I would love TouchID on all future Apple iOS devices.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
New iPad Air's Touch ID Power Button an 'Incredible Feat of Engineering' According to Apple VP
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
What courageous engineering! I bet it was hard for Apple to figure out how to get the sensor to work against gravity.
Yes that's only the reason I switched back to iPhone 8 Plus from IPhone X
its easy to do the fingerprint on the side, like many androids have done. On the top its hard, because the antenna interfers mainly for cellular iPads. Find me an android where the finger print on the power button is located on the top.
It isn’t just because a fingerprint scanner works on the owner every time that it works, it’s precisely when it doesn’t work all or nearly all of the time with others’ fingers or other tricks that it “just” works. That’s just a question of false positives ratio and using a particular phone won’t tell you anything about it. Perhaps there are some but I don’t know of any website that tests for this.
Have you considered the reason they aren't putting it at the top is because it's just a stupid place to put the reader? If you use the fingerprint reader to unlock your screen, or to authenticate an online payment purchase while you're using the phone, you're going to want it someplace you can activate it with the hand you are holding the phone in. On the back you can extend you index finger up under the device to the location. On the side, it's aligned with where you thumb will be (if you're right handed). But at the top you now have to be able to reach the top of the device at the same time you're holding it from the bottom quarter of it. Since phone makers these days seem to think Phablet is the new normal size and 16:9 isn't tall enough, very few people can actually reach that high without using two hands.
Yeah? Put it on the Iphone 12 or I won’t buy it. Cause this ****ing mask makes face ID useless.
both would be so awesome, in case one fails, the other likely wouldn't.
The “incredible Feat of Engineering” would’ve been putting it under the screen, like Android manufacturers have been doing for years.
Word on the street is that iPhone's been delayed due to COVID and that Apple needed more time to test 5G
First mobile phone to ever have a fingerprint scanner was Toshiba G500 and G900. Both of these phones were actually way ahead of their time. Both ran Microsoft Windows Phone OS, had 3G connectivity, had a secondary camera and also had fingerprint sensors. These were announced in 2007 but never launched to the consumer market.
The first publicly available device to have fingerprint sensor was the Motorola Atrix, which launched back in 2011.
The first publicly available device to have fingerprint sensor was the Motorola Atrix, which launched back in 2011.
I totally agree. I'm glad it's at least an option because I hate FaceID, but it reeks of desperation needing to call it out so much.
When a photo of a fingerprint would unlock the phone?
I am sure as with everything, they likely prototyped Touch ID power button on the iPhone first, in fact, thats probably what they did, but internally went forward with Face ID because at the time, it just seemed like a better option.
They never saw that back in 2014 when they were working on the iPhone X that in 2020, there was gonna be a pandemic.
Its just like Apples multi-touch strategy started first with a Tablet in 2003, but plans switched and the iPhone came out first. Its a similar case that could apply to the iPhone 12. Even if it doesn't happen with this release, you can sure bet it will be on next years device.
I’m right handed and I hold my phone with my left hand so I can do things with my right one. My medium size left hand comfortably touches the top left and right of my X. I can do it with my right too, although it feel weird, and I accidentally press the power button and lock the phone. My palm rests on the left side of the phone, at the level of the keyboard, and my pinky can easily raise the phone if I need to type something one handed. I see no issue with the top mounted button, but I wouldn’t want it on the side because it would be much easier to accidentally press it.
Not sure what it would compare, but Sony has done this from long time, even the latest Xperia still using this solution.
Why can't they do this on the iPhone? What is the problem Apple? It will solve a lot of problems... well maybe. As long as they allow both to work at the same time. if you have to turn one off to get the other to work that would suck.
It would be awesome if it came to the iPhone 12, but I'm sure we'd have heard about it by now. The reality is that the new phone is very underwhelming at this point.
Bigger screen = Great.
5G = good, but that wouldn't make me upgrade considering the fact that carriers where I live probably don't have it widespread and will make you pay even more per month.
New design = Who really cares at this point. The vast majority of people put them in cases and with that hideous camera config on the back and a notch on the front, it's never going to win any design awards.
It would be awesome if it came to the iPhone 12, but I'm sure we'd have heard about it by now. The reality is that the new phone is very underwhelming at this point.
Bigger screen = Great.
5G = good, but that wouldn't make me upgrade considering the fact that carriers where I live probably don't have it widespread and will make you pay even more per month.
New design = Who really cares at this point. The vast majority of people put them in cases and with that hideous camera config on the back and a notch on the front, it's never going to win any design awards.
A little thing called screen real estate. If you want the old Touch ID, go buy an iPhone SE.
I’ll keep that in mind the 15 minutes a year I’m wearing gloves. I wear a mask a lot more time than that.
I’d like future iPhones to be equipped with both, and to be able to change in Settings for it to require one, or the other, or either, or both.
Obviously with this interview and the promo materials already in stores, looks like the Airs may very well drop sometime this week.
I do hope the upcoming iPhone 12 line gets this updated Touch ID too.
And while on the wish list here, may the iPad Air and the phones also inherit the excellent antenna design from the iPad Pro (especially since my 7th gen iPad and 2020 SE are lagging there).
I do hope the upcoming iPhone 12 line gets this updated Touch ID too.
And while on the wish list here, may the iPad Air and the phones also inherit the excellent antenna design from the iPad Pro (especially since my 7th gen iPad and 2020 SE are lagging there).
