Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


The SD card reader slot on the new 14 and 16-inch MacBook Pro models is not functioning as expected with some SD cards, according to multiple reports on the MacRumors forums.

2021-MBP-SD-Card-Error-Feature.jpg
 
Each microSD card has its own controller and there are dozens of companies making their own controllers, each with different firmware.

This is probably why Apple hates add-on storage. They're used to coding for only Apple approved vendors.
And yet other companies can make external card readers that "just work" with every card. Sigh, bring back those days for Apple.
 
Just plug in a different model using the universal USB-C ports… oh wait, y’all wanted integrated! 😉

But you can still plug one in...

I'm interested if anyone can say what kind of "connection" the SD Card in the new MBPs has? I have both a USB 3 card reader and a Thunderbolt 3 card reader... and the Thunderbolt is WAY faster. Did Apple go with Thunderbolt for the internal one? If not, I'll probably continue to use my external one anyway...
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbital~debris
I am sorry but an SD card reader is such a basic thing to add to a computer. Even the cheapest card readers on Amazon will read all SD cards. How could apple blow this. Did they not test a variety of SD card manufactures cards with their computers. I rather an another input port on my computer than having to deal with Apple's SD card reader. It looks like that cannot get that one right.
 
Old MBPs were notorious for this problem, and I had one that had the problem. I ended up just buying an external card reader.


my old MacBook's SD slot worked great for a while. I used it a lot. then it stopped working completely. after a couple of years it started working again but all cards mount locked.

I haven't tested my new MacBook. now I'm afraid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TMax and visualseed
No issues here whatsoever on my 14" 10/16 model. I've tried my SanDisk 128 GB SD card multiple times since day 1 and haven't noticed any hiccups so far.
 
And yet other companies can make external card readers that "just work" with every card. Sigh, bring back those days for Apple.
This is what happens when drivers are rewritten from scratch; all those weird things you had to do for "compatibility" get thrown out, and all those old cards which you don't have to test start causing problems.

Maybe the M1 pro is so fast that it's causing hardware interface problems - like there was latency present in the x86 world that was "built in" and is now gone. Hardware can be surprisingly intolerant of bad timing.
 
And yet other companies can make external card readers that "just work" with every card. Sigh, bring back those days for Apple.
and yet they don't. When I owned a photography studio, SD cards, no matter how new or from what manufacturer, were always iffy. On PCs and Mac. Its an old technology, and was essentially obsolete eight years ago. I can't imagine what the hell apple was thinking adding them back into the mix. Every card has its own firmware, sometimes they work, sometimes they don't. They all suck.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.