Where did you get your design degree from?
What are you talking about?? I dont care if you like them - do I need to have a design degree to state my opinion about something....?
Nonetheless:
1st, its a matter of taste, which is a subjective opinion, personally I think they look horrible.
2nd, Apples mantra since Steve Jobs ever came back to apple has been minimalism and simplicity. And they are not giving into easy solutions...Apple has never given out a product that has unnecessary forms or shapes unless it was absolutely needed and they had no way to get around that. So it makes no sense for them to add multiple antenna bands now, if they managed to avoid it earlier.
As for my professional opinion, since you so sarcastically asks for it. The lines breaks the continuity of the phones edges, with a glance it looks like the phone are missing a piece from the top and bottom, the continuity of the horizontal lines needs to follow through at top and bottom, or solved in a better way, (as the iphone 5s) - it simply looks like the phone is broken from a design standpoint. I´m pretty sure those lines will disappear in the molding process, with liquid metal or whatever they have planned, nothing else makes any sense to me. And since you ask, yes I´m a professional designer and artist which have successfully done my work for 25 years now, so I do think I´m allowed to have an opinion....My question to you are... what sort of professional authority do you claim to be (?), demanding such expertise from people simply because they have an opinion on an open apple forum.
Last edited: