Yeah but this "bug" is a biggie because it revealed they weren't actually deleting photos they said they were deleting!
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Troubling iOS 17.5 Bug Reportedly Resurfacing Old Deleted Photos
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Apple and I have different definitions of "deleted" apparently
Very very concerning
Very very concerning
After I updated to 17.5, I received a push notification that "A device has been added to your account. An iPad now has access to FaceTime."
Sure enough a 2016 iPad Pro was added into my Devices in iCloud. An iPad that I handed over to Apple a year ago for recycling.
It creeped me out and I called Apple support. They are looking into it but assume it is a bug.
Sure enough a 2016 iPad Pro was added into my Devices in iCloud. An iPad that I handed over to Apple a year ago for recycling.
It creeped me out and I called Apple support. They are looking into it but assume it is a bug.
Probably kept in the "just in case Law enforcement asks" bin
But, of course, Apple is on "our side"
Yeah - right
That is illegal in most western countries, keeping photos from individuals when that individual has requested deletion
I would agree!
But I also would not be surprised if law enforcement is getting lots of access to things, and using methods, that are "illegal" also
So that’s how you’ll explain those NSFW pictures to your wife 
I have had it with Apple software team lack of quality and innovation for years now but this is on a totally different scale.
Without that crap quality we'd never know that Apple was secretly still keeping files.
Possibly in the USA, however in the UK (where I live) and EU the relevant agencies have nowhere near the power and influence of what the NSA, CIA etc. does in the US, and have more democratic civilian oversight. It wouldn't be allowed.
How for the gods sake deleted photos can even resurface again? It smells so fishy! A new ad slogan:
What happens with iPhone, stays on iPhone (forever)
What happens with iPhone, stays on iPhone (forever)
I really want to hear the explanation for why photos that were requested for deletion are still around … years later
On device, cloud, etc..
All irrelevant… They should be purged everywhere by that point
Why are they not?
On device, cloud, etc..
All irrelevant… They should be purged everywhere by that point
Why are they not?
You're being facetious I assume, but there is a legit potential issue that can come from this.So that’s how you’ll explain those NSFW pictures to your wife
What if pics of an ex from years ago do show in recent photos? It can lead to big issues.
Sure anyone checking the phone of a partner likely already has trust issues with them, but the point remains.
Second that. I take a screenshot, send it and then delete it. Now I've got a couple back thinking, "hmmm, did I miss deleting them?". Not too old though so they were probably in the "Recently Deleted" album (which is protected by FaceID, but clearly that isn't enough).
Make good training input for Siri's ML algos? I mean, who will miss them?
I have a very jealous girlfriend. If all the deleted porn that I watched over several years comes up, I won’t live... 😭😱
😭😱Are there ANY reports of this happening if someone has icloud backup turned off?
If so, I agree this is a major issue and can’t be explained away by a sync bug. If not, the explanation given is plausible but still bad.
If this is the case Macrumors and other media outlets should make this a front page story, with precisely this information. The subtle distinction here is extremely important because in one case they have a bad bug, in another case they aren’t doing what they say they are with our data.
A merge conflict is explainable only if there is data there to be merged back, e.g. from an old backup. This is vital to understand and should be a priority for anyone reporting on this further. And it’s only justifiably explainable (but again, still bad) if the data being merged back into the library is from an icloud backup.
This should have nothing to do with icloud photo library, give how the software works. I hope we get more information about this specific detail.
I'm starting to believe that anything we do is on the net somewhere. Someone or something is hoarding all our data.
Somewhere just outside Denver for one.
And if you read my post instead of just quoting it, you would see I’m agreeing with you. However, the article calls it a bug in 17.5 and comments call it a recent failure of QA.
I am uninterested in spinning this, only in honesty in how the presence of supposedly deleted photo data is handled.
This is not a 17.5 bug. The article needs updating so the focus is where it should be.
Last edited:
This needs a major investigation. It’s really making me think Apple is no better than Google.
"Why should I trust them, they gave me MobileMe"
TBH it seems to be pretty much every product and every software release with Timmy at the helm
You're continuing to focus on the wrong thing.
What matters is deleted photos resurfaced meaning they weren't deleted.
Nothing Else Matters.