Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Tea Without Milk Is...

  • Most Vulgar

    Votes: 33 24.4%
  • Quite Acceptable

    Votes: 102 75.6%

  • Total voters
    135
Will remember that for next year when we are visiting Newport, RI

and milk always in last

You will want to. The concept of pouring boiling water in a pot seems hopelessly foreign to American restauranteurs. I finally gave up on ordering tea anywhere. Some of the fancy coffee shops do it right, but they're hit-and-miss at best.

Milk in first for me. I understand in Britain this is a cultural cue that a person is working class.
 
never heard of it. :eek:
Heh. Figures there's a wiki article on the stuff.

Looks a lil' scary to those who haven't seen it or had it but it's like so:


pearlmilktea.jpg
 
the way i do it is

1. get cast iron teapot
2. put boiling hot water into teapot to prime it
3. empty teapot of hot water
4. add loose tea (irish breakfast in my case)
5. pour in just off the boil hot water
6. cover and steep 5 minutes
7. strain tea into mug
8. add milk
9. add sugar
10. enjoy.

is that how they do it in the UK?

Can't answer for that, but I'd ditch the cast iron teapot. Ceramic is the way to go. Even glass is okay. I no longer "warm the pot" as so often recommended, because I found it didn't make a difference to the result. But then I live in a warm climate so the pot usually isn't chilly when I start.

if being poured from a teapot (As in, a pot already made) then milk first might be ok.
if you're just making a cup, having the milk in first would cool it too much when steeping the teabag.

so as a general 'safe for all' - milk last

Ah, well, I never steep tea in a cup. I have teapots for all occasions, including one for a single cup. ;)
 
Hot tea - with milk
Iced tea - without

Having recently travelled to the UK and also having some relatives come over to the US to visit, it's funny that most of them have never heard of iced tea and seem repulsed by the concept.
 
Tea without milk is... just as disgusting as tea with milk.

Ha ha, that's exactly what I was going to say!

Americans as a rule know almost nothing about tea. Don't even bother to order it in a restaurant here, even a good one. The drink simply has never caught on over here.

Except for iced tea, which americans can't seem to get enough of. I personally do not like the taste of tea, iced or otherwise...
 
Can't answer for that, but I'd ditch the cast iron teapot. Ceramic is the way to go. Even glass is okay. I no longer "warm the pot" as so often recommended, because I found it didn't make a difference to the result. But then I live in a warm climate so the pot usually isn't chilly when I start.



Ah, well, I never steep tea in a cup. I have teapots for all occasions, including one for a single cup. ;)

You, my friend, sound like a tea connoisseur. Care to enlighten me on your tea making process and also what your favorite tea is?
 
Except for iced tea, which americans can't seem to get enough of. I personally do not like the taste of tea, iced or otherwise...

Good point. Iced tea is a very American thing, but it can be made with almost any kind of tea in any way and turns out about the same. Then again, most Americans haven't actually tasted tea. The stuff you get served in restaurants here isn't tea, it's warm brown water. No wonder you don't like the flavor.

You, my friend, sound like a tea connoisseur. Care to enlighten me on your tea making process and also what your favorite tea is?

Only by American standards I suspect. On an everyday basis I make the standard British brands such as PG Tips, Typhoo, Barry's Gold, Yorkshire Gold, etc. I avoid anything sold in a supermarket, including Twinings. I also buy loose varietal teas (Assam, Ceylon, Kenya, etc) which I blend to taste. I also sometimes make Oolong (AKA "Chinese restaurant tea") and green tea.

Making tea properly is a cinch. Boiling water, a pot. Much easier than coffee -- which makes me wonder why most restaurants don't seem to get it.
 
Next debate: milk in first or last?

I refer everyone in this thread to the British standard BS6008:1980 Preparation of a liquor of tea for use in sensory tests, or the associated ISO 3103-1980.

7.2.2 Preparation with milk
Pour milk free from any off-flavour (for example raw
milk or unboiled pasteurized milk) into the
bowl (5.2), using approximately 5 ml for the large
bowl and 2,5 ml for the small bowl described in the
Annex.

Prepare the liquor as described in 7.2.1 but pour it
into the bowl after the milk, in order to avoid
scalding the milk, unless this procedure is contrary
to the normal practice in the organization
concerned.

If the milk is added afterwards, experience has
shown that the best results are obtained when the
temperature of the liquor is in the range 65 to 80 °C
when the milk is added.

While addition of milk is not essential, it sometimes
helps to accentuate differences in flavour and
colour.
 
For me, I drink mostly green tea varieties. So, absolutely never milk. Also, never, ever use boiling water with green teas.

When I drink black teas, milk can be quite tasty and always make it with vigorously boiling water.
 
I tried milk with a Lady Grey, and I thought that it was utterly vulgar. I've never tried it with a breakfast tea, and I don't like breakfast tea, but maybe the two go together better.

I usually have Twinings Earl Grey with a small teaspoon of sugar, though I know IJ Reilly doesn't approve of that. :p I'll also drink some oolong I find next to all the other asian food.
 
Heh. Figures there's a wiki article on the stuff.

Looks a lil' scary to those who haven't seen it or had it but it's like so:


View attachment 93458
It's very popular in the east especially, I used to drink them a lot. It taste good. The sago beans are like little jellies, I don't think it adds anything to the taste though.

EDIT: My bad, not sago beans but tapioca, they looks awfully similar though
 
I never put milk in my tea until just recently. So I gave it a try since I like trying everything once. Blech, I almost threw it up. No tea and milk for me please.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.