Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Well if this is the best that comes from Apple’s meticulous review farming, I won’t be the least bit surprised if all the unbridled reviewers absolutely decimate the Vision Pro.
Representatives of three of the biggest independent VR news/reviews sites tried it at the launch event and were very impressed.
I think the area that will disappoint them is the lack of content/apps to actually use on the device.
 
Yeah, the real write-off is the stock strap. Kind of damning honestly that they had to waffle back and forth on two strap designs - one that looks great in promo and one that works better for actual comfort.
Yeah, the original strap design looks like a fancy knit running shoe from Nike, especially with the bright orange pull tab thing.

Most of the negativity in these impressions articles is focused on comfort. The AVP is very similar in size to the Quest 3, and despite its external battery, probably not much lighter, if at all.
All VR headsets have complaints about comfort, especially when they don't have a rigid strap design. So nothing in these impressions articles is unexpected.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sphark
It’s amazing how many people spend so much time here discussing and arguing that they are just not interested in this device and how this is going nowhere fast and how Apple really screwed up with this one. It’s amazing because whrn I’m not interested in something I quickly ignore it and move on lol. Not here they spend all day explaining emphatically on how they are just not interested… lmao!
 
One thing that is missing here is what apps are all those innovative devs that attended WWDC building for this thing that they actually think they can monetize?
 
It’s amazing how many people spend so much time here discussing and arguing that they are just not interested in this device and how this is going nowhere fast and how Apple really screwed up with this one. It’s amazing because whrn I’m not interested in something I quickly ignore it and move on lol. Not here they spend all day explaining emphatically on how they are just not interested… lmao!
Even funnier when they whine about how antisocial the AVP is, and how you should go outside and experience the real world, yet they have thousands of posts on a nerdy forum about unreleased tech gadgets.
I somehow doubt they are posting here as a shared activity with their spouse/friend while on a hike through the woods.
 
Well if this is the best that comes from Apple’s meticulous review farming, I won’t be the least bit surprised if all the unbridled reviewers absolutely decimate the Vision Pro.
With Apple we never hear the cons, it always about this can replace your devices, or so they claim. The more Apple products you own, the more challenged you would be to go out and get one for its feature set IMHO. The reviewers are all of that category, they use a lot of Apple and other gear.

So as the Verge reviewer said, "I’m just still trying to see where it fits in the real world." If that decision of value against a new product platform is difficult, imagine someone far less knowledgeable of a perspective considering buying a $3500 device for business or entertainment instead of other solutions out there? I look forward to many other reviews that will be helpful to that question. ;)
 
All VR headsets have complaints about comfort, especially when they don't have a rigid strap design. So nothing in these impressions articles is unexpected.

So excuses are already being made? Thought it was "Apple comes to market later than the competition, but always improves upon the things their competitors got wrong..." What happened to that?

I would fully expect Apple to overcome the top complaint for "All VR headsets". If they cannot, then the only discernible difference between AVP and the others is the Apple logo and the walled garden. Sure, there may be other notable refinements, but they don't do much good if the user can't stand to wear the thing.

Guess the short battery life is a blessing. No one will want to wear it longer than the battery will last anyway.
 
So excuses are already being made? Thought it was "Apple comes to market later than the competition, but always improves upon the things their competitors got wrong..." What happened to that?
I never said that, but I think they are improving on some of the things competitors got wrong.

And having multiple light shield options will allow better comfort for some people. I have a Valve Index, and I find that the face pad on it is too wide, which makes it less comfortable than it could be. The HTC Vive I used before that came with two face pads: a wide and a narrow, and the narrow one was a better fit for my face. Even having just two options was an better for me.

But at this point it just comes down to simple physics and compromise. There's own so much you can do when the technology requires a certain amount of weight at this point in time. There are smaller headsets, but they all compromise in areas that Apple didn't with the AVP.

If reviewers say that the Vision Pro has worse UI than competitors, I definitely won't excuse that.
 
So excuses are already being made? Thought it was "Apple comes to market later than the competition, but always improves upon the things their competitors got wrong..." What happened to that?

I would fully expect Apple to overcome the top complaint for "All VR headsets". If they cannot, then the only discernible difference between AVP and the others is the Apple logo and the walled garden. Sure, there may be other notable refinements, but they don't do much good if the user can't stand to wear the thing.

Guess the short battery life is a blessing. No one will want to wear it longer than the battery will last anyway.
They hate it because they ain’t it!
 
AVP screams gen 1 product. The headset weight, battery, software (keyboard), third party app support, and price.

Count me in 5 years from now when all the above are thoroughly resolved.
 
  • Like
Reactions: arkitect
The front eye screen says it all.

Someone must have actually forced this through the pipeline, cuz.....

Makes the Touch Bar seem incredibly clever.
Truly a “how stoned are you?” moment.
I would say most of the negative was nitpicky - "I was in pain" - because my long hair was pinching and I didn't ask to change the strap as it slid down my hair - that is filled with glossy hair product.

"The keyboard was hard to use" but if you read the full review, she was doing the pinch gesture wrong.....

Even the comment about "I felt excluded too..." in the full review ends with her in tears about how special that type of recording will be with her own kids when they are grown.

Some of this was MR quoting very poorly too.
So you’re saying it’s non-intuitive and forces the user to conform to the technology? Seems “Windows-ish.”
 
  • Like
Reactions: arkitect
Reference
I felt the beginnings of a mild headache. That tension dissipated as soon as I took the headset off
I wonder how prevalent the verge reviewer observation will be when Apple starts to demo them in stores?

The eye movements that seem to control how you see things while using Vision Pro, or the per eye frame rate with video (light flashes), or brightness sensitivity with displays very close to the eyes has not been long termed looked at yet? It's not like you can look away quickly wearing a AVP.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.