The N54 in my dads 335xi didn't give us any issues at all in the 70,000 miles...
But the E90 was becoming the dreaded maintenance queens Germans tend to become in high mileage( freaking dealer wanted $2000 for a battery change, which we obviously told the dealer screw you). $1000 just to get it back within emissions regulations when something with the emissions system failed.
I have about 95 or 96,000 miles on my E60 at this point. My father gave it to me when I graduated college. My Grand Cherokee had become too unreliable and not worth fixing. The cost of ownership with the BMW is gut wrenching. My battery change cost $500 due to "reprogramming", whatever that means. I had a bunch of suspension work done as well as a new starter, let's just say the cost was about 1/3 of what the car is worth, if not more. It's too much money to dump into a car that old, in my opinion. It's a fantastic car, but as I've mentioned before I'd prefer and SUV or possibly something less ostentatious.
What interior color did you have in yours? My dads has the jet black interior which certainly can make the dash even darker, etc. But I love the morello red interior. It's not a bright red like BMW's red interior is, it is a darker red. I describe it like a red wine like color to it which makes sporty, but classy especially with the carbon fiber trim. Helps create a nice contrast with the black center HVAC controls.
It had black leather, black dashboard, and black carpet- no wood trim, just aluminum. It's a nice interior, but the cheesy glossy plastic around the HVAC controls was the biggest turn off. The secret storage compartment in the center stack was quite a surprise.
My only complaint with CUE is the fact the zoom animation on the nav screen is a bit slow to react, but everything else is fairly fast in response and animation.
I noticed that as well. I think my biggest gripe is the lack of designated physical buttons. I'd prefer to switch between HVAC, Radio, Nav, etc quickly and easily. I do like that they opted not to burry the HVAC controls into the infotainment system, unlike some cars that have deleted their physical HVAC controls. I didn't find the voice recognition to work that well either. The touch screen didn't respond to my fingers that well (better than some though). Like I said before, the capacitive touch dashboard buttons annoyed me. It may be "cool" but I prefer function over form in this case. I wasn't a fan of the center console layout much either. I do appreciate the "normal" shifter compared to BMW's "backwards" shifter (pull for Drive/shift up, push for Reverse/shift down).
GM has improved it a lot since it came out. When I first checked out the ATS in 2012, it was very laggy in response and animation was choppy. But our 2014 ATS is much much improved.
I'm pretty sure I drove a 2014 model. Though it may have been a 2013...
Certainly though the cheapest thing in the ATS is that horrible horrible instrument cluster, but thanks to HUD I rarely have to look down and see that horrible thing. 😀
Now that you mention it, the instrument cluster was pretty boring. I also felt the numbers were quite small to read. That said, I really liked the graphics used on the LCD within the cluster.
----------
I don't know if I'll ever get used to that. Our T4R has a spare, like a REAL, full sized tire, on a matching real wheel. It's not as bad with run flats, but I had a car with no spare, non-runflats - just a can of "fix-a-flat" and a pump.
A 4Runner better have a spare tire! I have run flats on my BMW, but I do have the space/well for a full size spare, so all is not lost. My girlfriend's new (to her) Volvo S60 has the "optional," "dealer installed" spare tire, which consists of a donut in a bag thrown in the trunk. Who wants a spare tire rolling around in the trunk. I'm hoping this will be one of those fads that rebounds.