Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I threw 3 divx/xvid files on there and A/B'd with cinexplayer I've been using. VLC lost all three times (2 animation and a live action).

I love VLC on the mac but it plays this is substandard. I'll continue using Cinex...

Signed up on MacRumors just to post this?

RIGHT. That's not obvious at all.
 
why are you guys so excited over this?! any file that i paid for i can already play on my iPad EASILY (thur conversion or iTune). it's those files that I downloaded that I need this player for, such as divx, wmv, and MKV. If this player doesn't play them, WHAT IS THE POINT?

There are a number of us who have huge files in other formats the Touch, and iPad will not play without converting them. Yes I can convert them and for those of you with PC's the dBpower Amp Batch Converter is a fantastic way of converting large numbers of audio files to what a iPod/iPad will play as for videos I have used Any Video Converter (http://www.any-video-converter.com/products/for_video/) for years they have a version for the PC and Apple ( both PPC, and Intel based) But when you have several terabytes of such files it gets to be a royal PIA to convert such large numbers of files, not too mention the space taken up by the duplicate files. There is also the fact there are some codexs such as Flac, and Ape that are lossless and are the codex of choice for maximum fidelity.
 
The reason I'm interested in VLC is that I thought I could use it as a front end for my MythTV system. In the UK digital TV is broadcast as unencrypted MPEG2 data. VLC on the desktop can play this back without any transcoding being necessary, I had hoped that VLC on the iPad would also be able to. Unfortunately it looks like I will have to wait to see if they add the features I need later.

That was my hope as well. Neither CineXPlayer nor VLC can play the .mpg files that my hardware encoding video capture card outputs. OPlayerHD Lite does, but has a banner add across the top of the screen. If no new version of CineX or VLC comes out I'll have to verify that the audio/video out-of-sync issue mentioned in OPlayerHD reviews won't affect my MythTV content and that the paid version removes the banner and then just go with that instead.

Edit: The audio out-of-sync issue is there, so I would need a newer version even for OPlayerHD.
 
Normal MKV 480p H264 won't play either, at least properly. Could a future update fix this? For now, back to Airplay. :(
 
I downloaded it and .... I was waiting for something usable as opening a video attachment in my Mail app right in my iPad. I use a combination of iFile and oPlayer that work excellent but it need a jailbreaked iPad. I need a non jailbreak option to be able to use iOS as it needed to be. And VLC did not fill that gab yet.
 
the worst player i've ever seen

why apple approves such useless apps?

it even doesn't recognize the files i uploaded to it's folder via itunes

after a week of waiting for it, absolute disappointment :mad:

hell

The worst comment I have ever read

Why does god make such useless people?

It even doesn't understand when it gets something for free via itunes

after years of reading comments on this board, absolute disappointment :confused:

heaven's
 
I like how people come up with there excuses of why they want this app!!
lets be honest, its the easiest way to get downloaded content from the web on to the ipad, say no more :cool:
 
Extremely bad video quality

I care about file-types but what about the bad video quality. Am I the only one to have found this? You don't need a trained eye to see the really bad image quality. Just see the comparison I made. Total disappointment.
 

Attachments

  • compare_vlc_quality.jpg
    compare_vlc_quality.jpg
    93.5 KB · Views: 142
I kind of get the impression that this doesn't work right under iOS 4.2. Nothing but black screens on EVERY format I've tried, even h.264 files that are natively supported by the operating system.

I get sound, but no picture.
 
This made my day and I still give it 5 stars for even getting approved, but really what is the point?

I've tried to play 25 different Matroska files only to have VLC crash out completely on 21 of them and play a black screen in the other 4. This was let out of the development lab way too early and needs a lot of additional work.

Good for free, but not very good overall.
 
I kind of get the impression that this doesn't work right under iOS 4.2. Nothing but black screens on EVERY format I've tried, even h.264 files that are natively supported by the operating system.

I get sound, but no picture.

ditto.
 
I kind of get the impression that this doesn't work right under iOS 4.2. Nothing but black screens on EVERY format I've tried, even h.264 files that are natively supported by the operating system.

I get sound, but no picture.


defo does not work right on 4.2, shame
 
I applaud the effort, but of the 10 .avi files that I tried, none of them play smoothly. .mkv did not work either.
Sadly, this is still the best player out there currently for the ipad.
An outdated windows mobile pocket pc plays files better currently.

On the desktop, if VLC won't play it, I find another video to play. I don't even bother to try to find a codec b/c I assume that it's the encoder's fault. It would be nice if the ipad/ipod could do the same thing....5 years after its release. One of the reasons to go with Android.
 
too bad it doesn't work. i only use vlc to play files i cant normally play. so far, nothing works.
 
Why would I want VLC?

I gather it plays non-Apple video formats. Um, why would I want those? Please spell it out for me. I really have no idea why this is such exciting news for the rest of you.

Because it can play pretty much any video or audio format you throw at it? (Not all of us have exclusively iTunes/Apple content.) It's really great on your desktop for those random file formats you may occasionally encounter on the Web (and for some weird things you'd rather not keep on hand, like RealPlayer or Windows Media/Flip4Mac), but it can also play downloaded Flash videos and other formats, even some corrupted ones that other programs can't handle.

Basically, it can do everything you ever wanted and so much more.

However, posts on here seem to indicate that the iPad version is lacking some of this functionality, so it might be less exciting on iPad at the moment. Hopefully, they are working on bringing it up to par.
 
Signed up on MacRumors just to post this?

RIGHT. That's not obvious at all.

Obvious that I like what I've been using and feel VLC isn't as good? Yep. That's obvious! Cinex is free if that's what you are talking about... The Klexi guy is pushing that and it's $5. Just because I just signed up, doesn't mean I'm shady, dude. Jaded much?

Whoops had to edit this because "I" downloaded it for free on August 12th... Seems to have gone up in price since then...
 
It's just a big fat phone, what do you expect?


I'm not even going to try this. I don't have enough hair to start pulling it out
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.