I went to the Apple Store in Monterey, CA yesterday morning 15 minutes before opening. The employee forming the line outside for iPhone buyers asked me which version I wanted to buy. I simply said "device only," to which he replied "just so you know, all the iPhone 5s's are locked to carriers at this point if you were interested in an unlocked one. Those won't come out for another couple of months." Of course I did my research on this thread and knew he was either lying or misinformed (nice enough dude) and I didn't have time to follow the line only to get into an argument with the sales rep, since I had to go to work. Plus, I want to be 100% sure it will be unlocked since I travel overseas a lot and don't want to be stranded somewhere with a locked iPhone. Anyway, my concern is that Apple is waking on thin ice with consumers right now. The fact that they are changing the wording on-line, and that the employees at retail stores are saying they are all locked to carriers leads me to believe there is some sort of law being broken. Yes, manufacturers and carriers are allowed to SIM-lock devices in the U.S. (which is stupid) but why sneakily try and prevent users from purchasing a full-price phone that is SIM unlocked, albeit not advertised as such. My conclusion: Simple, really. Imagine how much it costs for a 2-year iPhone plan. AT&T is almost 90 USD per month. This includes a shameful amount of data, minutes few people use anymore because of Skype and other such services, and a mostly irrelevant high priced text messaging plan. Texting on a smart phone in the United States is becoming irrelevant since most smart phone users communicate over IP - iMessage, email or FaceBook for example. AT&T REQUIRES this plan if you want a subsidized price. Check out their other plans or their prepaid service. Over that two year span that they lock you into with the attractive subsidized price, people are spending thousands in the long run on a 650 device. You are basically getting a loan to buy an iPhone, and paying it back at an extremely high interest rate. Some of this "interest" is going into Apple's pockets from the carriers, and some of it the carriers keep. It's a win-win for all of them. Result: Apple Retail employees are supposed to lie to you. In my opinion this is all bordering on breaking Anti-Trust laws. There is no locked or unlocked iPhone, they are identical until the sales representative marks it as such on their servers when you pay for it. Every time you boot up your phone it cross-checks the IMEI with Apple's white list. Hell, this isn't even the carriers' technology. The carriers, and Apple, just sit and watch the 90/month from a large portion of American pockets stream into their off-shore and tax-free bank accounts.
The Apple employee tells me the phones are locked so as to reserve the first supply of iPhone to the herd of 2-year contract-era. Then, when the feel like it, and they got enough people plugged into that system, they'll sell me a phone that I can freely swap carriers to avoid roaming charges internationally. Or maybe I just want two different SIM cards in my briefcase in case I find myself where one carrier has no service? Come on.
Every day I wait for this make-believe special unlocked version, my old phone decreases resale value. Not cool.