Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

SouthernFried

macrumors member
Original poster
Mar 29, 2022
48
62
I thought this might be fun. Feel free to throw in your other devices you have owned too. My first smartphone was in 2012 starting with the iPhone 5. I understand that newer devices are obviously higher-spec, but that doesn’t necessarily mean you didn’t have a better overall experience with older models.

1.) iPhone XR (Bonafide #1 and longest kept device).
2.) iPhone SE (2022)
3.) iPhone 5 (Extra points for nostalgia).
4.) Samsung Galaxy S8+
5.) iPhone 5C (Stupid purchase only because I had the 5 before it).
6.) Samsung Galaxy S7 (Absolute junk. Worst device I have owned by a country mile).
 
Last edited:
1 - iPhone 5 (Black/Slate, 64GB)
2 - iPhone 6+ (Space Gray, 128GB)
3 - iPhone 6s+ (Space Gray, 128GB)
4 - iPhone 11 Pro Max (Space Gray, 512GB)
5 - Google Pixel 3a XL (Black, 64GB)
6 - iPhone 3GS (Black, 32GB)
7 - iPhone 4 (Black, 32GB)
8 - iPhone 4s (White, 8GB)
9 - HTC Touch Pro (16GB miniSD card)

Note that the 3GS, the 4 and 4s were never used by me as primary phones. These were acquired at different points from 2011 on. Also, I have everything I list above sitting on my desk right now except for the 6+ which was traded in.
 
1. iPhone 14 pro max
2. iPhone 7+
3. iPhone 12 Pro max
4. iPhone XS max
5. HTC One
6. iPhone 4s
7. iPhone 5s
8. iPhone 3GS
9. Moto X
10. iPhone 6+

My iPhone 6+ experience was terrible. I had several warranty replacements. The battery life sucked. Issues related to the lack of memory popped up less than a year into owning the phone. My terrible experience on the 6+ is probably why I liked the 7+ so much. I’m obviously still in the honeymoon period, but so far the 14 Pro Max has been great though.

The HTC one was a seriously great phone with an absolute garbage camera. I only had the Moto X for a bit because I wanted to tryout a cheaper android phone. It was pretty nice for the price, to be honest.
 
1. iPhone 14 Pro Max - Current
2. iPhone 13 Pro Max
3. iPhone 12 Pro Max
4. iPhone 11 Pro Max
5. iPhone XS Max
6. iPhone X
7. iPhone 8 Plus (short period till X came out)
8. iPhone 7 Plus
9. iPhone 6S Plus
10. iPhone 6 Plus
11. Galaxy S5
12. Galaxy S4
13. iPhone 4S
14. iPhone 4
15. iPhone 3GS
16. iPhone 3G

That was my line up. I wish I had the Original iPhone but oh well.
 
Here’s mine:

  1. iPhone 11 (kept it longest due to PWM)
  2. iPhone X (first time I was wowed by an iPhone since the iPhone 4)
  3. iPhone 4
  4. iPhone XR (My X replacement after PWM hit me bad. The single camera felt like a downgrade)
  5. iPhone 5
  6. iPhone 7
  7. iPhone 6
  8. iPhone 3GS
I’m yet to rate my iPhone 14 Pro because if it causes migraines for me it’s going back but it feels like it might come 4th.
 
1 iPhone
2 iPhone 3G
3 iPhone 3GS
4 iPhone 4
5 iPhone 4S
6 iPhone 5
7 iPhone 5c
8 iPhone 5s
9 iPhone 6
10 iPhone 6 Plus
11 iPhone 6s
12 iPhone 6s Plus
13 iPhone SE (1st generation)
14 iPhone 7
15 iPhone 7 Plus
16 iPhone 8
17 iPhone 8 Plus
18 iPhone X
19 iPhone XR
20 iPhone XS
21 iPhone XS Max
22 iPhone 11
23 iPhone 11 Pro
24 iPhone 11 Pro Max
25 iPhone SE (2nd generation)
26 iPhone 12 mini
27 iPhone 12
28 iPhone 12 Pro
29 iPhone 12 Pro Max
30 iPhone 13 mini
31 iPhone 13
32 iPhone 13 Pro
33 iPhone 13 Pro Max
34 iPhone SE (3rd generation)
35 iPhone 14
36 iPhone 14 Plus
37 iPhone 14 Pro
38 iPhone 14 Pro Max
 
