Still think iPhone 3was much nicer looking...
I think the 3G/S with its curved back and sides sits more nicely in the hand than the angular iPhone 4. But the shiny plastic body is cheap-looking compared to aluminum or glass. Overall it's a toss up. I think the OG iPhone had the best-looking materials, reception-be-damned, and the 3G had the nicest shape.
However in terms of Apple's design progression, this is something of a non-sequitur. Not that a curved aluminum body couldn't be nice, but this mockup just looks quick n' dirty.
Last edited: