Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This is a legitimate gripe. It's time for Lightning to go and bring in USB-C - that's the courage I want to see.
USB-C with Thunderbolt and OSX. Docks, mice, keyboards, drives, eGPUs and monitors stay on the desks.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: dan110
I've been hooking my phone up to my car via the USB port for the last 8 years. So pot meet kettle?


So, let me get this straight. You're saying that your experience in your vehicle is representative of the vast majority of people with vehicles?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Munibeast
It's about courage. And bravery. And being modern. And advancing.

And yet I am so glad that my iPhone has a headphone jack and my apple laptop has multiple USB ports!

I'm still on a 2012 MacBook Pro with a matte finish screen that doesn't act as a mirror, usb ports, removable RAM, Battery, optical disc drive, etc. etc. etc....

But somehow all this new crippled CRAP that apple is releasing is supposed to be better? LOL... what a joke this company has become.
 
It's about courage. And bravery. And being modern. And advancing.

And yet I am so glad that my iPhone has a headphone jack and my apple laptop has multiple USB ports!
Your Apple laptop that probably lacks:

- Ethernet
- ExpressCard
- DisplayPort 1.3
- eSATA
 
Why do you care? It ships with a dongle.

Because with USB-C, you can:
1) Simultaneously charge and listen to audio over wired headphones/speakers, and
2) Use a connector that others are adopting, instead of Apple's proprietary Lightning, and thereby be able to plug your listening device into many different source devices without needing an adapter. (Aka, what you're able to do with 3.5 mm devices now.)
 
I don't mind the removal of the headphone port. I prefer wireless headphones and have for a couple of years. But those AirPods look ridiculous. And 5 hours of playback time is pathetic. Good thing I don't have to buy them and can use one of the hundreds of other options available. Assuming I even buy the iPhone 7, which at this point I am leaning towards doing depending on what the next Nexus/Google phone is.
 
I don't care that they removed the headphone jack, I care that the replacement wired connector is proprietary.
If the iPhone had a USB-C or Thunderbolt connector instead of Lightning, I'd be all for it.

There are still good reasons to have wired headphones (or wireless with the ability to tether):

- Doesn't require any power
- No wireless signals (duh); I know some parents who insist their kids with wireless headsets listen tethered when not outdoors.

... but I'm never going to buy a pair of Lightning headphones, on principle. They won't work with my Mac, they won't work with my Gen 3 iPad, my Playstation, etc. I would happily buy a pair of USB-C plugs, though.
I don't know what Mac you have, but your Gen 3 iPad and Playstation won't take USB-C either, right?

USB to Lightning is pretty straight forward-- I'd expect the eventual USB-C to Lightning to be much the same:
https://www.amazon.com/OriDecor-Lightning-Converters-Transfer-Compatible/dp/B01E93RBTG/
Small, and 5 for $9, 10 for $17.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
In my opinion, this change is neither good nor bad. It's just neutral. Normally, a neutral change to the hardware wouldn't be a big deal. Apple could've switched wireless chip manufacturers for some minor reason. Who cares? Or they could've moved the camera from one corner of the top of the phone to the other corner. Meh. The discussion about the latter wouldn't have warranted more than one or two pages of discussion on here.

In this case, though, the neutral change (get rid of the audio jack, give people Lightning-to-3.5mm adapters) affects something many, many people use daily (namely: dirt-simple connection to existing headphones and other listening devices, which doesn't interfere w/ charging the phone). And these people get practically nothing in return.

If this had been a massively positive change, fewer people would be bitching about it. Free magical wireless earbuds w/ 12 hr battery life, which are wirelessly charged by the phone whenever the phone itself is charged? HELL YEAH. Alternately: if the reason for the removal of the 3.5 mm jack was to allow for some amazing new feature in the phone that the jack absolutely would not have allowed (none of the things the jack was supposedly getting in the way of were amazing, even taken cumulatively), people might've overlooked it.

Instead, the change is neutral. It's boring. There's no sexy component to it. It's not future shock--people aren't irritated because there's something new and interesting and disruptive happening, and they're scared of change. There is no damn change. It's nothing. And that's the problem, and Apple isn't sure how to spin it.
I really wouldn't call that neutral, it's obviously negative, as you pointed out in your lengthy post.
 
  • Like
Reactions: calabi-yau
How do I charge my phone and listen to music with my headphones at the same time? Do I have to buy a pair of wireless headphones to accomplish this now?
And the air pods have 5hrs of music playback? I do 8hrs a day as my job requires it and having my phone attached to headphones and charging is the easiest way for me.... I guess my 6s Plus better last awhile, when if finally goes I'll hope for better Wireless battery life or I'll have to move on I guess
 
I have no problems with Apple removing the jack as I've been using BT in-ear for the past year. My problem is those damn AirPods. They are hard plastic and just as uncomfortable as it's wired predecessor. I'm surprised Apple didn't take a cue from Bragi and come out with something similar but improved. I think Apple dropped the ball on this one.
 
Oh right, so I guess Sony are frigin technical geniuses then as they managed to make water proof headphone ports YEARS AGO!!!

If Apple are that inept at technical design, I highly suggest they hire some of Sonys mobile division engineers...

Or basically Apple is talking UTTER BS to give excuses for ditching the headphone jack which is far more likely..

