It's too bad some people on both sides of this discussion seem unable to defend their opinions with some degree of thought and reason rather than trying to turn this into a "you stink!" "no, YOU stink!" marathon.
I already can use my 1G iPod Touch for a number of "computer" style tasks, like ssh/vnc access. It's an incredibly useful gadget. So when people call the iPad just an iPod Touch writ large, I don't see it as the slam they apparently believe it to be. I obviously fall into the camp that believes an iPod Touch-like interface makes a lot of sense for this device - although I agree with those folks that would like to be able to run programs like Pandora in the background, rather than limiting it to the Apple software that currently has that ability.
It makes sense, though, that some people would prefer the equivalent of a Tablet PC that runs OS X in the same manner that current Mac computers do. The problem (meaning the reason it's not likely to happen) is likely the lukewarm reception those Tablet PCs received - they just never broke out of niche status. Of the two people I knew that owned one, neither ended up finding them all that compelling (I say that because when they updated their laptops, neither guy bought another tablet). But just because an OS X tablet is not likely to happen doesn't make wanting it unreasonable - especially when the only real option open to them (the ModBook) is horribly expensive.
I already can use my 1G iPod Touch for a number of "computer" style tasks, like ssh/vnc access. It's an incredibly useful gadget. So when people call the iPad just an iPod Touch writ large, I don't see it as the slam they apparently believe it to be. I obviously fall into the camp that believes an iPod Touch-like interface makes a lot of sense for this device - although I agree with those folks that would like to be able to run programs like Pandora in the background, rather than limiting it to the Apple software that currently has that ability.
It makes sense, though, that some people would prefer the equivalent of a Tablet PC that runs OS X in the same manner that current Mac computers do. The problem (meaning the reason it's not likely to happen) is likely the lukewarm reception those Tablet PCs received - they just never broke out of niche status. Of the two people I knew that owned one, neither ended up finding them all that compelling (I say that because when they updated their laptops, neither guy bought another tablet). But just because an OS X tablet is not likely to happen doesn't make wanting it unreasonable - especially when the only real option open to them (the ModBook) is horribly expensive.