Warning: Extended musings on the Surface Pro 8 and what it means to me as an iPad/Macbook user.
The Surface Pro 8 blew me away. My skepticism for the Intel chip and claimed battery life aside, I think Microsoft has done an amazing job here. It's the first time I've felt jealous of a Microsoft product in a while. Since it was first introduced, the iPad Pro I think has reached for the goal of being the ultimately versatile device, and each iteration of the hardware and software has brought it closer and closer to that goal. Depending on what you have attached to it, an iPad Pro can be a tablet, a sketchbook, notepad, laptop, or even more things. But as has been discussed over and over for years, it doesn't quite reach the mark of being fully versatile yet. It can't replace a laptop for many workloads (mine included, as a native software developer), and it's extremely unlikely to replace a desktop for any workload.
The Surface Pro line, for all its many flaws, has always made more ambitious attempts to be the one device that can do it all. Historically, it's always had to do this at the cost of very serious compromises. The Surface Pro 7 had an extremely outdated design, poor battery life, a 60hz screen, weak performance that still pushed the cooling system to its limits, poor IO, and a worse pure tablet experience. The Pro 8 significantly mitigates many of these tradeoffs, particularly in hardware.
Everyone's use case is different of course. If you have no need for a 'full' laptop or desktop experience I think the iPad is still the obvious choice. Despite the improvements in Windows 11, iPadOS is clearly still much more optimized for touch, and the app selection and quality is leagues above Microsoft's offering. Not to mention there's still so many 'ifs' about the Surface that could come up later that would negate almost all of this, like the serious concerns I have about the claimed battery life and performance. But if you are like me or your use cases are similar to mine, then for the first time Microsoft has caught up and come closer to creating that 'one' device that can do it all for you than Apple has, particularly if the app you're most in need of in tablet form is just a web browser.
I still believe in Apple's approach. I'm not one of those people thinking that Apple is afraid of cannibalizing the Mac. I think the simplicity of the iPad is very important to them, and they feel they have to think through every new addition to iPadOS very carefully to ensure that the simplicity isn't damaged. I think the clear lead they had in the market is what gave them the freedom to take this problem so slowly. Too slowly, I think. My hope is that the Surface Pro 8 is an amazing machine. Not just for the people that purchase it, but because the effect of competition is real, and even if it's not quite all the way to achieving the dream either, a good SP8 would be a reminder to Apple that the clock is ticking. The SP8's tablet problems are in my opinion, easier to solve and less damaging to the experience than the iPad's laptop and desktop problems. If Apple continues to spend years reworking basic side-by-side multitasking over and over again, Microsoft is going to pass them for many people, if they haven't already.