Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Screen protectors - naysayers stay out
- Thread starter puckhead193
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I’m trying out a glass one on my wife’s 7. Very strange install with the liquid adhesive but seems to be very nice. I can’t imagine hot water affecting it at all.
Previously on her S4 I used LK screen protectors that I mentioned previously. On her S4 these would last a very long time before needing to be replaced.
On her S7 they don’t seem to last. They start to peel in a month. This is the reason for trying out a glass sp. We’ll see how well the glass holds up.
I use Ghost Armor on my apple watch. its damn near invisible, covers the full face of the watch and is inexpensive. Plus if you do damage the screen protector they will replace it for just $5. I've already had it replaced once because i banged my watch into a door knob. Watch had no damage, but the screen cover got a scuff. $5 later I had a fresh protector. its swim & shower proof and survived the heat in Mexico with no issues.
Thank you for the replies. Let me rephrase a bit, it didn't quite peal off, it felt more like it slid off or at least it came loose(these are I am assuming tempered glass). Of course these were the $10 cheapo ones from Amazon. I will look into your recommendations but I kinda wish there was something that works similar to Watchshell which I had on my Rolexes. Those are also applied using a liquid adhesive they supplied with the kit, so far with Watchshell I can swim and shower without issue.
Update: Unfortunately Ghost Armor does not seem to have a protector for my model. LK does but it seems to not be water resistant when I tried to shower with it. Someone on reddit recommended ESR and so far it works pretty well, unlike the other protectors this one covers the entire bezel and has a gasket underneath. To me it kinda interfere with the overall aesthetics of the watch, but it does seem to hold up pretty well over the long weekend. I'll keep it on for now, or maybe just go without a protector. I've banged it a few times before and so far there are no dents or scratches so I might just go without.
Update: Unfortunately Ghost Armor does not seem to have a protector for my model. LK does but it seems to not be water resistant when I tried to shower with it. Someone on reddit recommended ESR and so far it works pretty well, unlike the other protectors this one covers the entire bezel and has a gasket underneath. To me it kinda interfere with the overall aesthetics of the watch, but it does seem to hold up pretty well over the long weekend. I'll keep it on for now, or maybe just go without a protector. I've banged it a few times before and so far there are no dents or scratches so I might just go without.
Last edited:
Though I'm a long time Apple user, this 45mm series 8 aluminum is my first watch. Reading about horror stories of super scratched screens I started looking for something to protect mine and after reading page after page of iffy products here (hate the orange peel effect of some of the wet install films, tried it on an iPhone once) I bought the LK films. Other than aligning them, they are pretty easy to install once you've done it (and screwed up) the first one. So far I get about two weeks out of one before having to replace it. I put a new one on just now due to paint smears (or something) on the previous one after a few hours of yard work. It had started bubbling on the edges which is usually what leads me to replace them.
I'd prefer a glass protector but I remember the nightmares of trying to get one to work when Apple was selling phones with curved edges, so I probably won't go there. These films go on without affecting the performance or look of the watch.
Has anyone found a case that works with the LK films? I bought a rugged armer Spigen case but it just adds so much bulk and immediately starts peeling these films. I'm not as worried about the aluminum finish, it's a watch after all, but like the screen to stay as pristine as possible. It would be nice to have a case compatible with these films in certain situations though.
I'd prefer a glass protector but I remember the nightmares of trying to get one to work when Apple was selling phones with curved edges, so I probably won't go there. These films go on without affecting the performance or look of the watch.
Has anyone found a case that works with the LK films? I bought a rugged armer Spigen case but it just adds so much bulk and immediately starts peeling these films. I'm not as worried about the aluminum finish, it's a watch after all, but like the screen to stay as pristine as possible. It would be nice to have a case compatible with these films in certain situations though.
Built in protector maybe?
I've fitted one of these to my Mum's AW Series 8 with zero issues
I've fitted one of these to my Mum's AW Series 8 with zero issues
JETech Case with Screen Protector for Apple Watch Series 9 8 7 45mm, Overall Protective Cover, Built-in Tempered Glass Film High Sensitivity, 2 Pack (Black)
JETech Case with Screen Protector Compatible with Apple Watch Series 9 8 7 45mm, Overall Protective Cover, Built-in Tempered Glass Film High Sensitivity, 2 Pack
www.amazon.co.uk
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
I think I tried it and lost it in the swimming pool while swimming crawl. I personally find better the Misxi plastic cover, never lost it accidentally but I can remove it mainly for washing the watch from sweat or salt/chlorine. I don’t notice a decrease on the touch screen, about the look it’s a matter of taste but I find the transparent one not too invasive. And if I don’t want it for one evening I can remove it when I want. Without the covers I scratched my watch in no time.
I've just had the opportunity to try a Kamita clear protector on my Apple watch 8.
Easy enough to fit. And, initially, seemed OK.
But it became more and more annoying that it made the watch's touch screen less sensitive. And reflections from the surface were off-putting.
Have ended up deciding not to use it.
If I had a job that involved paint, dust, grease, etc., I can certainly see why protection is needed. But for my everyday life, I'm not convinced. Having had the watch for the best part of a year, and no obvious scratches or other damage just doesn't seem worth it.
Think I'd either take the watch off or use something like ordinary kitchen cling wrap if I were doing some decorating.
Easy enough to fit. And, initially, seemed OK.
But it became more and more annoying that it made the watch's touch screen less sensitive. And reflections from the surface were off-putting.
