Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The owner of reddit sounds like a real prick! I hope reddit fails because of his attitude and greed. It would be awesome if the moderators continue their efforts to stick it to the owner. A referendum. First Twitter, now Reddit. These apps need to get people in charge who know what they're doing and aren't greedy egotistical maniacs.
 
"Any declining organization or government has a potential to reach the point beyond which every new decision is a wrong one." - Me
 
Last edited:
Reddit does have the right to charge asinine fees for their API if they wish. They even have the right to replace entire mods teams (who are borderline unpaid Reddit employees) if they choose.

But they do not have the right to falsely accuse developers of blackmail. That is my main issue with this whole debacle.

Seriously, if you haven’t already, read into it. The CEO publicly accused the developer of Apollo, Christian, of blackmail. Fortunately for Christian, he recorded their entire conversation and released it for all to hear. Spoiler: there was no blackmail and the CEO even acknowledged that.

Huffman still has not spoke about why he lied about the blackmail accusation.
Looks like a good time to sue for that $20,000,000 he'll need to keep Apollo going. ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: MacWiz_007
I'm currently trying kbin (terrible name) right now. I looked at Lemmy and it makes no sense to me. If we're using the email analogy here, does every email domain have its own isolated subreddits that don't connect to the other domain's subreddits? That sounds unworkable... but from what I can see that's how it works. kbin seems to function about identical to reddit and doesn't hurt my head so I think I'll use that.
I believe that is how it works. the communities are server-specific, but an account from any server can interact. kbin is a closer approximation to reddit. for sure.
 
and so it continues ... I have no idea what the "T&C"s are for a reddit moderator, and maybe reddit has the right to do so, but, how do users react? I put reddit in the camp of "social media" and it will be interesting to watch who "wins" here.
I am not a reddit user but I assume reddit makes the vast majority of its money through ads. Ads require clicks, so now it is up to the users...
I sure hope the users will speak and not participate in reddit anymore ...
As a former Reddit advertiser, I am sad to see the platform die, but it is dead. It was a fantastic place to advertise, even if it had a relatively small userbase. (You had to make your advertising a bit bursty. You could spend a bit of money for a short time, then you would have saturated your potential viewers and responses would quickly drop off. Give it a few weeks, then hit them again. Now that Twitter and Reddit are no longer viable social media platforms, I am wondering where will be the next good place to spend advertising dollars.
 
The CEO wants an IPO later in the year. Then in an effort to stop the AI folk and the like from using Reddit as basically a low cost research leg, small time devs get caught up and moderators revolt over that.



To go public, Reddit has to show their money via valuation is safe from shenanigans like this. So the revolting moderators have to go. What’s next, are hackers going to get involved?



I have no skin in this game so I just watch. I am affected a bit as some communities I frequent are shut down. Anyway, there were probably better alternatives to this but I have no skin in this game.
What's next is, advertisers walk away from the platform and consumers start walking away from companies that advertise on Reddit.
 
What I'd want the mods to do is just delete the unuseful subs.

Keep r/Apple and r/Hardware. All the rest of the mods just delete the subs that are decades old.
Just because it's not useful to you doesn't mean it's not useful to someone. I've hit private reddits in 2 searches for information this week, and none were for apple's. One was for Windows, the other was for midrange computer info. I'm less happy with the reddit moderators, because they're hiding information, than I am of the management, even though I think they're being stupid. At least the management isn't keeping me from the information directly.
 
What's next is, advertisers walk away from the platform and consumers start walking away from companies that advertise on Reddit.
This is what will be the death of them, it was not the NSFW content, it was always and will always be the money machine behind it. The free labor kept the overhead low and kept the place some what democratic, I dare say it was the thing elon screamed he wanted, self policing self regulating free place. The CEO saw a cash grab for him and his board and took it. There is nothing wrong with that, but if your company is not fit to sell warts and all then maybe its not right to sell it and explore other venues for capital.
 
Would love to see what an Apple built crowd governed forum would look like. Build it on ActivityPub for compatibility with Mastodon and other open platforms and deeply integrate it into iOS and macOS.

Let users create short posts on their own feeds (Twitter) and organize into channels for wider long form discussions (Reddit).

I can imagine hooks into Apple News with featured threads and crowd sourced breaking news coverage at a local level — something Twitter used to be good at.

At this point, Reddit can only be salvaged if Steve Huffman steps down. Same for Twitter and E… never mind, not going down that rabbit hole. I’d like to see how Apple’s design solutions and hardware/software integrations could be applied to the segment.
No thank you. Apple doesn't do social very well. Judging by how slanted their news app is I could only imagine the echo chamber an Apple social platform would become.
 
Lets note here these are UNPAID moderators, who are modding these subs on their own time for nothing in return...

Who the hell you going to replace them with?


Steve is making a running for worst tech CEO with Elon
Another person? Everyone is replaceable. There will be hundreds of volunteers to take their place.
 
The idea behind Reddit is great, and although there is some toxicity there, if you choose which communities to interact with, you can keep it down.

The implementation, though, is not optimal… if I had the capital, I just know I could come up with something similar but better than Reddit. But instead of doing that, they’re going the Elon Musk route. Choices.
 
That's part of why this isn't as easy for Reddit as some people think it is. If you replace the existing mods with mods who are terrible, you drive away users. If you don't replace them with any mods at all it becomes a 4chan-esque cesspool, again driving away users.
Well no content vs poorly managed content? At least SOME will stay if you have some content vs now where I have had 25 times now needed to use cache results from Google to see a solution to a problem I have. This is like if stackoverflow went on this train. Horrible for the users.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Shirasaki
Ummm, aren’t the mods preventing those in their communities that want to have their communities back doing a very similar thing? They removed their entire subs by going dark against the wishes of many in their own community.

Seems like the mods forcing their opinions onto others by closing the subs instead of just stopping using their accounts/deleting their accounts/however they want to personally boycott are just as bad, if not worse, than what they are “fighting” against.
Exactly. If these mods and ONLY THESE MODS (irreplaceable) are what makes the site. Just leave. If the communities turn to trash it will die anyway. But you are stopping me as a viewer to see content that’s been out there for years.
 
Exactly, people are acting like these moderators are brain surgeons. Any active member of a Reddit community can take over.
And you know the frustrating part about this? I wanted to link to a post I made. MY CONTENT. It had so many great details and information. But I can’t because the mod made the subreddit private.

This is just doing more harm than good. Can’t even access my own content because of a mod and this whole blackout mess.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.