Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The Magic Mouse is not for everyone. I bought one for evaluation, thinking I'd get two more for my other Macs if I liked it, but I just can't work with it. It looks great and the scrolling and other multitouch stuff is very nice, but from an ergonomic point of view the shape is just all kinds of wrong. You can't cup your hand around it, you just sort of nudge it around like some curious looking vegetable on your plate. I guess it's OK for casual surfing and other light tasks, but if you're doing serious work at your computer 10 hours a day you'll end up with carpal tunnel syndrome all the way down to your ankles if you rely on a Magic Mouse. It's not a tool[/], it's a... thing. It's like trying to run a marathon on high heels (not that I've worn any). Also, the tracking speed appears a tad slower than the Mighty Mouse (as if that one wasn't slow as molasses already), so you need a mouse pad the size of a ping pong table.

I now very reluctantly stick with my wireless Mighty Mouse. It was never an ideal mouse either, but at least it feels good in your hand. I would much prefer a Logitech mouse, but I guess I'm letting form go before function here... I just bought white desks, white JustMobile AluPad mouse pads and the keyboards are obviously white, so black mice stick out like sore thumbs. It's a wonder why neither Logitech nor Microsoft nor any other mouse manufacturers will consider white/silver editions of their high-end mice to match Macs (Logitech have a couple of white alternatives, but it's only low end crap models). Apple were a sitting duck for years when all they offered was the Mighty Mouse which 7 out of 10 people seemingly hated, but no third party came to the rescue... give me a white Performance MX and I'll stockpile a dozen of them immediately.

Another thing Apple needs to work on with their mice is reducing friction... my Logitech mice slide silently, but both the Mighty M and the Magic M have this nails-on-chalkboard noise on hard mousepads, it feels like you're sandpapering your desk.
 
... if you're doing serious work at your computer 10 hours a day you'll end up with carpal tunnel syndrome....


If you work at your computer 10 hours a day you'll end up with carpal tunnel syndrome regardless of the mouse you use.


The magic mouse is amazing- I would highly recommend.
 
Another vote for the Magic Mouse. It was the first mouse that got me to put away my MX Revolution, although I still use that for gaming in Windows.

Better Touch Tool FTW.
 
When I returned my 21.5" iMac the Mighty Mouse was the one thing I missed. so eventually went out and got one. Used BetterTouchTool to improve it, which it did do. However BTT has been playing up recently, so temporarily disabled it.

Still great mouse without BTT, even better with a working BTT.

it does eat batteries though (mind you, currently using Ikea cells at the moment!)
 
I couldn't get by without my Magic Mouse now. It'd be like taking a step backwards if I went back to the Mighty Mouse, although I agree with Igantius that peripherals are a personal choice, so give it a real good test drive. After awhile, you'll probably spend the cash on the Magic Mouse. It really is ahead of the market.
 
If you work at your computer 10 hours a day you'll end up with carpal tunnel syndrome regardless of the mouse you use.
I've been able to escape it so far (after 15 years of workdays like that), but one day with the Magic Mouse really wore down my wrist like no other mouse has done. It's almost as bad as the brief period I used a trackball.

When you use a normal mouse, there's a good balance that distributes the load evenly between your wrist and your fingertips, but with the Magic Mouse you have to A) position the wrist higher up in order for the fingers to reach closer to the tabletop, or B) jam your hand flat against the surface, and either way it's just uncomfortable and awkward. I guess I could buy a second Magic Mouse and glue it on top of the first one...

I dunno, I guess people hold the mouse differently. Half the reviews are raving and the other half can't get over how uncomfortable it is. Just google for "magic mouse uncomfortable" and you'll find hundreds of rants like mine.

I couldn't get by without my Magic Mouse now. It'd be like taking a step backwards if I went back to the Mighty Mouse, although I agree with Igantius that peripherals are a personal choice, so give it a real good test drive. After awhile, you'll probably spend the cash on the Magic Mouse. It really is ahead of the market.
Ahead of the market? How? It has multitouch, but since it's crippled compared to the touchpad (no zooming/pinching/tapping/3- or 4-finger operations) it's rather pointless. As for touch scroll with momentum, Logitech has had mice like that since 2004 (see V50, or the MX Air). The laser tracking is a generation behind (doesnt work on clear glass like Logitech's Darkfield technology), and it's powered by two AA batteries like other desktop mice were 10 years ago (it's OK for laptop mice though). In summary, it has one feature that's ahead of the market, but this particular feature is brutally crippled. All other aspects are unremarkable and in some cases far behind the market.
 