Apple truely really are getting more and more arrogant and treating its customers with more and more contempt as the years role on.
Heading to the shower with my Z3 compact playing my favorite classical now. ;)
 
Actually, once sound comes out of a DAC, it is analogue. All sound we hear is analogue:

https://paulsmithblog.wordpress.com/2014/11/27/24-bit-recording/
Can someone explain why I keep seeing this repeated over and over like it means something special in this context? DAC specifically means "digital to analog converter"-- so even the name means analog comes out. We look at digital photos with our analog eyes, we listen to digital music with analog ears, we use a digital thermometer to measure our analog temperature, I'm an analog kid on a digital forum... None of this represents a tear in the fabric of the universe or anything-- why do people keep saying it?
 
I hope this new iPhone will flop. Then they would realise it was a mistake to remove it. I'll be fine with my SE for a couple of years but after that I guess I'll have to get a Samsung or whatever still has a headphone jack.
Changing your habits around using your operating system and app and entire ecosystem sounds like a lot of work just to save changing your habits around using a headphone jack.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ErikGrim
So your issue is the fact that the jack is analog, not necessarily that the jack is there in the first place? Would you have been okay if Apple upgraded the jack to digital, but kept the old form factor? And maybe for a while the jack was backwards-compatible with analog listening devices, while the device-makers had time to upgrade the devices to digital?

No I honestly don't care what they do. It's just a headphone jack. I'll probably hope something cool comes out that uses the lightning connector as an amplifier and has better sound. But it's not something I'll ever lose sleep over or comment on... doh!
 
Why do you care? It ships with a dongle.

I don't know what Mac you have, but your Gen 3 iPad and Playstation won't take USB-C either, right?

USB to Lightning is pretty straight forward-- I'd expect the eventual USB-C to Lightning to be much the same:
https://www.amazon.com/OriDecor-Lightning-Converters-Transfer-Compatible/dp/B01E93RBTG/
Small, and 5 for $9, 10 for $17.

You both don't get what I was talking about. I said I would never buy a pair of lightning earphones because they're not going to be compatible with anything else.

Yes, there's a dongle -- which goes from Analog (female) -> Lightning (male). In order to use lightning earphones with any other device on the planet, you'd need a Lightning (female) -> Analog (male) adaptor.

Also, there is no reasonable expectation that Lightning will ever be natively supported on any non-Apple device. USB-C and Thunderbolt are available and being used in non-Apple devices today.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
I think it's the other way around. There needs to be a good answer for why to change other than "it's old". The wheel is an old technology... Time to replace it! Preferably with something digital!

But there is several reasons.... Apple has already stated them. Whether you believe them or not, i cannot know or convince you otherwise.
[doublepost=1473306801][/doublepost]
Personally I have no objection to lightning connected headphones. I just need to charge the phone at the same time as having the headphones connected. I don't think that is a big request.

ok, that's a reasonable request, I have no answer, but I'm sure something will come up.
 
I wonder what the life span of the adapter will be? You would think with regular usage it would break rather quickly. And say you wanted to charge the phone at the same time as using the 3.5mm adapter, how would that even work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Munibeast
Wow. This one just never dies does it?

Unless you are an android, your ears can ONLY hear analog. This is not really a debate about digital vs. analog. Whether the sound comes out of a 3.5mm headphone jack or the adapter, it is analog when it gets to your ears. We cannot hear digital music without conversion to analog.

If you ARE an android, forgive me. But you are the exception... I think:eek: (better check the latest batch of memos).

And if pretty much ALL of you are androids, forgive me. No wonder there is such passion for this change. I'm unfortunately a lowly human with biological ears that can't hear the music delivered as a bitstream of 1s & 0s. Your offense at my personal opinions as a human consumer makes perfect sense to me now.;)

Nice rant, but I'm just talking about the connector. Unless you're listening to vinyl all the time I don't see what your beef is with digital signals.
[doublepost=1473307077][/doublepost]
That's the problem with Apple fan boys. They will try to justify this and yet a feature they suddenly said, it's something they can't live without. Silly little rabbit, trix is for kids, but in this case...the sheeps, I mean Apple fan boys.
[doublepost=1473300486][/doublepost]
You mad?
[doublepost=1473300603][/doublepost]
You mad?

you troll?
 
Still don't understand why people are comparing this to things like the removal of the floppy disk and cassette players. Each of those things were replaced by better technologies. Ditching a wired technology with a wireless one isn't the same thing, but rather something that complements existing things. For example, Wi-Fi isn't a replacement for Ethernet, for without Ethernet, you generally wouldn't have Wi-Fi.

From the interview, it just sounds like Apple couldn't fix a supposed issue that they were having. Were they telling the truth, or was it lazy engineering? We'll never truly know.

There was literally nothing wrong with the 3.5mm jack.

Agreed. This isn't like the removal of the floppy drive or the DVD drive. It's a hostile decision forcing you to use a proprietary cable with this phone. If you want to use your expensive headphones that you can use on nearly any other audio device on the planet, you have bring a dongle, which you can lose. It seems so far from the beautiful and elegant engineering that brought me into the Apple universe. Protruding cameras that stick out even farther than before, no headphone jack. No thank you. The first year I don't buy a new iPhone. I hope that if you're as unhappy about this decision as I am, you will do the same.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.