For me it was WWE 2K16. Played for 10mins it was that bad
I'll never forgive THQ or WWE for making/publishing/licensing WWE Raw for Xbox/PC back in 2002.
I was this huge wrestling fan back when I was 12, and enjoyed the heck out of the Smackdown series on PS1. When the Xbox came out I was so hyped about Raw, thinking it was just an updated and graphically superior Smackdown 2 and I chose that as my one game for the system instead of Halo.
I still feel bitter about it to this day, that game was such a huge pile of **** and far inferior to the PS1 games.