First of all, for the record Im not a BSG fanboy who blindly thinks that the writers can do know wrong and the show can never have a bad day, so I dont want to give you or anyone else that impression. There were a few episodes in the past couple seasons which I didnt care for as well. That being said, in the spirit of good debate and discussion, I thought Id reply to your comments...
😉
Abulia said:
Part of the brilliance of BSG was not knowing what would happen the next week on their journey. Plus the show, by and large, was about the journey, not the destination (Earth or New Caprica.)
Cant attempting to settle on a planet be part of the journey? Sure, perhaps to the colonists they were ideally viewing this as a possible permanent move, however we know darn well it wont be and that at some point New Caprica will be left behind. So, really, this is part of the journey, and in my opinion, beats simply having the entire journey take place in space encountering Cylons every week.
Abulia said:
Now we have a show firmly rooted on a planet where we'll be stuck with resistance fighting stories that are going to draw (eg. mimic) the situation in Iraq. It's going to be pretty easy to see what comes "next." (I'd go into more detail but want to keep this thread spoiler free.)
I think having the colonists occupied by the Cylons will add a different element to the drama. As opposed to be chased and hunted by them, now the Cylons are here, plain and simple, and theyre right in everyones face. Its different than fighting them from the cockpit of a Viper, attacking Baystars, firing up the FTL drives...
And although parallels will no doubt be able to be drawn between the Cylon occupation and the Iraq situation, I would compare it more to the Nazi occupation of France, especially with that scene of the Cylon centurions marching down the center of the town talk about ripped right out of the history books!
😉
As for seeing whats going to come next, sure, weve already seen it in the webisodes oppression, slavery, torture - those types of concepts. But how bad will it get? When will the fleet save the day?
How will they save the day? Many questions exist which will definitely keep things interesting.
Abulia said:
And flashbacks? Okay, show of hands here...who liked the 3 out of 4 epsiodes in S2.5 where they all involved starting at the ending and showing the epsiode through flashbacks? They. Were. Crap.
I cant say that device did much for me either, but I definitely didnt mind it. In this case though, as opposed to flashing back a few hours or a couple days, we could be flashing back over the past entire year. As I said earlier, frankly, I like the fact that we dont know and that we have a year to figure out. I loved that aspect of Season 1 into Season 2 - my head was spinning trying to piece everything together. Near the end of Season 2 though, I started feeling comfortable, that I had a much better handle on things. Now, Im back to square one in many respects, which I think is cool.
😎
Yes, I realize this makes things a little more convenient for the writers, but I dont really care as long as it makes for great television.
😉
Abulia said:
Even the actors have gone on record stating they're not so keen on getting away from the Galactica and the trip to Earth.
Really? From everything Ive read that actors say this will be the best season ever and they really enjoyed filming it. If you have any links regarding your above comment Id love to read them for a different perspective.
Abulia said:
The writers have confessed that they "hope" they're going to get it right with this new arc. Everything says that Moore and Co. are stumbling about, hoping they've got it right this season.
Everything? I dont think so. I think theyre taking a risk, and I can see where theres some concern, but Id like to think that the amazing writing of the previous 2 seasons should provide people with some confidence that Season 3 wont be a huge letdown.
Abulia said:
See, the problem is, they've taken away the surprises.
And where exactly is the Cylon plan?
I think you just proved that they havent taken
all of the surprises away...
😛 😉 😎
If you think that the writers have run out of twists, turns and surprises for the show and that Season 3 will not have any surprises whatsoever, I think youre sadly mistaken.
😉 🙂
Anyway, thats probably more than my $0.02.
😎
