Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Report Insists Apple Will Eliminate iTunes Store Music Downloads in Future
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I'd think this is a sticking point for a lot of people... or it should be. Or maybe I have no idea because I have never paid for the streaming of anything.
Can somebody who streams music enlighten me? I'm guessing you can actually download the songs onto your device for offline usage, yeah? Surely you don't need a connection every time you want to listen to music!
On a cultural note, I don't think young people are into music the way previous generations were and this shift is all part of that. Not owning it and just having access to it on your device creates a different attachment to music. That's not to say young people don't love music, they do. It's just more whimsical now. Perhaps that's a good thing. Perhaps it's not. Music is certainly not as socially relevant or on the cutting edge of issues like it used to be though. Before, social issues were often raised through music, now it's immediate on social media. Music is slow to the dance in comparison.
EDIT: I just saw that you can indeed DL music for offline use. that makes it highly attractive. IF I didn't already own an insane amount of music, I'd entertain the idea!
Can't get any clearer or more definitive than that.
Sounds like it's an absolutely, in the strongest terms, maybe d/ls will be available in 5 years.Wow, seriously what the hell are they smoking? Guess I should start coding a LimeWire clone with a nice flat and intuitive interface so it's ready when this happen and BOOM profit for me
Oh I definitely see the other side of the argument. I do it for the killer early adopter price and for the convenience. I have a very extensive personally-purchased and curated library that I wouldn't miss a beat cancelling my subscription. It's just cheaper to spend the 10 bucks (or 8 in my case) to fill in the gaps of music I've missed or wanted to sample but not actually buy (new stuff too). It just works for me. Obviously, mileage varies per person.
true, but I doubt apple will continue to make non-iOS iPods so that you can purchase music elsewhere....they want you to stream from Apple Music.
That was how long ago?
I didn't say it was a bad thing or good thing. You added the negative context yourself. It's just demographically that is the case that older people prefer to own their music. https://musicmachinery.com/2014/02/13/age-specific-listening/
If you scroll down you can clearly see the correlation between age and ownership of music....and that was in 2011 before Apple Music and streaming really surpassed sales in generating revenue for record labels. http://www.which-50.com/music-streaming-death-itunes/
Last edited:
Thats why streaming services give you the option to download tracks to your device. When you download the track from iTunes, it still has to get to your device somehow.... or does that not count as data usage?
I'd find that hard to believe. As they'd need to make a mechanism for everyone to download their current music, the option would still be there anyways...
From Apple Music - "You can download music on up to 10 devices. These songs are accessible only during your Apple Music membership."
Paying a monthly streaming service for life - NO THANKS - just let me buy it and download it permanantly to my devices.
It would be the last day anyone bought music from Apple.
Still sucks though. I know several graphic designers and videographers that were left SOL thanks to this move.
Maybe they meant simplifying their monthly budget. I can see how subscriptions for Apple Music + Office365 + Netflix + TextExpander + AdobeCC can quickly get out of hand.
Back on topic, if Apple stops selling downloads I'll go back to buying and ripping CDs. Loss for Apple, win for JB Hifi and the Australian economy. Apple charges top dollar for digital downloads and gives our Government the finger when they ask for taxes.
I added it? Whid? You wrote in CAPS the word OLD spelling out your agist agenda implicitly.
Continuing to read all this talk about "planned" or "forthcoming" changes at Apple - I'd just like Apple to remove the DRM from my iBooks and set me free from the eco-system - will you do that for me Apple?
Last edited:
This is good news, regardless of how many MR users throw tantrums. I used to avoid streaming until I discovered Rdio had a great music discovery UX at its core. Even then, I would download the music for my iTunes library as opposed to just relying on Rdio alone.
With Apple Music, I have all of my music in one place, and I have great means for music discovery. I know that when I press "add to my music library", or "add to playlist", it'll probably go there and remain there. Apple is a fairly consistent company, and music purchasing is DEAD to the younger generation. Other than a few obvious outliers, the only people I know who still care to buy music are all 40+ years old.
Streaming is inevitable, and the only other viable source of music purchasing should be based around physical copies with thouroughly designed and collectible packaging. Vinyl's and box sets are still big deals for me, but I will never buy an iTunes Store music download unless they've managed to somehow make it ridiculously cool and special in comparison with the streaming counterpart (which they won't.)
Having said that: if they don't seriously fix the UIX of Apple Music to be less clunky and backwards, they probably shouldn't be removing their tried and true purchase store.
With Apple Music, I have all of my music in one place, and I have great means for music discovery. I know that when I press "add to my music library", or "add to playlist", it'll probably go there and remain there. Apple is a fairly consistent company, and music purchasing is DEAD to the younger generation. Other than a few obvious outliers, the only people I know who still care to buy music are all 40+ years old.
