Well good news and bad news! (and I'm not talking about the servers)
I got the game!
But... when my brother plays on the other controller, we have a blast, until when we try to log my brother off so I can just play, we can't figure out how to do that. I tried turning off the controller, and when I pressed manage players on the start button, nothing happened. Help!
Turn off the controller. Then wait just a bit. Also, free costumes on PSN store tonight!