jefftroll,
I had the same results as you with the steinheil ultra crystal. I also picked up this case today to test, works pretty well.
Ive installed these things a million times. and even after going through both the included protectors that came in the package, I could not get the area around the home button to stick, nor the area around the earphone.
I did everything that is recommended when installing these things. Used Iclear on the screen, compressed air, and did it in a steamy bathroom to lessen the risk of getting dust under the protector.
Both the ear phone and home button have issues. For now I am going to keep it, it was only $11.99, and then when the power support protectors come out, I will order that one.
See pictures below. PS it did this before I put the Belkin Grip Vue case on. No matter what I tried it wouldnt adhere correctly. I even tried taking it off and reapplying but still no luck.
It almost looks like when they made the cut outs for the home button and ear phone, they distorted the plastic, and thats why it wont adhere.