Funny how tastes can differ.Personally, anything is nicer than the Macbook keyboard. Even typing on glass is more pleasant to me. The Macbook keyboard is one huge disappointment for me. The smart keyboard is a tiny bit better, but for me nothing to write home about.
I find the Macbook keyboard not too bad, it's the fact that the sharp aluminium edge between the keys is annoying on my fingers that makes me dislike the MacBook keyboard a lot.
The ASK doesn't have that and (on my 12.9") it has exactly the same layout as my MacBook Pro/ Magic 2 keyboard etc.
It really is a delight to use, I'v had it on my iPP for 6 months and it never leaves it.