Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The iMac Pro does have slotted RAM, they showed it off multiple times in the keynote. But like this 4K model, the display has to be removed to access it, along with the processor and SSDs.

I said upgradable, not slotted. And no, having to remove the display and void the warranty isn't "upgradable" for a mainstream user. And this model (which is 5k, not 4k) has a memory door on the back and Apple lists the model as user accessible. That's my whole point, when the "consumer" 5k 27 inch has a memory door, why not do the same on the "pro" model?

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201191#install1
[doublepost=1497386149][/doublepost]
It's upgradeable, but some work is involved ... and probably a voiding of the warranty: http://ifixit.org/blog/9182/2017-imac-upgradable/

That's not the iMac pro (which doesn't ship for months), that's the 2017 21 inch iMac.
 
I said upgradable, not slotted. And no, having to remove the display and void the warranty isn't "upgradable" for a mainstream user. And this model (which is 5k, not 4k) has a memory door on the back and Apple lists the model as user accessible. That's my whole point, when the "consumer" 5k 27 inch has a memory door, why not do the same on the "pro" model?

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201191#install1
[doublepost=1497386149][/doublepost]

That's not the iMac pro (which doesn't ship for months), that's the 2017 21 inch iMac.
Okay, calm down. I was saying it is upgradeable because it can be upgraded. Obviously it is something to be done after the warranty has expired. The reason they couldn't have it on the Pro seems too be because of the new cooling systemn although I'm sure if they really wanted to they would find a work around.
 
Okay, calm down. I was saying it is upgradeable because it can be upgraded. Obviously it is something to be done after the warranty has expired.

Perfectly calm, don't project.

I'm talking about user upgradable. There's a huge difference between a door on the back which any user can easily and quickly swap and completely taking the machine apart and voiding the warranty.

Not to mention that "this mac" in the article is a 5k 27 inch. Which has a memory door. So it's not like the iMac pro in that respect.
 
Perfectly calm, don't project.

I'm talking about user upgradable. There's a huge difference between a door on the back which any user can easily and quickly swap and completely taking the machine apart and voiding the warranty.

Not to mention that "this mac" in the article is a 5k 27 inch. Which has a memory door. So it's not like the iMac pro in that respect.
I know, of course there's a difference and it's a shame that upgradeable RAM isn't found on many other Macs, especially desktops where it should be standard and has no reason not to be. Reasoning for not having it on the Pro is that the cooling system doesn't allow for it in the place where Apple would want it, and it isn't necessarily very important as upgradeability is a selling point of the new Mac Pro and it comes with 32GB minimum unlike the 8GB found on the consumer iMac.
I still don't think it's justified, though I would accept the change on iMacs if Apple increased the base RAM and also slashed their prices for RA upgrades.
 
upgradeability is a selling point of the new Mac Pro

I assume you meant upgradeability is not a selling point? I've never seen a "pro" desktop computer with zero options for internal upgrade before this. And I think that the kind of person who needs an 18 core CPU may want more than 32 gigs of ram.
 
I assume you meant upgradeability is not a selling point? I've never seen a "pro" desktop computer with zero options for internal upgrade before this. And I think that the kind of person who needs an 18 core CPU may want more than 32 gigs of ram.
No, I mean it is a selling point. Of the Mac Pro (not iMac Pro).
 
I have the 2017 3.4 ghz iMac 27" and confirm it will hold 4x16gb modules @ 64gb, However it does crash about once a day, restarts automatically. Im using Crucial memory ddr4 2400
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.