Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This service is absolutely ridiculous. This could have been a value added function of AM, that many of us would not use, but charging 5usd ON TOP of AM… wow. Ridiculous. Surely some people will pay, so good for Apple, but a joke to us…
I don't think you understand how this works. It isn't ON TOP of Apple Music, it's essentially a lower tier of Apple Music, a "gateway drug", or a service that's ideal to go along with one of those new colored HomePod minis, for someone who just wants to put a HomePod mini in their kitchen/whatever and tell it to play music. But, hey, great reason to get outraged.
 
The voice plan is clearly directed toward Spotify users who want to be able to play music from their HomePods more easily, which is why it was announced right next to the HomePod segment this week. It's a way to incentivize people away from Spotify and back into the Apple ecosystem. Don't understand the people who are criticizing this plan so negatively.
The suggestion I heard is that it's positioned to compete with music subscriptions on other smart speakers - for instance, Amazon has a $4 plan if you just want to use their music service on an Echo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BromoCop
Spotify is still superior to Apple Music in nearly every way. The AI algorithms that choose the music on Spotify are light years ahead of what Apple is capable of or has invested in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dtruett1
Why is Singapore not on the list of launch countries? Used to be a priority market for Apple...
Totally agree. Although my guess is:
1) Spotify is already competitively priced in SG so there’s very little value proposition for this AM tier
2) Siri has a hard enough time already with my friends’ Singaporean accents — I think they know this would be even more frustrating in SG than to other users elsewhere (and boy is that saying something)
 
Many of you might not remember the iPod shuffle. It was an iPod with no screen and no controls. You could load songs onto it from your computer, but all you could do from the iPod controls was play, pause, and skip songs. It was a huge success. Apple Music Voice reminds me of that.
 
Is there a 'stop recommending Drake to me' option available?
Truth. I've tried a few Apple Music trials, no matter what artist, genre I pick...usually classic rock, rock. Artists from the 60s-90s...maybe a few from 00s. Drake appears & always "recommended for me," under the "For You" tab.

Fine, I know may are fans...I'm not!
____

"Typical Monday morning at your house?"

No! I don't own a pool or even tattoos.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: SurferPup
Spotify is still superior to Apple Music in nearly every way. The AI algorithms that choose the music on Spotify are light years ahead of what Apple is capable of or has invested in.
Spotifys algorithm has been pathetic for me. Never managed to properly gauge my interests and seems to have a fantasy with Drake and Podcasts that I don’t care about.

I’ve used Apple Music for around 4-6 months now and it’s been very good at getting my interests locked in. The rest of my family has also been using it with CarPlay and HomePods and it’s also correctly identified their interests according to them.

I know for sure that Apple Musics recommendation system a few years ago was a total joke but it’s certainly gotten a lot better.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: SurferPup
Truth. I've tried a few Apple Music trials, no matter what artist, genre I pick...usually classic rock, rock. Artists from the 60s-90s...maybe a few from 00s. Drake appears & always "recommended for me," under the "For You" tab.

Fine, I know may are fans...I'm not!
____

"Typical Monday morning at your house?"

No! I don't own a pool or even tattoos.
I’ve even did the “recommend this less” thing, and it just will not take a hint. I thought Apple was into machine learning?

Here’s a screenshot. I’m listening to David Bowie and other classic artists like The Doors, Elton John, etc. It’s all I listen to.
 

Attachments

  • 877ED7C1-183C-4238-922F-99056916C957.png
    877ED7C1-183C-4238-922F-99056916C957.png
    1.3 MB · Views: 80
Here's a radical idea. Forget this silly crap and make a serious effort to have a jazz and blues library anywhere near what Spotify or Pandora have. Then, I'll subscribe.
 
All I want is for Apple Music to let me organize playlist folders the way I want. I don't understand why you can't put playlists not-created-by-you into folders. Incredibly frustrating.
 
Last edited:
Why is Singapore not on the list of launch countries? Used to be a priority market for Apple...
When music or moves launch in some you tries and not in others, the reason is often something to do with per-country licensing rights for the media - different company or companies in charge of that area and have differing terms in their existing contracts, or someone believes the new variant of the service isn’t covered under the existing contracts and wants to renegotiate. Sure, could be unrelated, something to do with Siri or some such, but in general. Look at licensing.
 
Being able to build a playlist based on mood was my favorite part of a now defunct app called Songza. It was surprisingly accurate and introduced me to several songs I never would have guessed I'd like. I miss that app.
Songza was amazing! You probably already know this, but it was bought by Google, then the playlists were merged with Google Play Music. Now that Google Music is Youtube Music, some of those playlists actually live on there ?
 
This works now? We do this all the time, and I just tested it again to be extra sure: "Hey Siri, play coffeehouse jazz in the kitchen." Totally works. Oh, but I did have to set up rooms in Home and assign speakers. Have you done that?
Yep, you are correct. The problem is that I have a Home Pod, an Apple TV and an Airplay 2 Capable Stereo system all in the same room so saying play in *room* won't give me good results. I suppose I could create rooms for each device, but that seems silly. I can tell the Home Pod to play music on the stereo (Hey Siri, play *playist* on Stereo). I have a homepod in a bedroom that should be playing at the same time and if I say "Hey Siri, play *playlist* on Stereo and in master bedroom" it plays on the stereo but not in the bedroom.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.