Have ended up deciding not to use it.
If I had a job that involved paint, dust, grease, etc., I can certainly see why protection is needed. But for my everyday life, I'm not convinced. Having had the watch for the best part of a year, and no obvious scratches or other damage just doesn't seem worth it.
Think I'd either take the watch off or use something like ordinary kitchen cling wrap if I were doing some decorating.
My brother in law has one. He works in selling large construction equipment and kept destroying his Stainless. And the Aluminum watch may was well just come with a case. I liked a leather case I got years back but I can't remember who made it.
I use a film screen protector, Supposedly a type of hydrogel. It comes with an alignment tray very easy to apply, 100% unnoticeable and zero touch sensitivity loss. I have been using them for months and no issues at all no bubbling no corners peeling up 100% satisfied. do I need it? my watches have the sapphire glass, which is scratch resistant, but not scratch proof, IMO better to have it and not need it, then to need it and not have it.
Has anyone used RhinoShield or Spiegen for their Ultra 2
Trying to decide what the difference is between the ‘Rugged’ and thin fit cases for Spiegen?
Also Rhinosheild seems to come with an additional thin ring around the front of the bumper that clips
Any advice appreciated?
Trying to decide what the difference is between the ‘Rugged’ and thin fit cases for Spiegen?
Also Rhinosheild seems to come with an additional thin ring around the front of the bumper that clips
Any advice appreciated?
Spigen - see my other thread
Wouldn't use any other; they've been faultless on my AWU & AWU2 and take 15 seconds to apply
Wouldn't use any other; they've been faultless on my AWU & AWU2 and take 15 seconds to apply
Spigen EZ Fit Tempered Glass Screen Protector for Apple Watch Ultra 3, Apple Watch Ultra 2, Apple Watch Ultra (49mm) - 2 Pack
Spigen EZ Fit Tempered Glass Screen Protector Guard for Apple Watch Ultra (49mm) - 2 Pack, Thank you for Purchasing our Product.
www.amazon.co.uk
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
Spigen since October 2023 with my Ultra 2. Easy to apply, not so scratch resistant: it’s time to change it with the second one of the pack.
Very impressed with the ESR Armorite on my black AWU2. Was never a fan of using a protector on the watch, but thought for the outlay I'd give it a go. Very impressed, doesn't affect the look or the screen quality. Seem to look better on the black watch than the natural.
Well worth a go.
Well worth a go.
Afraid not, but there are some on the amazon review pages:
ESR Armorite Watch
Edit: Added pics of mine.
Attachments
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
It looks great. It actually blends in very well.
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
I second the positive opinion about ESR for U2. I don't like to install screen protectors on my watches, this is the first one I tried, and in my opinion Ultra or U2 really doesn't need any screen protectors, since any protector out there is not going to outperform the sapphire glass. Every screen "protector" will scratch way easier than a sapphire glass which is practically unscratchable unless it meets a diamond ring or another sapphire, then yes you may scratch it. I have many watches older and newer with sapphire glass and none of them has a mark on it.
With that said, Ultra has a raised lip around the glass, and that what scratches! Like I said I usually don't like screen protectors and rather have a scratch that is a personality rather than looking at a cheap ugly protector. However this ESR is really different! I have installed it recently and it's actually almost impossible to tell it's there, still completely original look of U2 Black and now I'm not worried scratching the bezel which gets hit the first if you happen to contact the watch with anything. After installing it literally next day I got a scratch on the bezel, and I remember hitting it to something and thinking "OUCH", but was so pleased that it was not the naked titanium bezel but a bezel protector that I can exchange easily! As a naysayer of screen prtectors I totally recommend ESR - not for glass protection but for the bezel protection which can be scratched. And it's almost impossible to tell that there is a protector on the watch, so the original look of the beautiful U2 remains! Here's a picture, and believe me it looks much better in reality than on the picture.
With that said, Ultra has a raised lip around the glass, and that what scratches! Like I said I usually don't like screen protectors and rather have a scratch that is a personality rather than looking at a cheap ugly protector. However this ESR is really different! I have installed it recently and it's actually almost impossible to tell it's there, still completely original look of U2 Black and now I'm not worried scratching the bezel which gets hit the first if you happen to contact the watch with anything. After installing it literally next day I got a scratch on the bezel, and I remember hitting it to something and thinking "OUCH", but was so pleased that it was not the naked titanium bezel but a bezel protector that I can exchange easily! As a naysayer of screen prtectors I totally recommend ESR - not for glass protection but for the bezel protection which can be scratched. And it's almost impossible to tell that there is a protector on the watch, so the original look of the beautiful U2 remains! Here's a picture, and believe me it looks much better in reality than on the picture.
Attachments
Here's another shot of before (red dial)and after (blue dial) just to show in details how little if any ESR changes the original look of U2. Only one small thing I'm missing is a very thin polished line on the titanium bezel that catches the light sometimes and shines with a beautiful black diamond mirror like effect. Of course ESR bezel doesn't have that, but it's ok. On silver titanium it's more noticeable though. Other than that this is really good security not to damage your bezel. I hope this is helpful for those who are on the fence to get it or not.
Attachments
I have the LK screen protector with a Spigen Thin Fit case for my Series 10 46mm. For some reason, I get an air bubble that appears at the bottom of the screen that increases in size each day. Although I remove the case and smooth out the air bubble, it'll reappear the next day. Any suggestions?