Disagree. I found the premier distant and trying to hard to be extreme or over the top. The show needs to have a base with characters i care about, a story that is told well( not likely flashbacks being whenever) and ....not a main actor i don't care for.
Lost from the onset give you great characters that you cared about the instant you met them. You grew to love them and want to know what they did and who they were. THey had a story that was interesting, created discussion and was never seen on television. Also.....i never eactivly hated anyone..except nikki and paulo but of course, everyone did.
Everyone wants to have a show that can replace lost as a sci fi adventure but lost was not sci fi on the onset, it become sci fi as we went deeper within the show and the island.
You might want to read the first page or so of this
thread. It might enlighten you on another show that was thought to be “over the top.”
"I am mixed on this show after watching. The "monster" is a bit over the top.”
"Yeah. Doesn't sound too exciting does it? I thought it was a good program until the "monster" bit... ah well. I'll give it a few more watches.”
"I didn't really like the monster part of the plot. You could accept the rest of the story with a small grain of salt, but the monster requires one very large grain.”
"I must say, the pilot didn't give me the slightest interest in seeing the next episode. It's like the network's trying to create a scripted drama out of all the Survivor/Fear Factor-type reality shows. The pacing is contrived and predictable--snippets of emotional, human interaction are alternated back and forth with Oh My God! Another Emergency! complications.”
"The writing and character interaction would have to have been a heckuva lot better to make this overwrought manipulation of every dramatic mechanism at all interesting.”
"Good thing we're not in the focus group..”
"And how do you get people interested in 48 characters?”
"i've heard very good things about this series, reviews etc saying that its one of the best new shows of the new season. I wouldn't miss it!!!!”
and then:
"Aren't these the same people that say "The Cat In The Hat was a wonderful romp through the days of our youth"? Liars! Liars!”
"I wonder what hour of wasted time THEY were watching? The only reason that I can see in watching more is to find out if this is "reality" survival fictional series or some "fantasy" series. For a weekly series I am only wiling to keep track of 10 to 12 characters. Not 48 "survivors". And some Jurassic Park reject.
I hope that ABC loses their pensions on this one.”
"Anybody still watching this show? It's not stellar, but it's still ok.” Doctor Q quote
"Next week, Kate, Charlie, Sawyer, Sayid, Boone, and Shannon explore the far side of island. What do they find? Mr. Roarke (Ricardo Montelban) and Tattoo (Herve Villechaize) saying "De plane, Boss! De plane!””
NOT TO MENTION all the jokes that were made all through those first two pages. Eventually the show took off and the rest is history.