1. iPhone 14 Pro Max - Current
2. iPhone 13 Pro Max
3. iPhone 12 Pro Max
4. iPhone XS Max
5. iPhone 7 Plus
6. iPhone 6 Plus (After this I never looked back)
7. iPhone 5 (It was great till the top button failed)
8. HTC (Can't remember model, It was after the Palm Pre and before the iPhone 5)
9. Galaxy S5 (I got this after the iPhone 5 failed. This is the android phone that made me go back to iPhone)
10. Palm Pre (Think of butterfly keyboard on a phone, my first smartphone)

This is to the best of my memory. Only smartphones listed because it gets a little fuzzy before that. I have a little nostalgia for the iPhone 5 but when it comes down to it if I'm honestly ranking them they got better and easier to use as time went on. I can't do something silly and put the iPhone 5 up with the 13 Pro Max. I've used other phones for work or secondary phones but this is the list of my primary phones
 
  • Like
Reactions: SouthernFried
  1. iPhone 13 Pro
  2. iPhone 4S
  3. iPhone XS Max
  4. iPhone 7+
  5. iPhone 7
  6. iPhone 6+
Too early to judge my 14 Pro. Feels very similar to my 13 Pro though. iPhone 6+ was the worst. Too underpowered, not enough RAM, terrible longevity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SouthernFried
Ranking my favorite experiences, best to worst.

iPhone 11pro midnight green (just bought used a month ago. Dream phone)
iPhone 7 gold (amazing screen coming from 5s with terrible screen. Amazing photos. Amazing typing accuracy)
iPhone 5c blue (absence makes the heart grow fonder. First iPhone. Love the size and curved edges, and the home button click)
iPhone 11 green (great deal at $599. Loved the color. too big. Amazing upgrade on photos, though, from the 7)
iPhone 13mini starlight (still too big for a mini. Gets too hot.)
iPhone 5s black (terrible screen)
iPhone 7 black (terrible screen)
 
1. iPhone 4: my 1st smartphone. The form factor. Square edges. Lightweight. So cool with apps that were out of this world. ie. it was able to take 360º panoramic photo with vibrating internal motor.

2. iPhone X: Face ID

3. All the other iPhones. meh.


I am hoping 14 pro will be able to claim #3 spot.
 
1. iPhone 3G
2. iPhone 11 Pro Max
3. iPhone 14 Pro / Max
4. iPhone 6s Plus
5. iPhone 13 Mini
6. iPhone 12 Mini
7. iPhone X
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: SouthernFried
1) iPhone [I really wish I had kept this]
2) iPhone 3G
3) iPhone 3GS
4) iPhone 4 [My favorite design and phone to this date]
5) iPhone 5
6) iPhone 5C
7) iPhone 6
8) iPhone 6S Plus
9) iPhone 7 Plus
10) iPhone X
11) iPhone XS Max
12) iPhone 11 Pro Max
13) iPhone 13 Pro Max
14) iPhone 14 Pro Max
 
  • Like
Reactions: SouthernFried
1. iPhone XS Max (I used to be a huge big phone hater but I decided to take a chance and try out the size. After a month, I cannot go back to a smaller size, that’s why I rank this phone so highly. also amazing feel in hand)

2. iPhone 13 Pro Max (The battery life on this phone literally changed the way I used phones. I used to charge phones around 5pm-7pm because I would run out. Now I can legit go two days with this phone)

3. iPhone 6S. (Just a beast of a phone. Huge upgrade over the 6. I could have kept it longer but the iPhone X was too big of a draw for me)

4. iPhone 4 (First iPhone. Retina Display blew my teenager mind)

5. iPhone X (Pretty dope phone. If I hadn’t moved to the XS Max a year later and fallen in love with the Max sized phones, probably would’ve been ranked higher)

6. iPhone 6 (It was ok. dope to move to a bigger screen from the 4 but it bent and dented too easily. Managed to actually make money selling it and buying a 6S on craiglist so atleast it was good for that)
 
1. iPhone 4: my 1st smartphone. The form factor. Square edges. Lightweight. So cool with apps that were out of this world. ie. it was able to take 360º panoramic photo with vibrating internal motor.

2. iPhone X: Face ID

3. All the other iPhones. meh.


I am hoping 14 pro will be able to claim #3 spot.

