Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I use iPad mini to do double duty- tablet AND phone (with buds using VOIP app). I don't really feel like I miss a thing and data plan is much less expensive than phone plans ($60 PER YEAR for continuous 5G). I'm happy with this choice and it works exceptionally well for my needs.

However, the ONE thing that matters to me that iPhone has and this doesn't is pocket-ability. If iPad mini could effectively fold in half and/or roll into a cigar-like cylinder, that would deliver easiest pocket-ablity... even easier than the original 3.5" iPhones... without having to give up the much larger screen (and pay much more cost for device and service).

This thread is full of people viewing this as some kind of threat to iPhone- or Apple- or the long-established iPhone form factor... that foldable phones "have no use cases", etc. Of course, bulk opinion was the same when Apple clung to 3.5" and 4" screens as "perfect" (size) vs. the "abomination" phablets: "one-handed use", "pants with bigger pockets", developer "fragmentation", blah, blah, blah. Then Apple adopts phablet sizes and its as if we didn't feel that way at all: "how did we ever get by without..." and "shut up and take my money"... even ridiculing the now "too little" screen sizes of the old to try to sell each other on buying the new.

If Apple launched an iPhone fold or a rollable phone as implied here, there would suddenly be "use cases" galore... suddenly "how did we ever get by without..."... suddenly abundant "problems best solved by this and only this (from Apple) solution"... and "shut up and take my money." It's only "stupid" and "useless" now because Apple doesn't have a version themselves for sale now... as it seemingly is in ALL things before Apple offers their version of whatever it is.

To those who are actually able to "think different" which- in my definition, does NOT include a definition of "unless your thinking deviates from what Apple has for sale right now";)- I encourage you to NOT view this as a monumental change/threat to iPhone... but instead as a potential way for an iPad to fold or perhaps roll down to a container that becomes even more pocketable than iPhone. Imagine the potential of merging big iPad-like screens and small iPhone screens in ONE device.

That's basically what I do now with iPad mini. It is my cell phone when I need a mobile phone but a much more usable bigger-screen iPad when I want to do anything & everything else with it (which is the vast majority of the time). I tuck it under an arm instead of being able to put it in a pocket. If only it could fold or roll.

That's how I see all of this line of stuff... a way to have a much bigger screen than (still relatively) tiny iPhone screens AND get the easy pocket-ability benefit too. Perhaps it's just me but that would be a VERY APPEALING product.
 
Last edited:
Gotta start somewhere. Without Samsung, we would still have 3.5” iPhones and 4gb storage for $1999
iPadOS is the result of no competition. Saw the same with intel before Ryzen
Rewind back when the largest screened iPhone was 4". I'm at a career fair, the lines are long, so I strike conversations with those around. Quite a few older attendees were on the older side (they were in their 40s, 50s, and even beyond). We talk tech. One common theme was the ones that were NOT using iPhones were doing so because a 4" screen was just too damn tiny! Many were Samsung using phones instead. They didn't hate Samsung, but they preferred an iPhone. At least Apple finally delivered with the iPhone 6 (4.7") and 6+ (5.5").

I also really enjoyed micro SD card slots. Nowadays, my first Android phone without without that has 128 GB of storage, so it's not really an issue (at least for my use cases), but back then, it was a nice workaround to not being hamstrung by that part
 
All they have to do is buy InWith Corp and they do not need much more.

haha thanks for the laugh, Apple making reliable stuff... maybe once, but users have always been beta testers ( NEVER BUY REV A Apple products has always been a mantra).

From Cracking to broken ribbon cables to failing keyboards and nvidia cards... Apple is not as reliable as you might think.
With Apple, you are the software tester :D
 
With Apple, you are the software tester :D
Honestly, yeah. And I blame consumers for this. When Apple didn’t have to manage support for multiple models their software was top notch. Without someone to slap wrists and throw prototypes we are seeing a return of the Sculley Apple.
 
