Or ever. I only tried to use siri sparingly and she either could not understand my question or gave me wrong answer. No, what I asked was as simple as “play a song” followed by a name, or local weather.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Siri on HomePod Correctly Answered 52.3% of Queries in New AI Test
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Depends on what you do. I am sure HomePod as smart home stuff will be big fail. Apple's Homekit has yet achieve any significance yet. HomePad will probably only work with products that is designed for HomeKit and nothing else.
So in term of this, HomePod will not able to compete with Google home or Amazon Alexa. Not motion this thing is powered by Siri.....
Google has done lots of research with AI and AI algorithms. It is not just about mining information from you and me. Google's DeepMind has done some excellent work on AI and AI Algorithms. Google is so far ahead of AI research, Apple just cannot compete with Google. In terms of AI research, Apple is behind than Google, Microsoft and Amazon.
Siri loss AI battle isn't that much of surprise to me.
How many people need to remind Apple how stupid Siri is before they actually do something about it? Even people like Gruber are calling them out on it....
When the Apple employee demoed the HomePod for me yesterday Siri struggled in the same way it does on the iPhone. It was far from smooth and highly accurate.
This is, in a word, pathetic. As a speaker sound quality is obviously important but Siri NEEDS to get smarter. I fully expect (that is, I hope) Apple to update Siri this year.
As long as people keep buying it, Apple has done nothing. They know Siri’s limitations more than anyone.
Music, Home Automation, Siri just fine. Want more, Siri not the best choice. Integration with legacy entertainment systems, nonexistent. If looking forward, a year or two, HomePod and Siri will do very nicely. A massive shift towards streaming. The DVR, DVD, massive home audio systems, moving out of main stream. HomePod and Apple TV type devices will be the mainstream. My investment in audio systems will change significantly in the next few years. Apple future vision seems to be correctly focused on audio.
Boy I love Apple and I want to be clear upfront that I am enjoying my Homepod mostly so far, but a spade just has to be called a spade here and I have to just come clean with the fact that Siri is borderline stupid on this device. I'm holding judgement for a software update that might fix this but here are just a few of the walls I've hit:
"Hey Siri, play Smooth Criminal by Alien Ant Farm" - Siri "...I can't find Alan Andrefarm in Apple Music"
"Hey Siri, rewind 10 seconds." - Siri "...Hold the line please.......hold the line please.......hmmmm....this is taking longer than I thought."
"Hey Siri" - Siri "................................................." No answer at all
Sometimes my audio will just randomly stop and I can't figure out why or how to start it back up or if I should try to ask Siri if she can please press play or whatever.
Now, it probably sounds like I hate this thing. Quite the contrary. It sounds amazing in my office, and when Siri works like it should, this thing shows real potential.
But yeah, those few caveats are annoying.
"Hey Siri, play Smooth Criminal by Alien Ant Farm" - Siri "...I can't find Alan Andrefarm in Apple Music"
"Hey Siri, rewind 10 seconds." - Siri "...Hold the line please.......hold the line please.......hmmmm....this is taking longer than I thought."
"Hey Siri" - Siri "................................................." No answer at all
Sometimes my audio will just randomly stop and I can't figure out why or how to start it back up or if I should try to ask Siri if she can please press play or whatever.
Now, it probably sounds like I hate this thing. Quite the contrary. It sounds amazing in my office, and when Siri works like it should, this thing shows real potential.
But yeah, those few caveats are annoying.
Siri, how long will it take me to get to the closest [insert store name here]?
Siri, I'm headed to my next appointment. What's the traffic like?
Siri, order me a Lyft.
Navigation is more than just "In a quarter mile, turn right onto..."
The HP offers 7.1 stereo, in a single cabinet. The seven tweeters, plus one woofer, provide multichannel sound in a single package. While the HomePod is capable of working in pairs (when Airplay 2 is released), that in no way implies that the sound from a single HomePod is not stereophonic.
The excuses made for Apple in this thread are hilarious, especially considering they come from the same members who would most certainly celebrate and gloat as if it was a personal achievement if Siri had come out on top.
That's not what he said either.
This is being claimed frequently on these forums. Or, not so much that it happens to the actual people claiming it since these people are 'smart enough to not use the Google'...
Not only that, but if external parties got their hands on Google's data, Google would lose the very thing that they use as incentive for advertisers to buy their services.
The point is that information about individuals make up Google's business secrets and never gets out of their realm. They base their entire business on the fact that no one but them has this information and that this enables them to offer services that no one else can. The information isn't "rented out" and this assertion doesn't even work as an analogy.
That's not what he said either.
This is being claimed frequently on these forums. Or, not so much that it happens to the actual people claiming it since these people are 'smart enough to not use the Google'...
Not only that, but if external parties got their hands on Google's data, Google would lose the very thing that they use as incentive for advertisers to buy their services.
The point is that information about individuals make up Google's business secrets and never gets out of their realm. They base their entire business on the fact that no one but them has this information and that this enables them to offer services that no one else can. The information isn't "rented out" and this assertion doesn't even work as an analogy.
Did you read the article? It says, "Removing navigation, calling, email, and calendar-related queries from our question set yields a 67% correct response, a jump from overall of 52.3% correct. " In no way does that imply what you said.
They included commands that smart speakers can handle. Siri couldn't handle navigation, just like Cortana couldn't handle commerce. Should the speakers only be judged on what the HomePod can do?
I just tried the above two commands with my HomePod. Both worked perfectly the first time.
EDIT: And just tried the above a few more times. Worked fine each time.
At least with the other speakers you can use Bluetooth or a line in to connect to them. Sheesh.
Got my HomePod today. After 30 min still cannot figure out how to set it up. It also forced me into 2-factor authentication which I absolutely do not want. So far it's a dud. Even MS would not be that bad. Something is majorly wrong with this product.... Do not buy ...
I think Apple knows very well Siri trails other assistants...hence positioning the HomePod as a premium music speaker first.
The game isn’t over. Truthfully, all AI is still basically crap.
The HP is a smart speaker. The Echo and Google Home are smart microphones attached to dumb speakers. (To be fair, Google Home Max is a not-completely-dumb-but-also-not-terribly-smart speaker.) The HP is a different category of device than Echo and Max. Informed consumers won't be choosing among them, because they are not similar devices.
Last edited by a moderator:
Sorry to hear that.
My HomePod set itself up transferring AppleID and WiFi info/passwords/etc automatically from my iPhone in about a minute. I was stunned how easy setup was.