Yes, they have been, because smartphones don't exist. There is no industry standard that differentiate a smartphone from any other phone.
That was the very point of my post. Your 8 year old kyocera, my 5 year old Sony Ericsson, they were all as capable as smartphones today.
...snip...
BUt see, 9 years ago, there WAS a difference. The only way you could do those things was with a "smartphone". Times have blured that line, but even if it's just the carriers that maintain the "sides of the fence" - the line still exists.
I've yet to use a non-smartphone that i'd like to do web & email on. Heck, i didn't particularly enjoy them on my Treo (which is one reason i don't mind not having data on it right now). There is a difference from what i have seen in my use.
But you are the one that said Apple made up the term, and/or that it was a made up marketing term from the past 2 years. My point was that um, NO they didn't. That marketing game started longer ago than that....
More features meant carriers could charge more money. Still does.
And i remember the joy 14 years ago being able to "dial-in" to work from the lake. That Motorola Flip thing got signal there (and AT&T didn't back then), and that like 2400 baud connecton meant i could enjoy a weekend and solve any crisis that needed to be solved. Life was good.....
But after all the phones I and various family members have used over the years - the iPhone/Touch (i have a Touch) is the most user friendly to do these things on....
Anyway..... i have use for 2 or 3 of the rumored Apple Tablets - even if they are just bigger Touch's.