Re: Re: Macrumors liability
No, but you may own a copy of said book. You just don't have a copyright to it. I understand that copying the book without copyright is illegal and that distributing the copy is illegal. But if I happen to possess such an illegal copy, am I guilty of any crime? This seems fuzzier to me.
Frankly, this is just one more example of why digital content and the law do not mix very well. We are compelled to resort to analogies that never hold up very well and mislead as much or more as they illuminate.
Originally posted by arn
Well, that may be a different issue. Copyright is not revoked when someone is sold a copy of a piece of work. If I buy a book... or even an eBook, it doesn't mean that the contents are no longer copyrighted.
What about books? Even if you say you own the "book", you don't have the right to copy it and distribute it... right?
arn
No, but you may own a copy of said book. You just don't have a copyright to it. I understand that copying the book without copyright is illegal and that distributing the copy is illegal. But if I happen to possess such an illegal copy, am I guilty of any crime? This seems fuzzier to me.
Frankly, this is just one more example of why digital content and the law do not mix very well. We are compelled to resort to analogies that never hold up very well and mislead as much or more as they illuminate.