Doylem is a declared disliker of HDR (not the only one, BTW,) and he criticizes it by saying what a lot of folks won't, but I don't believe he ever makes personal attacks on anyone. In fact he's a great teacher from a certain point of view, a more traditional, patient perspective, as compared to computer enhanced images. Rather than get upset, maybe just consider the perspective, and understand why he says what he says. You don't have to agree, it's as simple as that. But, if we want to outlaw comments on work posted in this thread, then let's outlaw comments...or maybe just negative comments. Perhaps it would be better if we just posted our work, and never got any feedback at all, other than "Love it," or "awesome." We'd never learn anything, but we'd all feel good about ourselves.
Personally (my confession,) I'm not attracted to most HDR work I've seen. But, that's personal taste. I don't really like the "look" most people achieve with it. It tends to look all the same in tone, colors, edges... actually becomes repetitive and boring --- TO ME. I said "most." Not "all." But that's my own personal taste. But certainly HDR is as legit as any other form of photographic expression, just like black and white, super saturation, effects laden, high contrast, super-wide perspectives (fisheye) and those who like doing it, and like viewing it are certainly no different than anyone else. This isn't a political issue.
Nuwomb, you produce some very interesting and visually arresting images. In some cases the your methods (superwide urban perspectives/HDR) actually works really well for me, other times it doesn't. Personally, the extreme wide angle/fisheye perspectives more than the HDR can tend to make me feel dizzy, but that's nothing against your work at all. In fact to me the wide-angle perspectives you create are, to me, uniquely distinguish your style from many others doing HDR, and gives it interest and a 'signature' that says, Nuwomb. So, I like that you're pushing your envelope, but I still don't really care for HDR, sorry. Nothing personal intended, period! I'm sure you can easily say the same about my work, or Doylem's -- the things you don't like or that are boring. And it would be fair and valid. You have received a lot more positive comments over time than negative from what I've seen. But the one thing I've noticed more about folks using HDR, which surprises me, is how sensitive they get to any criticism of their work at all. That's largely why I don't bother to comment anymore on images, even constructively -- it turns into a personal, highly charged 'political' battle. "Oh no... Not this HDR war thing again..." I'm sure many talented photographers didn't leave this forum because of any negative comments, but because they preferred to associate with others doing their particular form of art, or simply got busy and had to tend to real life. To blame Doylem for that is really a bit silly, and for those of you who can't take criticism, get out of the art world. It's a fact of life, and if you can't handle a little negativity here in this forum, you're not going to be able to handle it in the real world.
When I first came here I got all kinds of constructive criticism and negativity... serious discussions about methods and techniques and some great feedback. I saw things in different ways through the eyes of others, and sometimes I had to admit I wasn't always objective about my own work - kind of a personal thing, if you know what I mean, until I realized I actually learned more from the dissenters than the admirers. I didn't always agree, but it made me think.
Questions is: is this forum going to head down the road where eventually it's a bunch of mediocre photos with only the occasional "wow, amazing" comments because good photographers or critics with solid perspective on the craft can't comment without hurting people's feelings? If so, it loses my interest, whether you consider me a decent photographer or not.
In the end, let's try to keep criticism here from turning into personal attacks, and let's also grow some thicker skin about our art. Otherwise posting anything you personally created on the internet (or anywhere out there in the world of media) is only going to get your feelings hurt one day...
With all the best intentions... -phil