Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Tim is already in damage limitation mode, following the luke warm reception to the products.

When in need, bring up Steve!
 
I hate it when comments like this are right. I don't want Apple to fail.

iPhone 6 was great -- it'll sell like nothing else. But the Apple Watch just has a sniff of 'the beginning of the end'.

I'm not sure where all the negativity is coming from. iWatch can be seen ninth same way as the original iPhone or the original iPad. They are very much proof of concepts that started the i industry and supported Apple to advance the technology. Without the in atoll success of iPhone and iPad Apple would never have been able to push developments like A7 & A8, advanced screens and even cameras. Likewise this iWatch will enable further developments in technology to move this iWatch away from being a proof of concept device into something that only a futurist can see coming. Imagine in a few years an iWatch that replaces your iPhone completely.
 
So, I guess I will be one of the few here considering buying the watch? I think it doesn't look as bad as u guys think it is. I'm not digging some of the bands, but some looks pretty good IMO. The price tag is a bit high though. I'll have to get my hand on it before deciding whether it's justified. In the meanwhile, continue bitching on something u haven't yet seen in person. Time and time again, seeing an actual Apple product in person can really change ones perspective. For that reason, I'll reserve judgement until then.
 
You summed up exactly how I feel. I Don't know what I should do. The iPhone 6 looks really solid, but after the watch, I felt like I should jump ship. History is starting to repeat itself.

Give me a break! I don't even wear watches but yet I can see that then device is extremely impressive.
 
I find it more interesting that he said they worked on the Watch after Steve's passing (Oct 2011), but in the keynote he says they were working on it for 4 years, which would be started before his passing.

You think he and others hid this project behind his back? Or is he trying to steer credit away from Jobs and to himself?
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure where all the negativity is coming from. iWatch can be seen ninth same way as the original iPhone or the original iPad. They are very much proof of concepts that started the i industry and supported Apple to advance the technology. Without the in atoll success of iPhone and iPad Apple would never have been able to push developments like A7 & A8, advanced screens and even cameras. Likewise this iWatch will enable further developments in technology to move this iWatch away from being a proof of concept device into something that only a futurist can see coming. Imagine in a few years an iWatch that replaces your iPhone completely.

the one and only reason im not totally bashing it. the first thing i could think of when i saw this was "this is a revision A product"... the refinements will be killer. but i'll be passing on it for now.
 
Regrettably I don't think the Apple Watch is something Steve would have liked in any way whatsoever. It seems self-indulgent and has a user interface comparable to that of a classroom projector.

I'm not hating -- I really thought Apple would pull something out of the bag, especially with all the hype. This is essentially a glorified Samsung Gear. It was at the moment when I saw the crowd go wild over something I just couldn't see as groundbreaking, that I felt a sinking 'I might be in a cult' moment. Had Samsung introduced the exact same product, we'd be laughing rather than considering jumping ship.

Just my $0.02.

I'm not sure if you fully grasped the technology and innovation that went in to the watch. It is definitely NOT a glorified samsung gear. No, samsung can't release something like this. It's not in their technical capability or at least not willing to try. If samsung released something like this then I'll resp them again. Until then, they're just a copy cat.
 
Well Apple fans are second largest block here. After trolls of course.

So if you an Apple fan, but unhappy with what was launched.... you are a troll?

Nice try. The largest block by far is Apple fans, and they have opinions!!
 
So, I guess I will be one of the few here considering buying the watch? I think it doesn't look as bad as u guys think it is. I'm not digging some of the bands, but some looks pretty good IMO. The price tag is a bit high though. I'll have to get my hand on it before deciding whether it's justified. In the meanwhile, continue bitching on something u haven't yet seen in person. Time and time again, seeing an actual Apple product in person can really change ones perspective. For that reason, I'll reserve judgement until then.

the watch is insanely impressive, and i think it looks incredible. this thing will set the standard for all others over the next few years while they play catch-up. in one fell swoop apple has shown their hand and trumped everything else out there.
 
Next summer on Broadway

I'll have to sit behind 40 people looking at those little glowing watches. ugh.
 
I think the watch is beautifully designed and manufactured.

It's just missing a couple features that would make it great. If it had built in GPS and 3G, then it'd be perfect as a standalone device.
 
Regrettably I don't think the Apple Watch is something Steve would have liked in any way whatsoever. It seems self-indulgent and has a user interface comparable to that of a classroom projector.

I'm not hating -- I really thought Apple would pull something out of the bag, especially with all the hype. This is essentially a glorified Samsung Gear. It was at the moment when I saw the crowd go wild over something I just couldn't see as groundbreaking, that I felt a sinking 'I might be in a cult' moment. Had Samsung introduced the exact same product, we'd be laughing rather than considering jumping ship.

Just my $0.02.


I'm on the same boat as those who dislike Apples "WATCH" and dismiss it as gimmicky but it must be said that if it wasn't for leaks hinting that apple were working on a health-based watch there would be no Samsung gear (hence no other watches by competitors) and we may all have been wow'ed at todays event. So lets be fair to apple.
 
They've been developing this thing for years now. Hell at the D10 conference a few years ago Cook was clearly hinting at the device with his talk of sensors.

The S1 is a marvel in itself. Frankly, no one dumps the hundreds of millions of R&D and manufacturing logistics into a product they aren't looking to go whole hog on.

