Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Doesn't matter how old the 4S is now, it's obvious people want big screens. 4.5 and bigger wouldn't sell if people didn't want one. I think that's quite obvious and Apple should act fast or they risk losing market quickly. A 4 inch iPhone now when 4.7 is normal would be a little toy. Bigger than the 3.5 we have now, but still really small. Regardless of your opinion on Android, people just want big phones, including me and 4 just won't cut it.
 
The largest difference is not having to code different shaders and make it as complex as possible to develop on the Android OS. Major differences occur in the actual assets that are saved on your memory card. Making the app far easier to update instead of having to download the entire package such as iOS devices.

Having a game development background, I can tell you nightmares of simple console ports even back to the 16 bit players.
DOS/Windows? Been there too.

That is completely awesome.
 
That is completely awesome.

The worst of all of those years... PlayStation to Sega Saturn ports.

The largest problem being as while the original PlayStation used triangles for 3D objects, the Saturn calculated in quads. Making 3D games on the Saturn have a more "chunky" look to them or clipping issues.

Compare the Resident Evil port to the Saturn vs. The PlayStation. Or many others from EA.
 
The worst of all of those years... PlayStation to Sega Saturn ports.

The largest problem being as while the original PlayStation used triangles for 3D objects, the Saturn calculated in quads. Making 3D games on the Saturn have a more "chunky" look to them or clipping issues.

Compare the Resident Evil port to the Saturn vs. The PlayStation. Or many others from EA.

It's somewhat difficult for me to visualize how this would have affected things, as I have no idea what kind of poly counts either of those systems could handle. Of course that wouldn't have been used given the cost of rendering such a thing in real time. I'm picturing the results of trying to tessellate solely in quads along erratic curvature. Assuming you're trying to get some amount of evenness to avoid jacked up deformation, it is more difficult with quads. I thought at a hardware level they were all transformed to triangles when rendered by the gpu though? I remember the Saturn, but I never played anything on it. I'm not sure what the advantage of quads would have been with real time models where subdivision wouldn't be used.
 
Now before you get your knickers in a wad, what I sad was an example. When you think about it, the original iPad is not that old at all but is now completely unsupported in recent apps.

Care to point out what apps are unsupported? I have the original iPad, and there are only a few I've seen. None have been recent. The ones I've seen are mostly camera apps, and that's a given as to why.
 
I know i'll never own an iPhone now, having used one once, it felt cheap nasty and made by the lowest bidder. Quality was not important. I'll say the same about Samsung as well, the Mrs has one, absolutely horrible. Cheap and nasty, just like the iPhone.


So still rocking that 1980's motorola brick phone? That phone never felt cheap, only nasty.
 
iPhone users today:

3.5" is perfectly fine for phones. Anything else is too big and not needed.


September 12: Apple today unveils the iPhone 5 with a 4.5" (or w/e size) screen. It's like a theater in your hand.

iPhone users reactions:

OMG 4.5"!!!!!!! This is so awesome. 3.5" is way to small now! This is the greatest thing ever.

Android users:
Oh...
Image

This isn't an anti-iPhone comment, just stating the what's likely to be the reactions if there is a new screen. The iPhone is a great phone, but after comparing it to some Android devices it's way too small IMP. With that said there's also some Android phones out there that are way to big. I would say 4.75" would be the max for a phone.

This is nothing but strawmen and stereotypes. The rantings of a few fanboys do not speak for "iPhone users today". The most common opinion that I see from iPhone users about the screen size debate is that they don't care either way. The current size works. Screen size is less important than the rest of the package. As long as Apple doesn't make the phone too big for ergonomic use and deals with app development issues, whatever they do with the screen size is fine. As long as the tradeoffs are dealt with, more screen real estate would be great.
 
Last edited:
Let's check the facts on Apple's iPhone sales (this is the total sales of 4S, 4 and 3GS per quarter), shall we? You can do the math:

2012 Q1: 37 million
2012 Q2: 35 million
2012 Q3: 26 million
2012 Q4: 20 million (est)

See a trend? I am sure initial demand for the iPhone 5 will be strong, but like the 4S we will see a quick down turn. People are tired of the same crap coming out of Apple. Sales (or lack there of) is all we need to see to affirm this position.

To see the real trend you should make comparisons between each quarter and the previous year quarter.

You'd see only positive trend since 2007!!
 
