I got the white one to use with my white phone and the only thing about it that I like is that the white really matches the white iPhone well and is not so blue white as others. However, that's where the like ends. I think the case is cheaply made, not well designed and will be sending it back. The sides kind of clip on but the top is just kind of hanging out there and not tight to the phone. I much prefer a case that is uniform looking and at least goes around the phone and fits snugly. My overall favorite case for my 4S was a Case Crown Glider. This case was my favorite. It was a very snug fit, and looked like it was part of the phone. It clipped the edge of the phone and didn't go over the screen and didn't interfere with screen protectors. It was minimalist in style and protected my phone when I dropped it a couple of times on pavement. Unfortunately Case Crown doesn't have the same design Giider for the 5. Their new version looks like they took their old cases and added a band of silver along with a new bottom to fit the new 5's. And then the new cases do go over the top of the screen.
Love having a new phone but hate the perfect case search. For me, the InCase Slider is working the best for my needs. That may change once I get my screen protector.