  • Like
Reactions: yabeweb
I think they should release a phone with multiple screens that are like pages in a book, so you can just flip them over and look at the different screens just like pages in a magazine. This would be great for porn and advertisements, and that's where it's at these days. That's what internet is for now. Porn and advertisements. Well also mind manipulation and suppression of thinking bad and unhealthy things. A magazine phone is the ultimate expression of modern internet.
The fact that we so flippantly talk about looking at porn is proof enough that yes, the internet has brainwashed us in ways that are unhealthy.
 
Wasnt this what they used in the movie 'Red Planet'? I think they also used it for augmented reality.
 
Although some of this tech looks kinda cool at first glance… I am still not sold. The screen is not that much bigger scrolled all the way out. Plus dust issues. The same thing with foldable phones so far having crease issues. No wonder Apple hasn’t jumped in on any of these yet. They just aren’t ready for primetime. Gonna stick with my iPhone Pro Max.
 
This technology always makes for an impressive demo but from the start, all the way back so many years ago when Samsung first started vapor-waring the living daylights out of this concept, I've tried to figure out what problem it's solving. You can't fold or do away with the phone itself so how does being able to bend or roll the screen matter in any way? I mean, if they were able to shrink the phone components down to the size where you could roll or fold the entire phone down in size, then maybe there's a benefit, but this always feels like one of those solutions in search of a problem. I don't understand the fascination with it.
 
That rollable oppo prototype:


does look like magic.

When you hear it described it sound over engineered but the result is great and actually of benefit. Something you can put in your pocket but can be expanded when you need it to be.
Amazing!

I’d personally love this but I can see Apple not releasing it as it cannibalizes the iPad and of course, they want iPhone users to buy an iPad and not have an all in one device..
 
Remember Apple’s whole Butterfly keyboard debacle? Well, imagine if instead of returning to scissor they had released an improved version with more key travel to fix it on future models.

Now imagine making this exact same comment about that release. That’s what you’re doing here. This is the fix for the current foldables’ main issues. It’s not something new for the sake of being new.

Okay that's logical, but Samsung has been pushing this technology in a decidedly imperfect form for over a decade at this point. Comparing this to Apple's Butterfly keyboard issues is a little disingenuous. At some point, people can get fed up with a company continuing to "fix" issues with an overhyped technology that simply isn't ready. Samsung could have just kept all this under wraps all these years and kept their heads down getting this right but they chose to go the standard hype/vapor-ware route. It's reasonable that people would get a little exasperated with that and critique it.

You know, fool me once....
 
Apple’s big thing was thinking different, and giving products user didn’t even know they need. I really feel like Samsung has taken a page off that playbook. Maybe this isn’t something we never knew we needed, but at least they’re trying new things. I hope Apple releases their AR/VR glasses soon. These minor little updates to products they’ve now had for years, is showing they’re lacking in the innovation.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Macative
That rollable oppo prototype:


does look like magic.

When you hear it described it sound over engineered but the result is great and actually of benefit. Something you can put in your pocket but can be expanded when you need it to be.
I'll admit, it is an impressive proof of concept. But it is still a solution for a problem that doesn't exist. I don't have a need to make my 6" phone into a 7" phone. And I certainly don't have a desire for the entire product design to be compromised and focused around making my 6" phone into a 7" phone.

Wake me when the 6" phone can become a 12" tablet. Then you'll have something. When it can double as 2 different devices that have distinct use cases, then it matters.
 
Remember Apple’s whole Butterfly keyboard debacle? Well, imagine if instead of returning to scissor they had released an improved version with more key travel to fix it on future models.

Now imagine making this exact same comment about that release. That’s what you’re doing here. This is the fix for the current foldables’ main issues. It’s not something new for the sake of being new.
I wish Apple had reverted back to scissor with more key travel. If they'd just gone back and stuck the late 2013 MacBook pro keyboard in their computers, I'd have purchased three of them by now.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.