Care to point out what apps are unsupported? I have the original iPad, and there are only a few I've seen. None have been recent. The ones I've seen are mostly camera apps, and that's a given as to why.

Fresh in the featured section...

Bastion


Another.
Adobe Photoshop Touch

...

I'm not going to waste my morning for this.

Denial or acceptance, choose your poison...
 
As much as I like my iPhone 4S, I must admit I like my Galaxy S III even better.

There's a lot to be said for all of the features, how easily one can tailor it to their liking, and the speed that one experiences.

Competition is good for everyone, and if this is what Apple needs to wake them up, then it's all worth it.

...

Denial or acceptance, choose your poison...

just wanted to share with you all. looks like you both own Android phones. give the following apps a try. i think they will come handy.

gesture search - hand gesture universal search. indexes everything on phone, contacts, apps, music.

airdroid - perform 90% of tasks using wifi. transfer files, send/receive messages, app management etc. any computer through Chrome, Firefox or IE etc.

mysms - send/receive sms through a website even when the phone is not within reach. the only requirement is the phone must be on and have signal. really handy in offfice or school environment.
 
So still rocking that 1980's motorola brick phone? That phone never felt cheap, only nasty.

It still has useful features...

Doorstop
Coffee Table conversation piece
Murder weapon
Jack stand
Partial steampunk prop
Parking chuck

All that without taking a bit of damage.

;)
 
To see the real trend you should make comparisons between each quarter and the previous year quarter.

You'd see only positive trend since 2007!!

Yeah, let's compare last year's quarters to this year's, since half of 2011 the iphone was only on att or just released to Verizon. In 2012, it was on all carriers and added to the Chinese market as well.

Gee, I wonder why Apple had more sales this year, than last year? Is this concept to tough to grasp for those with an Apple shaped logo on their phone? The real statistic is falling sales this entire year and the sales carriers have had to offer to get them off their shelves.
 
Yeah, let's compare last year's quarters to this year's, since half of 2011 the iphone was only on att or just released to Verizon. In 2012, it was on all carriers and added to the Chinese market as well.

Gee, I wonder why Apple had more sales this year, than last year? Is this concept to tough to grasp for those with an Apple shaped logo on their phone? The real statistic is falling sales this entire year and the sales carriers have had to offer to get them off their shelves.

It's fantastic that you think iPhone sales jumping from 70-75 million a year with the iPhone 4 to 120-125 million a year with the iPhone 4S is an indicator that "People are tired of the same crap coming out of Apple." :D
 
It's fantastic that you think iPhone sales jumping from 70-75 million a year with the iPhone 4 to 120-125 million a year with the iPhone 4S is an indicator that "People are tired of the same crap coming out of Apple." :D

Just as I think it's cute you are unable to see a correlation between opening a market or adding carriers as the reason you see the YoY jump from 2011 to 2012 in such dramatic fashion. And at the same time stick your head in the sand and ignore the huge sale figures losses, quarter after quarter this year!

I guess when you are Blind with such devout faith in apple, acknowledging factual data that shines any negative light upon your logo is simply ignored and replaced with whatever the flavor of the day excuse is. Great for you, but I prefer the real world.
 
you are unable to see a correlation between opening a market or adding carriers as the reason you see the YoY jump from 2011 to 2012 in such dramatic fashion.

I see the numbers, but I understand that other market forces besides customer apathy can explain them. I also see that Apple still leads the mobile phone industry in customer satisfaction (increasing its rating from JD Power this year).

I understand that increased availability and distribution of the iPhone is responsible for some of the increase. I see that the iPhone 4 was limited through the first half of it's life by availability issues, thus causing sales to even out over it's lifespan. I see built up demand for the 4S, based on the extra quarter than the iPhone 4 was sold, that frontloaded sales for the 4S. I see that the 4S was released in the holiday quarter, which negated the holiday bump seen by the iPhone 4 in its second quarter of release.

I could go on, but hopefully, you get the idea that there is more to the analysis than "Number go down = bad".
 
Need to look at the bigger picture

What is missed here is that Samsung segments the market with different devices. Between the Galaxy S3 and Galaxy Note II they will sell about 50 million additional units by end of year. There will also be other Galaxy series phones on the lower end which will sell another 10 million units world wide by end of year. Yes, the iPhone 5 will be a big hit and sell 50 million units in 3 months or so, but that is ok since Samsung with all models won't do to badly either. Net profit will still be high for both companies.