The Magic Mouse is the first Apple mouse I've liked, really liked!

I think the trick to it is to hold it gently, nudging it around with the thumb and pinky finger. It doesn't need a mouse pad, and the fact it lies low is actually good for preventing carpal tunnel syndrome. The other thing it needs is Better Touch Tool to get multitouch operation on the top.

I think that people that have trouble with it want a mouse that they can be heavy-handed with. That just doesn't work with the Magic Mouse.
 
I refused to buy the Mighty Mouse because of it ability to clog the scroll ball.

I bought the Magic Mouse in December and I am in love with it. It feels great and it is very smooth.

If you have a MAC there is no reason not to get one.
 
Hi first use of the mouse I thought was sluggish, but I went into the settings and changed them. After that it's brilliant. I only have one problem. I sweep my hand over the top of it now and again trying to move the cursor, instead of actually moving the mouse lol...But hey ho, I am irish lol:D
 
The Magic Mouse is not for everyone. I bought one for evaluation, thinking I'd get two more for my other Macs if I liked it, but I just can't work with it. It looks great and the scrolling and other multitouch stuff is very nice, but from an ergonomic point of view the shape is just all kinds of wrong.

Agreed. The shape is not comfortable for everyone; it's too flat and short for my taste.

Try one before you buy, if you can.
 
apple mouses don't fit well in your hand. They never seem to be ergonomic at all. I'd really recommend a logitch mouse instead.
 
I personally did not like it when I had one. It hurt my hand and I was trying to get use to it. I'll be sticking with my MX, but the OP should still give it a try and see if he/she is in the 50% that likes the mouse.
 
i love mine. I go through batteries once every two weeks or so. They take AA, which is good, as i have a ton of rechargables..
 
I have one and don't like it. I use google maps a lot, and other map apps for plotting running routes. The mouse is by default too sensitive for that, and zooms in and out all over the place - a flaw with gmaps I guess, but just touching the mouse fires the screen all over the place. I'm using default settings.

I ended up turning the 'momentum' off, as browsing was generally the same - web pages would disappear up the screen.

And it's too easy to skip forward and back when browsing too. I guess I should tinker with my settings, as I notice 99% of other respondents think it's great, so I guess I must be doing something wrong.

It doesn't track very well on either my desk (white laminate) or my hard mouse pad. It's unusable for games, so always have my usb MS Intellimouse handy.

It looks great though, but to me is a bit of a dog to use. And get rechargeable batteries for it. Any extended use of it does hurt my hand too - your hand has to float above it, you can't rest your hand on it or all manner of unpredictable actions are fired. I hold it with my thumb and third finger on either edge, I daren't touch the top of it.

For this purchaser, it wasn't worth the money - it's just not enough of an improvement from my Intellimouse.
 
When I rest my hand on the desk without a mouse my palm isn't flat on the desk, there is a little pocket created underneath it that MagicMouse fits into easily. By using BetterTouchTool I can set the sensitivity so I don't get many accidental actions from it, and from another post I made on a different forum when someone was asking about the Magic mouse.
Download BetterTouchTool and that little mouse will do all kinds of tricks. One of my favorite tricks is a better Mac version of the windows 7 commercial of dragging a window to the edge of the screen and have it pop to half screen. With the MagicMouse and BetterTouchTool you can set it up to do it with just a 3 finger swipe left or right and even adjust the pecentage of screen. I use a 60%-40% with the 60% for my browser on the left and the 40% on the right for just about everything else.
 
Bought one today and absolutely love it! BetterTouchTool is a must though, otherwise it's just overpriced piece of plastic. BTT makes it absolutely amazing! I have like 20 gestures on it and every single one works as they should! I was sceptic about how it fits my hand and how does BTT work but I'm surprised. It fits nicely in my hand and is just awesome, much better than Mighty Mouse.

The shape of it is weird in the beginning but then you realize that it's needed to get big touch surface and to make all nice gestures to work!
 
sometimes I hate how Apple design their products. this one happens to look too pretty and I wish there's a black version of the mouse.

I'll probably get one when it's on sale.
 
Got my magic mouse together with my imac and i love it. Best mouse i have tried from Apple so far :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.