I regret not entering the smartphone world in 2010-2011 when the 4 and 4S were around. I was still flying blind with a home landline and POS boost mobile flip phone in those days.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: PlayUltimate
1 iPhone
2 iPhone 3G
3 iPhone 3GS
4 iPhone 4
5 iPhone 4S
6 iPhone 5
7 iPhone 5c
8 iPhone 5s
9 iPhone 6
10 iPhone 6 Plus
11 iPhone 6s
12 iPhone 6s Plus
13 iPhone SE (1st generation)
14 iPhone 7
15 iPhone 7 Plus
16 iPhone 8
17 iPhone 8 Plus
18 iPhone X
19 iPhone XR
20 iPhone XS
21 iPhone XS Max
22 iPhone 11
23 iPhone 11 Pro
24 iPhone 11 Pro Max
25 iPhone SE (2nd generation)
26 iPhone 12 mini
27 iPhone 12
28 iPhone 12 Pro
29 iPhone 12 Pro Max
30 iPhone 13 mini
31 iPhone 13
32 iPhone 13 Pro
33 iPhone 13 Pro Max
34 iPhone SE (3rd generation)
35 iPhone 14
36 iPhone 14 Plus
37 iPhone 14 Pro
38 iPhone 14 Pro Max
An Apple a day does not seem to keep the doctor away. :p

j/k

You do seem to have a predilection for Apple.
 
1.iPhone 2G
The one that started everything, amazingly I somehow used it right through until the iPhone 5 (probably because I was a student without too much money at the time!) - in the UK we could of course just buy it for £269 and some clever hackers made it possible to work with a O2 pay as you go SIM

2.iPhone X
I was actually still content with my iPhone 6 Plus until a friend offered me this for £500 as they were upgrading, still using it today but not for too much longer, still a perfectly functional phone even if the battery is a little worse for wear now and the camera doesn't seem too happy these days either

3.iPhone 6 Plus
Had no intentions of buying this until my iPhone 5 was stolen, but I absolutely loved the bigger screen and battery life...until 'batterygate', but Apple responded with a very cheap scheme to replace the battery which had it firing on all cylinders again until retirement for the iPhone X

4.iPhone 5
This was the most cursed iPhone for me ever, the only iPhone I've ever smashed the screen on, then issues with the screen not responding to touch at all intermittently despite several more screen changes by Apple (eventually they gave in and replaced the entire unit with a refurb but it took a lot of effort to convince them to do so!), then it got stolen! Battery life was also probably the worst of all my iPhone history too, 4G seemed to drain it like mad

???.iPhone 14 Pro Max
Ordered today!
 
In timeline order with scores out of 10.

1. 3GS - Loved the design! Funky black and white! Speedy for the time, but horrible camera and didn't sit flat on table. 8/10

2. 4S - Not as big a fan of the iconic design. Loved Siri. Felt like I was in a Star Trek Episode! Average camera and nothing else to talk about in terms of upgrades at the time. 6.5/10.

3. 5S - Loved the space gray industrial design of this iPhone. I think Apple's best iPhone design. Better camera but still not great, but super thin. Just wish it was bigger. 8.5/10

4. 6S+ - Not as big a fan of the design, but this phone was a workhorse! Camera was solid apart from at night. At the time people complained there wasn't much in terms of upgrade. But the processor was very good and it lasted a looong time. On par with the 8+ for longevity I reckon. 8.5/10

5. XS Max - Beautifully made phone. Cameras were okay for the time, but def not the best. Everything else about the phone was very good. It was Apple's biggest screen at that time and that was welcome. 8/10

6. 13PM - Not a huge fan of the design - heavy and chunky. But I understand why they did it. Preferred XS Max design. Battery is stonking, camera very good, smaller notch was welcome with the biggest screen up until that release. 8/10


Think back to iPhone 3,4,5,6. We got a new design every year! I want that Apple back! You got so much money, spend some of it, you stingy plonks!
 
Last edited:
1) 5s
2) 8-plus
3) 3Gs

Yes 5s gets a higher ranking - I've never liked the camera/photo processing on my 8-plus. At first I thought there was something wrong with the camera, but my wife's was the same.

I would do side by side pics shots and view them on iMac and most times the 5s photo just looked more realistic and not like a canvas.

