It includes all of Apple's recent keyboard mistakes and compounds them. Only the real thing could be this flawed.
Problems:
The keys don't have enough travel. The keys don't move up and down nearly at all, so they can't give you much feedback, and your fingers hit the end of the key press like a wall. I know it's probably asking too much for Apple to move back to mechanical switches, but this is a step in the wrong direction.
The function keys are too small. A common Apple mistake on recent keyboards. Function keys are far away from the hands' normal position; to hit them with speed and accuracy they should be big targets, ideally separated from the number keys by a space.
There are other problems with the keyboard: it's not ergonomic (the forward tilt is actually worse for ergonomics than a flat keyboard), there are spaces between the keys (try pressing command and option at the same time on a Macbook... it's not easy).
The Macbook keyboard is an OK laptop keyboard. It's better than any iBook keyboard, but that's not saying much. The MB Pro keyboard is much nicer, in my opinion--but even the best laptop keyboard in the world doesn't make a good desktop keyboard. Laptop keyboards are designed around insane space limitations (vertical and horizontal) that don't apply to the desktop. Turning a laptop keyboard into a desktop keyboard is just stupid.
But of course it's not an unlikely Apple move. It's form over function, style over substance, and it won't help any Mac users type any faster. It might give them some wrist and finger pain. But it will sell some computers.
Apple's best keyboard ever, by the way, has been reborn as the Matias Tactile Pro 2. It has function keys in the right place, USB 2.0, and full-action mechanical switch keys. http://matias.ca/tactilepro2/index.php
I think this keyboard is real. It includes all of Apple's recent keyboard mistakes and compounds them. Only the real thing could be this flawed.
Problems:
The keys don't have enough travel. The keys don't move up and down nearly at all, so they can't give you much feedback, and your fingers hit the end of the key press like a wall. I know it's probably asking too much for Apple to move back to mechanical switches, but this is a step in the wrong direction.
The function keys are too small. A common Apple mistake on recent keyboards. Function keys are far away from the hands' normal position; to hit them with speed and accuracy they should be big targets, ideally separated from the number keys by a space.
There are other problems with the keyboard: it's not ergonomic (the forward tilt is actually worse for ergonomics than a flat keyboard), there are spaces between the keys (try pressing command and option at the same time on a Macbook... it's not easy).
The Macbook keyboard is an OK laptop keyboard. It's better than any iBook keyboard, but that's not saying much. The MB Pro keyboard is much nicer, in my opinion--but even the best laptop keyboard in the world doesn't make a good desktop keyboard. Laptop keyboards are designed around insane space limitations (vertical and horizontal) that don't apply to the desktop. Turning a laptop keyboard into a desktop keyboard is just stupid.
But of course it's not an unlikely Apple move. It's form over function, style over substance, and it won't help any Mac users type any faster. It might give them some wrist and finger pain. But it will sell some computers.
Apple's best keyboard ever, by the way, has been reborn as the Matias Tactile Pro 2. It has function keys in the right place, USB 2.0, and full-action mechanical switch keys. http://matias.ca/tactilepro2/index.php
Don't bother. It's just that icky mockup of an ACD monitor with a DVD slot in the side trying to pass as a new iMac.
Actually its quite ergonomic. The key to many of the repetitive strain injuries (Carpal Tunnel) involves improper wrist position (flexed or extended). If the keyboard is somewhat thinner then your wrist will be in a more neutral position. Hopefully it won't take much getting used to though.
Same goes for all these people moaning that this keyboard doesn't curve. Do they not realise that having your hands curved like that is really bad for your hands? The best keyboard position for your hands is actually supposed to be having the keyboard sloping away from you, not sloping up.
I dare not intimate that you're wrong, but I don't think the vast majority of computer users, myself included, are nearly as discerning about their keyboards as you seem to be.
And for my part, I think the MacBook keyboard is one of the most comfortable I've used, laptop or otherwise.
The key word is progress
I like that word. And that explains my dislike of bad engineering....um... I mean mockups.
But I agree with you A LOT! I hated floppies and I celebrated their death.
laugh. i saw. Eidorian was nice enough to post the images on the forum.
did you notice the desktop background? it's that supposed touchscreen iPod fake from ages ago. This is truely a lame fake.