Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Interesting guide. Not sure where you came up with that, but it seems like it is actually a pretty accurate guide, at least for my wrist.
I'm a fashion stylist for one of my jobs. So it's my job to come up with ways to explain what looks good. Explaining complicated stuff into layman's terms. I just looked for something that everyone has to compare and have a sure fire way to get a idea across.

Why makes you believe a credit card is the right barometer?
It's not. To my knowledge my Credit Cards can't tell atmospheric pressure :p

I know some people will go with 42mm for the screen size but that doesn't mean it won't look huge on them not only due to wrist width but the watch height.
Hey when it comes to fashion. Fashion is fashion. If you've got the confidence why not!?

This guide is excellent. Im somewhere between A and B and 38 looked better on me in the store.
I'm glad that you found this excellent. Was every bit of my intentions! So you chose to have a "watch" look rather than the "Over sized Smart Watch" look. But for me I still am upset that it's not a large screen. But hey.... Coming from a Pebble watch, I think it's time for a change .
 
Thanks for the guide! I'm a B! Ordered a 42mm :)
I'm still worried it my look ridiculous on my wrist but I was told my current watch looks big and the 42mm is smaller.
 
Useful guide as everyone has a card to hand... I'm right on borderline but going to go with 38mm as I don't want it to stand out too much
 
Interesting guide. Not sure where you came up with that, but it seems like it is actually a pretty accurate guide, at least for my wrist.

A credit card is about 54mm in width. It's an ingenious idea.

----------

For those of you that have not preorder or still having some doubts on what size you should get. Listen up! ......

Awesome idea- thanks for sharing. I see that so much on here- about circumference rather than width. Glad I measured both before preordering at 2am 10 Apr.
 
Interesting. I have a really tiny wrist, I ordered the 38m. I have the Samsung gear and it swallows my wrist!!
 
Quite a nice guide. I'm a B, and as I've realised I can either go 38 or 42... I don't want anything big or standing out too much, but I definitely want the smartwatch look. I guess I'll go 42mm!
 
I would HIGHLY recommend going to try one on. I didn't even have a reservation, just walked in and was able to try them on last night.

I have a small wrist. Using the credit card example here, looking straight down, my wrist is just barely visible on either side of the card.

But when I tried on the 38mm, it just looked too small, it looked like I was wearing a ladies' watch.

The 42mm looked great....it looked right. It may be trending a little large but it did not look odd. It looked and felt right.

YMMV, though, so, again, you should really try them out in the store. I had already pre-ordered a 42mm, so this made me feel better about my purchase.
 
Thanks OP!

Great way to look at it. I think the fact the watch case is more rectangular is a factor as well compared to a 38 or 42mm round one.
 
If you are B and go with the 38mm you can definitely tell that the watch doesn't fill up your wrist, but it won't look odd to anyone else. 42mm may be the way to go but make sure it's not too big!
 
If you are B and go with the 38mm you can definitely tell that the watch doesn't fill up your wrist, but it won't look odd to anyone else. 42mm may be the way to go but make sure it's not too big!

This^

As soon as I tried on the 38mm I thought "wow its tiny", but after having a few pictures taken and looking at them afterwards, from the outside perspective it looks like a perfect fit.
 
I'm type A and tried the 42mm on. It looks amazing and was the perfect size (still smaller than my wrist). So this guide is ********.

Calm down. If you like it, then get that size. To some, including myself, it looks silly/dorky to have a watch that dominates your wrist, but to others maybe the 38mm on my 180mm wrist looks silly:

9t2V9KK.jpg
 
Sorry, but your guide is terrible. I'm a C and 38mm is perfect for me. 42mm look way to big and geeky.

P.S. I usually wear 35-37mm dress watches and 38-40 sport watches.
 
I wouldn't listen to this guide

Why is this a sticky? The rule of thumb is if you're a man get 42mm, women 38mm. Then if you're still confused go to the Apple Store.
 
Thanks for posting this, OP. I had sort of assumed it 42mm = male, 38mm = female, but that's not really true. And I have small wrists and hands for a guy, so I'm leaning toward the 38mm now whereas before I had not even considered it. Thanks!
 
Sorry, but your guide is terrible. I'm a C and 38mm is perfect for me. 42mm look way to big and geeky.

P.S. I usually wear 35-37mm dress watches and 38-40 sport watches.

Exactly. The 38mm seems to wear like most analogue watches in the 35-40mm range, whereas the 42mm looks oversized in the large majority of wrist shots that I've seen. Since these watches are all "dial" (screen) they wear large on the wrist.

The thing is, some buy the oversized, 46mm+ watches at Macy's and are happy with them, while others spend $50K on a Patek that's only 36mm. I've always leaned toward the classic side of the scale, like your measurements indicate, and I'm not a small man. All of my watches are 35-40mm, too.

The other thing about the 38mm being so nice and small is that it doesn't immediately scream smartwatch.
 
Exactly. The 38mm seems to wear like most analogue watches in the 35-40mm range, whereas the 42mm looks oversized in the large majority of wrist shots that I've seen. Since these watches are all "dial" (screen) they wear large on the wrist.

The thing is, some buy the oversized, 46mm+ watches at Macy's and are happy with them, while others spend $50K on a Patek that's only 36mm. I've always leaned toward the classic side of the scale, like your measurements indicate, and I'm not a small man. All of my watches are 35-40mm, too.

The other thing about the 38mm being so nice and small is that it doesn't immediately scream smartwatch.

Sorry to say, wrist shots are meaningless. You have to try one on to be sure. The 42mm does not look big in person at all. It looks normal size. The 38mm definitely looks small no matter what your wrist size. Try them on and decide for yourself.
 
Im B, where my wrist is just about even with the card.

Ive tried on boh the 42 and 38.

Even the 42 looks small to me in person. It looks huge in the pics i took, but in person looked surprisingly small.

I dont think this watch will look oversized on anyone but anorexics and prepubescent girls.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.