There are a couple of other Samsung devices coming out like the Galaxy Beam and Galaxy Nexus 2 by end of year.
 
just wanted to share with you all. looks like you both own Android phones. give the following apps a try. i think they will come handy.

gesture search - hand gesture universal search. indexes everything on phone, contacts, apps, music.

airdroid - perform 90% of tasks using wifi. transfer files, send/receive messages, app management etc. any computer through Chrome, Firefox or IE etc.

mysms - send/receive sms through a website even when the phone is not within reach. the only requirement is the phone must be on and have signal. really handy in offfice or school environment.

I have plenty of different phones, my daily driver is just my Galaxy S2 (which used to be a BlackBerry Bold 9700).

I get quite a few review units and misc phones I've used over the years. I'm actually starting to like the route Nokia is going with their WP8 models and existing models. They are solid devices.

One way I observe the Android phones vs. the iPhone, is that Android devices are very much like a PC built to run a common platform (Android) where you can say the iPhone is similar to the closed ecosystem of Mac hardware running OS X.

In the end, all this technology is something I have a passion for. I love gadgets and gizmos. Smartphones are just what happens to be the most hotly debated item when in the end, it's made to make phone calls. Everything else is just a neat feature.
 
Have you seem the iPhone screen?? 3.5 inches, so tiny, size hasn't changed since 07, Jesus Christ!!

it's a phone, it's not a tablet. I want something that slips into my pocket and I can't even notice it's there.
 
As much as I like my iPhone 4S, I must admit I like my Galaxy S III even better.

There's a lot to be said for all of the features, how easily one can tailor it to their liking, and the speed that one experiences.

Competition is good for everyone, and if this is what Apple needs to wake them up, then it's all worth it.

Great observation - and apple DOES NEED to wake up - or they risk losing people.

----------

Is form factor the only thing that matters to you?

No but screen size clearly is an issue for many. The larger screens on nearly all the competition phones is turning heads... and perhaps loyalties.
 
The SGS3 is a very nice phone. I'm very impressed with it but I have to think that is the closest to the iPhone one can get without actually owning an iPhone; for very obvious reasons. (beat dead horse) It's a bit large for my pocket though.

finally someone gets it.

the only thing Samsungs Galaxy S3 has is it's large screen. but people will quickly find out that size does not mean better. There is a reason why apple kept the iphone screen at 3.5 for so long. they did not want to compromise the compact footprint. The iphone 5 represents a slight increase in foot print and screen size. the enginerring of such a device is really impressive as they must utilise every mm of space. The secret of the Samsung Galaxy s3's thiness is result of a thin fragile plastic case and a much larger footprint to spread out the internal components which is disguised with a pretty big screen wich at full bright ness will drain the life out of the phone. to get the 10 hour life span one would need to lower brightness to the lowest level, turn off wifi, blue tooth, 4G, and end running aplications. iphone user don't need to do nearly that much to get the 10 hour life span.
 
Nope. 6 million was global sales. In July, another analyst has claimed the iPhone was still gaining U.S. market share faster than all Android devices combined.

As far as the iPhone 5 being disappointing for many customers, I think you are jumping to conclusions based on a few forum posters and bloggers. :)

Hopefully I am wrong, we will see very soon.
 
finally someone gets it.

the only thing Samsungs Galaxy S3 has is it's large screen. but people will quickly find out that size does not mean better. There is a reason why apple kept the iphone screen at 3.5 for so long. they did not want to compromise the compact footprint. The iphone 5 represents a slight increase in foot print and screen size. the enginerring of such a device is really impressive as they must utilise every mm of space. The secret of the Samsung Galaxy s3's thiness is result of a thin fragile plastic case and a much larger footprint to spread out the internal components which is disguised with a pretty big screen wich at full bright ness will drain the life out of the phone. to get the 10 hour life span one would need to lower brightness to the lowest level, turn off wifi, blue tooth, 4G, and end running aplications. iphone user don't need to do nearly that much to get the 10 hour life span.

This is true. I don't get 10 hours use out of my iPhone though, I don't think. Either way, I agree that the one thing I noticed about the SGS3 is how light it was which tells me the plastic housing is quite fragile. A good case would absolutely be necessary and then some. I still like the phone though. :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.