Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I really don't care about the cutout. It does look like the Caudabe cases have smaller cutouts which aren't as much of an eye sore. Either way, cutouts don't bug me and may even be easier to use.
Same… The Camera Control button is supposed to be made out of sapphire, so I don’t think it will scratch easily.

I mean, my 12 Pro Sheath also has cutouts for the charging port, Mic and speakers, mute switch and also the cameras… No scratches there…

And the new cutout on the Sheath seems to be nicely wedged, so it should be easy to use…
 
CleanShot 2024-09-13 at 06.29.32@2x.png


I did it.

I am not proud I did it. I'm concerned about how well this case will work with the camera control button.

However...

The more I read and watch videos about Apple Silicone cases the more I see how quickly they become damaged or peel apart.

I suppose the worst that can happen is that the button doesn't work with the case and I return this.
 
I've been a Sheath user/advocate for 3+ years/3+ different iPhones.

Can't pull the trigger this year, that cutout seems too risky. Plus, I'm sick of the same Sheath covers year after year! Give us something bold or different.

I've ordered the Ultramarine silicon case from Apple. I'm not happy about it, but at least it will 100% function as intended. And the color will look nice with white titanium.
 
Not a fan of the bright colours of the Paragon range. Caudabe for me has always been about subtlety and sleekneess, these are the opposite.

Decided to go with with the Ringke Onyx for my first 16 Pro case.
 
View attachment 2416969

I did it.

I am not proud I did it. I'm concerned about how well this case will work with the camera control button.

However...

The more I read and watch videos about Apple Silicone cases the more I see how quickly they become damaged or peel apart.

I suppose the worst that can happen is that the button doesn't work with the case and I return this.
Same here, I'm leaning on the return policy if I don't like it.

I've got three Caudabe Sheath cases so far and no returns so hopefully if I do one return at least I'm not labeled as a serial returner, haha!

Went with the White iPhone so I think it'll blend well, time will tell.

RE Silicone case, YES. I have had them on the iPhone 5, iPhone 6 Plus, iPhone SE, iPhone 12 and I was dissapointed EACH TIME with how the corners would flake right off and lets not get started on the iPhone 5C version with the holes I had for all of a few days. After the 12 I closed the door on ordering those again.

Apple Leather was where it was at up through iPhone 11, the one on my 12/13 mini just wasn't the same and now they are gone entirely....

1726242255458.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: NJRonbo
I wrote Caudabe yesterday asking what their return policy is should there be any issue with the cutout around the iPhone's camera control button. Here is the response I received:


First of all, so sorry for the delay in response. We're experiencing very high contact volume and it's taking us longer than usual to reply to emails. But let's get this resolved for you! :)

If for any reason you are not satisfied with your purchase, we do have a 30 day return/exchange policy. As mentioned in our previous email, our goal was to design a cutout that would enable users to easily access and use the Camera Control button, but wouldn’t be grotesquely large, especially given the slightly awkward placement of the button on the phone itself. The cutout was designed to work seamlessly and so functionality shouldn't be an issue here.

Looks like the order has been placed, and we really think you'll like it!
 
  • Like
Reactions: mgscheue
I wrote Caudabe yesterday asking what their return policy is should there be any issue with the cutout around the iPhone's camera control button. Here is the response I received:


First of all, so sorry for the delay in response. We're experiencing very high contact volume and it's taking us longer than usual to reply to emails. But let's get this resolved for you! :)

If for any reason you are not satisfied with your purchase, we do have a 30 day return/exchange policy. As mentioned in our previous email, our goal was to design a cutout that would enable users to easily access and use the Camera Control button, but wouldn’t be grotesquely large, especially given the slightly awkward placement of the button on the phone itself. The cutout was designed to work seamlessly and so functionality shouldn't be an issue here.

Looks like the order has been placed, and we really think you'll like it!
'especially given the slightly awkward placement of the button' What a lot of tosh! What is awkward? They are panicking. I may also add that I have ordered a Sheath for a 16 Pro Max but will never receive it before 20/9. How long have they had? They even got the specs from Apple. It's another epic fail from Caudabe, like last year.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: Phone Junky
'especially given the slightly awkward placement of the button' What a lot of tosh! What is awkward? They are panicking. I may also add that I have ordered a Sheath for a 16 Pro Max but will never receive it before 20/9. How long have they had? They even got the specs from Apple. It's another epic fail from Caudabe, like last year.
Yeah, you should go speak to the manager!
 
View attachment 2416969

I did it.

I am not proud I did it. I'm concerned about how well this case will work with the camera control button.

However...

The more I read and watch videos about Apple Silicone cases the more I see how quickly they become damaged or peel apart.

I suppose the worst that can happen is that the button doesn't work with the case and I return this.

I won't do Apple Silicone cases. They're terrible.

I put my order in last night for a Sheath, Synthesis, and a Paragon. There's a lot of sky is falling in this conversation, but it doesn't reflect my experience. Last year I was happy with my Caudabe cases (which I'm currently still using) and I have no concerns about the cutout this year either. There's no reason to have concerns if you can directly access the button.
 
  • Like
Reactions: justinf77
Same… The Camera Control button is supposed to be made out of sapphire, so I don’t think it will scratch easily.

I mean, my 12 Pro Sheath also has cutouts for the charging port, Mic and speakers, mute switch and also the cameras… No scratches there…

And the new cutout on the Sheath seems to be nicely wedged, so it should be easy to use…
I agree, sapphire glass is very strong and the button itself looks like it's recessed. All of the Caudabe cases have a reasonably sized cutout as far as I could tell. I'm sure they'll work fine. I made a last minute decision last night to upgrade and I picked up a Synthesis and Paragon after my preorder went through. Very excited about the phone and the cases. Same annual dopamine hit every time this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mgscheue
Wait a second, I ordered Synthesis Gray color for my 16 PM and their screen protector. It won’t be here by the 20th?!?! Even with express shipping?!?! I need them to be here since my phone will be here on 9/20!
 
Wait a second, I ordered Synthesis Gray color for my 16 PM and their screen protector. It won’t be here by the 20th?!?! Even with express shipping?!?! I need them to be here since my phone will be here on 9/20!
Well, I live in Europe so my sheath won‘t be here on the 20th, either… So I bit the bullet and also bought the cheapest Amazon case + Screen combo I could find, this should get me through the first couple of days…
 
Well, I live in Europe so my sheath won‘t be here on the 20th, either… So I bit the bullet and also bought the cheapest Amazon case + Screen combo I could find, this should get me through the first couple of days…
Might have to do that myself. That is some ******** if they are taking people money and don’t even have it right now. They clearly note a certain color is shipping later. Nothing about the others though.
 
'especially given the slightly awkward placement of the button' What a lot of tosh! What is awkward? They are panicking. I may also add that I have ordered a Sheath for a 16 Pro Max but will never receive it before 20/9. How long have they had? They even got the specs from Apple. It's another epic fail from Caudabe, like last year.
The button location is def awkward. It should have been further towards the bottom of the phone
 
I've never owned a Caudabe case but I know they are extremely popular here. What makes them special? also, If I were to get one, which of their series offers the most protection?
 
The button location is def awkward. It should have been further towards the bottom of the phone
I’m left-handed so have a different perspective on the button placement. I’m guessing it will be somewhat awkward for both left and right handers, but if it was lower my fingertips would fall directly on the button possibly causing all sorts of issues. I think they may have placed the button where they did to accommodate both left and right handers.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.