When Apple swallowed up PA Semi many thought Apple was nuts, iPhone/iPod Touch were laughed at, I'm quite sure Steve+Tim had a strong idea/concept of building upon Apple's R&D strengths and expand upon them. Innovation is driven by highly funded R&D which Apple can afford and known for.

It'll be interesting what iPod Touch/iPad update will include in terms of sensors.
 
I'm not sure if you fully grasped the technology and innovation that went in to the watch. It is definitely NOT a glorified samsung gear. No, samsung can't release something like this. It's not in their technical capability or at least not willing to try. If samsung released something like this then I'll resp them again. Until then, they're just a copy cat.

Look at the price.

Its a more expansive Samsung Gear, hence some better tech ;)

I'm not sure what amazing innovation your seeing here. Instead of it being the watch that changed the wearable playground, it just became the IOS version of what is currently out there. meh....
 
I was really hoping for a replacement for my Nike Band.

Alas, the iWatch is not it, looks like the Nike Band will be staying on my wrist for a while to come.
 
Bravo Tim. Bravo Apple.
Bravo is right, this is probably one of the most impressive releases in a long time. People grossly underestimate the value of what has been released today. give it 6-12 month and I think you will see a wild adoption of Apples payments system. Just this little advancement will mean massive sales of Apple hardware.
People get too hung up on specs. Who cares if the phone has 1gig or ram. As long as it runs well. Android needs more ram to operate properly. The less ram a OS uses the less it will have a strain on battery life.
Well yes and no. iOS actually needs a lot more RAM. In this regard the new iPhones are disappointing. The certainly can get by on 1 GB of RAM but getting by and living large are two different things.

326ppi, who cares as long as the screen looks great. Can your eyes tell the difference. No. I care more about screen quality, contrast, black levels than anything else.
People complaining about iPhone screens are at best Samsung plants and at worst idiots. Technology is all about balanced design and frankly nothing comes close to an iPhone.
Compare a plasma 1080P screen to a 4K led and than get back to me. Every hear of the Pioneer Kuro?

The iwatch looks great. If you don't like it don't get one. Simple as that.
Considering I don't wear watches I have to say i'm impressed. people need to realize that like all things Apple this is a rev one device that could be seen as a proof of concept that will only get better as technology advances.

I don't like that apple didn't upgrade the battery in the 4.7 iphone. Their fascination with thinness over function I don't like at all. Other than that good job Apple. :)
Actually I think the battery did get an update, there is just more happening in the phone so the over all gain was modest. Further You now have a real option if extended battery life is important to you.
 
I think the watch is beautifully designed and manufactured.

It's just missing a couple features that would make it great. If it had built in GPS and 3G, then it'd be perfect as a standalone device.

You can only achieve so much in a first release! When Apple can build most of iWatch on a single 14nm chip you may very well see one or more of those features. I would suspect the GPS would come first.
 
Sadly, I can believe this. The watch is ugly. If this watch were instead released by Sony, or whoever, MR forum members would be laughing and poking fun at it's square shape and continue to salivate over an alleged forthcoming iWatch that was more aesthetically pleasing.

So what, you prefer the Moto 360 that wedged a square display into a round frame, cutting off all content on the sides? All the Android Wear phones are quick-to-market gadgets with little thought and attention spent on the user experience. You may have your own opinion on whether the WATCH is aesthetically ugly or not, and you may even dislike the user interface, but no one can really dispute that it is a much more thought-out, cohesive piece of tech than the Android Wear watches, and one that integrates far more fluidly with the iPhone and Apple's ecosystem. But that's what Apple does best.

I'm sorry to inform you that that was to prevent the stock price from tanking. Lest we forget, Steve Jobs finally cracked the Apple Television that never saw the light of day. Guess he never cracked it.

Just because Jobs wasn't involved with the watch doesn't mean he wasn't involved with other products that are four years out. And I do think Apple/Steve probably "cracked" television from a tech point-of-view, but wrangling the TV content owners is a different kind of hell, and that's probably why we haven't seen one yet. Apple may have also delayed its launch in order to prepare a foundation first, such as with Apple Pay, bigger cloud infrastructure, etc. We don't know.
 
Is this still an apple fan site? Just asking because there is so much bitching going on here today in the comments...

Of course the site is full of 99% Apple fans. So its very telling when new product gets such a luke warm response, even from us, their biggest supporters.

More and more, the keynotes have been overhyped by under delivered.

The new phone design is not iconic. It does look very generic in the current market place.

The watch is clunky. Having waited a year later than the market, you would expect Apple to knock it out of the park.

Coupled with buying crap like Beats, and I fear for the direction of the business.

I hate to say it, but Apple are looking more and more superficial. The Sony and Nokia phones are simply way ahead now. Then it just comes down to preference of OS, and all of the modern phones work very well.

I'm sure Apple will have amazing launch day sales (the hype machine will be in overdrive), but I think the longer term will start to suffer. I know a lot of people moving away.

In my office, you can hear the frustration of iphone users who want to remain with the Apple brand, but are feeling like they are now being taken for a ride.
 
But what happened to Steve leaving Apple with a four year product pipeline?

Probably it's that things change fast enough in tech that the things on the farther end of your pipeline aren't likely to be the same as what you were planning 4 years before.That and I kind of think the watch was a result of there being rumours that Apple was doing it so they decided it would be a good idea to throw something together.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.