If they could cram everything into the 5s size, I'd go back instantly!

14-pro Plus on its way... it better jump to the start of the rankings!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: SouthernFried
1) iPhone 3GS (White)
2) iPhone 4 (White)
3) iPhone XS (Black)
4) iPhone 13 Pro (Sierra Blue)
5) iPhone X (White)
6) iPhone 2G - OG!
7) iPhone 14 Pro (Deep Purple)
8) iPhone 5s (Black)
9) iPhone 5 (White)
10) iPhone 8 (Product Red)
11) iPhone 6 Plus (Space Grey)

Now that I have counted the number of iPhones I had, damn that was a lot of wasteful spending. I could have had half of those and still enjoyed all their unique features.
 
Last edited:
1. iPhone. Hands down the best. Was just draw dropping after coming from a Blackberry and a Nokia.

2. iPhone 13 mini. So much packed into so little (by contemporary iPhone sizes).

3. iPhone X. The hype mainly.

I upgrade every 2 or 3 years, and I am afraid I have forgotten the other 3 or 4 iPhones I have owned. I guess they were meh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: throAU and SpotOnT
The only one that I've ever "owned" is the 5s. Ever since the 6, I started using Jump on Demand from T-Mobile. But from all the ones I've used, here's my ranking:

1. iPhone X: finally the best camera came to a smaller body (had been tired of the Plus models getting the better camera features, like the 6 Plus with OIS and 7 Plus with the dual-camera), and not to mention the all the other changes (design, OLED display, 3GB of RAM on smaller body, etc.)

2. iPhone 6s: the speed difference was so huge, both because of the A9 chip (A8 was very minor compared to the A7), and the 2GB of RAM (which was the first time the iPhone had to wait 3 years to get a RAM increase).

3. iPhone Xs: even though it looked the same as the X, I still really liked the design, and liked that the iPhone finally could reach gigabit speeds.

4. iPhone 13 Pro: really liked Promotion and the big improvement in battery life, but not the heavier weight. Also liked this blue better than the 12 Pro blue.

5. iPhone 12 Pro: ranking this one below the 13 Pro because the 12 Pro Max got the better camera, but I did enjoy the iPhone finally coming in blue (not counting the 5c).

6. iPhone 11 Pro: first time in a long time that I saw a noticeable improvement in battery life, but ranking it below the Xs because of the same design for the 3rd year in a row. Liked the triple-camera system coming to an iPhone for the first time.

7. iPhone 7: ranking this one towards the bottom because I remember that year, we were expecting something different in terms of design (having been used to the "S" cycle, and this phone broke that cycle). Still, the spec improvements were nice, but I disliked it not getting 3GB of RAM like the 7 Plus did.

8. iPhone 5s: even though it was my first phone, Android phones had larger screens by that year. Touch-ID was really nice though, and so was the A7 chip.

9. iPhone 6: the larger screen was nice, but the 1 GB of RAM felt like something that was done on purpose to cut costs, since Apple knew the larger screen would sell itself, and it did. Also, the A8 chip was basically no faster than the A7 chip if you considered the difference in display resolutions between the 5s and 6. And worst of all, the 6 Plus got OIS while the 6 did not (for no good reason).

10. iPhone 8: only ranking this one at the bottom because I only got to use it for 2 months, since the X came very late that year, and this was before T-Mobile started charging down-payments for Jump on Demand, so it made sense to get it anyway.
 
1. iPhone 14 pro max
2. iPhone 7+
3. iPhone 12 Pro max
4. iPhone XS max
5. HTC One
6. iPhone 4s
7. iPhone 5s
8. iPhone 3GS
9. Moto X
10. iPhone 6+

My iPhone 6+ experience was terrible. I had several warranty replacements. The battery life sucked. Issues related to the lack of memory popped up less than a year into owning the phone. My terrible experience on the 6+ is probably why I liked the 7+ so much. I’m obviously still in the honeymoon period, but so far the 14 Pro Max has been great though.

The HTC one was a seriously great phone with an absolute garbage camera. I only had the Moto X for a bit because I wanted to tryout a cheaper android phone. It was pretty nice for the price, to be honest.
The 7 was a great phone. Never owned one personally but I had several friends who did and they all loved theirs. The design was beautiful, especially in matte black.
 
  • Like
Reactions: throAU and zachz
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.