Re: Re: RE: areyouwishing
Originally posted by areyouwishing
Gradients, not that I would use them out of a page layout tool, since they band like crazy, but...
I have yet to find a way to use a specific spot color in a gradient with ID, if I want that spot color I have to select the CMYK percentages. I could make a gradient swatch, and then open the window etc. etc. but quark treats swatches like regular colors.
I think the ability to use any color on the fly can get people into trouble too, this is more of a user error thing though.
Make a text box in ID, make some lorem ipsum, select a word, click the select tool, go back to the text tool, and click the text box...the word is no longer selected, so if you kerned something and clicked off to see it unreversed, then click back on the word, you have to re-select it, quark knows what you had selected last for each text box (unless they are linked).
2 words...."Palette City" Sometimes this can work, like palettizing the usage/links window was a great idea, but there is a lot of stuff that could be a little more...streamlined, like the colors pallete
Quark tells you if you are using a type 1 font, open type, or truetype right where you select your font.
Quarks icons for type control are slightly better than ID's dropdown, waiting for a drop down to do all caps is not fun...just being picky here.
Despite the whole non-transparrent thing, I think Quarks Tables are easier to work.
Thats it for now, i might add to it if i think of more stuff.
P.S. Personally I use indesign more than Quark whenever i can, I could pick apart quark features all night.
1. The Gradient: It works the same way as in Illustrator. You create 2 color swatches (can be any spot, CMYK, lab, etc). You draw a shape, apply gradient. You drag 1 color to 1 end of the gradient, the other color to the other end - voilà. Spot color to spot color gradient. Now you can drag the gradient itself into the swatch palette and you can reuse it any time.
2. On the fly color - not sure what you mean. That I can eyedrop a color out of the CMYK mixer? I still have to create a swatch for a spot or CMYK color through a dialog...
3. the text box thing. Of course the word gets deselcted - you told the program to pick a different tool. One thing about kerning in ID. You can have optical kerning that is 95% correct even from the most anal retentive designer's perspective. Just select the text, and instead of metric kerning, select optical. Bliss. Besides, you have your terms wrong. You are talking about tracking which affects whole words. Kerning is between two letters, and you cannot apply kerning even in Quark, if you have a word selected (more than 2 characters). So, kerning works exactly as it should in ID.
4. Palette city: never was a problem. Just hit tab to hide. I always arrange them the way I like them, and then don't move them. that's one mistake people do. they keep moving their palettes, instead of layoing them out then hiding them. Quark has a way more annoying "feature:. The "joe Pesci" effect. You open a dialog, then inside it you open an other one, then another, etc. then to get out, you have to go: *in Joe Pesci voice* OK, OK, OK, OK. How is that better from having everything a click away? (just think style sheets dialogs in Quark).
5. From a designer's standpoint it really doesn't matter what type of font you use, as long as it works. ID will package all necessary fonts for you, plus display warnings even before you can use the fonts that they might not work. OpenType fonts are great - and ID had them first. you might be able to pack fonts in Quark, but since using ID, I don't even worry about that anymore. Wouldn't you allready know what type of fonts you are using anyway? I mean, if I know that I have Warlock Pro, and I wnat to use it, I already know it's OpenType. ID will pack it for me, that's it.
6. Not sure what you mean about the drop down menu... Any decent Quark user will tell you that you should NEVER use the italic, bold, small caps, etc. buttons to make a font italic, bold, small cap. You should instead select the appropriate printer font. When you hit those buttons, only the screen fonts of those variations load. When it goes to print most of the time you get a courier font. So, on this issue, you are just using quark wrong. iD on the other hand, when you tell it to use italic, bold, small cap, etc. from the drop down menu, it will go to the printer font and substitute it for you...
7. Don't even get me started on the whole tables issue. Please, Quark's tables don't even come close to ID table features. Can you span a Quark table into several Text boxes? Can you rotate them arbitrary degrees? Can you have the strokes selectively adjusted? Can you merge cells whichever you want (horizontal, vertical)? Can you color each cell? Dude, this tables comment alone let me know that you haven't even scratched ID.
Please get off your high horse about Quark, and just give ID another look. If you have questions, I would be more than happy to answer your questions.
*edit*
sorry, forgot to add smileys, etc. where appropriate. I went out drinking and just got back, so I am not sure this will all be coherent....

It's only a f*****g program, why can't we all be friends?