Streaming is inevitable, and the only other viable source of music purchasing should be based around physical copies with thouroughly designed and collectible packaging. Vinyl's and box sets are still big deals for me, but I will never buy an iTunes Store music download unless they've managed to somehow make it ridiculously cool and special in comparison with the streaming counterpart (which they won't.)
Having said that: if they don't seriously fix the UIX of Apple Music to be less clunky and backwards, they probably shouldn't be removing their tried and true purchase store.
I've purchased plenty of songs and albums on iTunes. Apple Music will never see a dime of mine however.
See this is how folks end up broke. They buy off into these company tag lines to milk you out of every single penny you have. Let's look at all the transaction the average consumer has to deal with media wise:
1. Pay for internet connection.
2. Pay for mobile data plan with LIMITED minutes.
3. Pay for XBOX LIVE or PS PLUS subscription.
4. NETFLIX.
5. Cable + Premium Channels.
6. Apple Music.
7. Random App with Subscription.
8. Freemium Apps with Micro transactions.
Considering the fact that these are never-ending bills, your wallet is pretty much under siege. How anybody can co-sign on this baffles me?
I keep seeing folks throw around statements about old folks are the only ones that want to own music which I don't think is the case. Older folks typically make more money than younger folks so why would someone with limited income be jumping up for joy at the chance to lose the few extra pennies they make a month? Again, truly baffling.
Last edited:
To me, music streaming subscription doesn't really make sense for people who really curate what they listen to (unless if it is at a very high volume); it does for people who listen to what's hot right now, and just moves on to something else whenever there's something new...
The way I see it, I pay 10$ for an album that I will listen to a bunch of times over that year, and over the years to come, so the price/listen is very low. Subscription though, I keep paying for it, for basically the same product. And yes subscription is basically the price of an album/month, and right now that might be what I buy... But I already see that at almost 30 I buy less music than I did in my teens, who knows what my music buying habits will be later in life... And subscription is a life-sentence; whenever I stop buying new music (at least at a rate that would make subscription worth-while) then if I want to keep listening to the songs I've been listening again and again for years, I have to keep paying.
The way I see it, I pay 10$ for an album that I will listen to a bunch of times over that year, and over the years to come, so the price/listen is very low. Subscription though, I keep paying for it, for basically the same product. And yes subscription is basically the price of an album/month, and right now that might be what I buy... But I already see that at almost 30 I buy less music than I did in my teens, who knows what my music buying habits will be later in life... And subscription is a life-sentence; whenever I stop buying new music (at least at a rate that would make subscription worth-while) then if I want to keep listening to the songs I've been listening again and again for years, I have to keep paying.
I can understand why some people might be upset if Apple stopped allowing music downloads in iTunes, but I'm completely fine with it. I've always bought audio CDs from Amazon and ripped them to my computer. I guess I'm still old school because I love having the album artwork.
Isn't this article suggesting that this is precisely what Apple will get rid of?
When you buy a new track, sure then you download the track from iTunes and it uses data, but you only need to do this once. When streaming you need to use download data every time you want to listen to the track and every other track you listen to.
Probably going to happened in 2030..... I cannot remember when was the last time I brought a CD...????? I've also stop buying songs on iTunes and rarely listen to my music.... Yikes!! Sorta gotten bored with it and now into Audiobooks. Oh well
I cannot remember when was the last time I brought a CD...????? I've also stop buying songs on iTunes and rarely listen to my music.... Yikes!! Sorta gotten bored with it and now into Audiobooks. Oh well Also think about this, right now Apple Music, Spotify, and all these big wigs in the streaming market, are in the infantile stage. So right now the prices, would be relative cheaper, because they want to acquire market. But once they become the one and only option. What do you think this companies are going to do?
They will juice up the subscription prices. So let's say you have invested a lot of money, in Spotify, or Apple Music, they are the market leader, and ran all competition out business. Once they have consolidated the market,they will raise the price. I guess that is one of the things I fear about subscriptions. They will gradually squeeze every cent, and they prices will go up, once they now you are hooked and have no other options.
I will try to just stay with my own library, for as long as I can. If that means going to Android Phone, because Apple no longer wants to serve my needs. I guess that will have to be the path, I will have to take.
They will juice up the subscription prices. So let's say you have invested a lot of money, in Spotify, or Apple Music, they are the market leader, and ran all competition out business. Once they have consolidated the market,they will raise the price. I guess that is one of the things I fear about subscriptions. They will gradually squeeze every cent, and they prices will go up, once they now you are hooked and have no other options.
I will try to just stay with my own library, for as long as I can. If that means going to Android Phone, because Apple no longer wants to serve my needs. I guess that will have to be the path, I will have to take.