Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This camera, though...
 

Attachments

  • D23216E0-1EB3-4DA1-B12D-E8CEACD7E9E0.jpeg
    D23216E0-1EB3-4DA1-B12D-E8CEACD7E9E0.jpeg
    492.6 KB · Views: 314
  • 2F65198A-EC04-4AF5-A824-C98C3A4FAEE3.jpeg
    2F65198A-EC04-4AF5-A824-C98C3A4FAEE3.jpeg
    1.4 MB · Views: 266
  • Like
Reactions: fryfrkhlly
Pro photographer here. Thank you all for sharing your photos! Some look fantastic! Others don’t. Yes a lot of that is differences in lighting, stabilization, focus points, HDR vs no HDR, user ability, etc. But let me tell you what I noticed with my Max compared to my 8+ when doing side by sides. The Max was producing sharper but noiser images. The 8+ was giving a softer more melty focus and considerable less noise. Hmmmm. While I like the idea of the smart HDR I’m thinking all the image consolidation has created some crappy digital grain and it sucks. I was so disappointed. Now, Part 2 to this story. My husband got the Max and I decided to do a side by side with his. BAM. His was beautiful! Not perfect, but waaaaay better. Performed exactly like I’d expect, and similar to some of the photos on here with beautiful contrast, low noise, and sharp details. WTF! I played with both Max’s for about an hour (doing side by sides with identical settings) before I concluded mine was a dud. Seriously! The photo quality was different and even obvious to my husbands untrained eye. Back to the store I went, swapped it out, and my new one is perfect. If you are noticing your camera seems to be taking awfully noisy pics (like real bad) then you might want to test it against a store phone and see if you notice a difference. In my case, my new one is great!! Also, I don’t expect dslr quality here, I just want what the phone specs are supposed to give. And for a casual snapshot scenario, this camera is awesome! (If you get a good one SMH)
Could you please inform me about your thoughts regarding the difference in quality when comparing the 8 plus photos to the healthy XS max ones. Also when HDR is not used, is there a significant difference too?
:)
 
I want to see some photos of distant trees at full resolution to see if the leaves turn to mush. Anyone have examples?
[doublepost=1537593359][/doublepost]So for the iPhone X in this series, was hdr turned on or was it left off?
All 3 cameras were left at default settings. Whatever comes turned on by default, was left on same for factory disabled settings. IIRC iPhone X had HDR off by default but someone else can confirm. I have already wiped the phone to give to my mom. She had a new Apple Watch series 4 to pair with it ;) .


100% Crops of all 3 cameras. In this example the X did really well for the section I cropped, as it grabbed focus on the leaves in the foreground. I believe the Xs was focused on something else all together.

IMG_4584_X.jpg
iPhone X

IMG_4588_Xs.jpg
iPhone Xs

IMG_20180921_Pix.jpg
Pixel 2

100% crops at 2X zoom. This is where the single fixed camera of the Pixel 2 really falls down. My favorite image is the Xs as it pulled in more detail at the highlighted top center, all without being blotchy like the Pixel 2.

IMG_4595_X.jpg
iPhoneX

IMG_4598_Xs.jpg
iPhone Xs

IMG_20180921_1Pix.jpg
Pixel 2
 
The future is lens-less! :D

http://www.caltech.edu/news/ultra-thin-camera-creates-images-without-lenses-78731
[doublepost=1537686865][/doublepost]

Which camera phones are you comparing it to which causes you turn your nose up at it?

I'm comparing it to real cameras just like Apple does. Apple doesn't get on stage and compare it to a S9, they compare it to DSLRs.

Went and took some photos purely to test out the portrait mode in nature, haven't retouched or filtered anything (I was just around my apartment complex, so don't expect anything amazing lol). Had some decent results. It's still questionable with some of the depth control for leaves and whatnot, but not too shabby. Can't wait for the day that they merge the regular and portrait modes - would like to have all of these options on regular photos also.

29921205867_bb2dae3ef2_o.jpg

This is pretty good. It's still a pretty sharp cutoff between the subject and background, but you can tell they're doing a better job at replicating the varying intensities of blur depending on distance.
 
Some selfies in portrait mode.
 

Attachments

  • 0D6DE4CA-6758-46DB-8997-5A1A355D91D8.jpeg
    0D6DE4CA-6758-46DB-8997-5A1A355D91D8.jpeg
    1.3 MB · Views: 194
  • 3E8BC693-C0AE-4FEF-AED5-4D4BE250DB8C.jpeg
    3E8BC693-C0AE-4FEF-AED5-4D4BE250DB8C.jpeg
    1.1 MB · Views: 184
  • 24382408-E800-4E52-88D2-91EF2459B1DC.jpeg
    24382408-E800-4E52-88D2-91EF2459B1DC.jpeg
    785.2 KB · Views: 185
I see a difference with my 8+ For sure. The 8 plus has a softer focus with crappier white balance for sure. Still a decent camera though. The Max pics were great for detail but still there is some slight grain/noise in certain lighting conditions. I like the HDR for some scenes but for others I found it lost contrast in the darks and made the colors too blendy. I set up my Max to have optional HDR so I can turn it off when I want to. Overall it’s a good upgrade. It’s fun to plan with the bokeh effects although they aren’t comparable to a pro lens it’s still fun to play with. For that reason I’m happy I upgraded.
 
  • Like
Reactions: filmak and pdxa4
Let's just take a moment to reflect on how far we've come, this was taken with my first iPhone, the iPhone 3G lol:

View attachment 787700

Dang... I started with the 3Gs and thought that was great compared to the louse blackberry curve I had prior to that. Man that was a lousy phone. Today I upgraded to the Xs and love the camera. Had the X, now my wife has it. As a photographer, I am happy Apple finally did something good to the camera, mainly the sensor. Maybe next year the telephoto will be f/2. The wide, f/1.5
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.